City planners, and eventually the City Council, have a number of issues to weigh before deciding on the best place for a new transit maintenance facility.
“Transit maintenance facility” is a fancy name for a bus yard, where the city’s fleet of Santa Clarita Transit buses will be housed, serviced, washed and fueled.
So far the city has considered three locations for the facility— on Ruether Avenue, Rye Canyon Road and at Porta Bella. One of the three, the Porta Bella site, has apparently been dismissed out of hand because it could be years before the property is cleared of contaminants and deemed safe by the state.
Another location, the Ruether Avenue site, has engendered quite a bit of opposition from folks who are upset that Canyon Country often seems to get the short end of the stick.
Take the homeless shelter as the latest example. It is proper for the city to want to meet the needs of those who have no other way to avoid the ravages of winter, but the city should have tried harder to find a location that would not impact existing retail stores or residents.
It’s difficult to argue, however, that the proposed Ruether site is really “in” Canyon Country. It’s in that no-man ’s land in the center of the city that isn’t truly Canyon Country or Saugus. In fact, the facility would be next to John Paul Mitchell Systems, which lists its address as Saugus.
But that’s not the point. Whether Canyon Country or Saugus, there are some new tracts of homes that are about 400 feet from the Ruether site and could bear the burden of added noise, exhaust and traffic, all day and most of the night, seven days a week.
The Ruether area is designated for a business park in the city’s General Plan, which was adopted almost 10 years ago. One could argue that the new homeowners in the area should have known, before purchasing their homes, that something would be built on the property one day. But it must also be noted that a bus yard does not exactly match the zoning for the area. A bus yard would need a minor use permit, because it doesn’t quite fall under the same category as a business park. Almost, but not quite.
On the other hand, if you consider the cost— and after all, your tax dollars are building the $16.5 million first phase, which will accommodate the city’s bus needs for the next 10 years— then the Ruether site deserves another look.
Ruether would cost the city $6.3 million for 14 acres of land. Rye Canyon would cost the city $5.125 million for 12 acres.
The 14 acres at Ruether would give the facility room to grow— something it would need to do in another decade. With 12 acres at Rye Canyon, it would be a tight squeeze, city officials say— possibly forcing the city to purchase a second piece of land elsewhere.
Also, the Ruether site is close to the center of the city, and transportation officials estimate they would save $100,000 a year in fuel costs if the buses don’t have to make the daily trek to Rye Canyon in the Valencia Industrial Center.
There is no dispute that a proper transit maintenance facility is needed. The buses are housed in a facility in the Valencia Industrial Center right now with no fueling capability— they’re fueled by outside vendors at four different locations. The ability to fuel buses at the new bus yard will save the city $1 million a year.
The city is taking the right step by listening to neighbors of the Ruether site. Hopefully a compromise can be reached that will satisfy new homeowners in the area and save the rest of Santa Clarita a few tax dollars.
