It came as a surprise to both sides when the Santa Clarita Planning Commission, on a 4-1 vote, rejected a conditional use permit that The Master’s College would have needed to build a 1, 200-seat chapel and performing arts center in Placerita Canyon.
Perhaps the shock value would have been lessened if all involved had thought of the proposal the way the city must view it. No matter who the players are in a development proposal, be it a residential builder or a Bible college, our city government is legally bound to view the project on its merits.
‘Hopefully the rift between the college and its neighbors has not grown so wide that there is no chance for meaningful dialogue.’
Despite the opinions of several people who departed the City Council chambers dumbfounded Tuesday night, the denial of the permit was not somehow sacrilegious or some sort of religious persecution.
City government is not a perfect system, and ours certainly does not always act as if it had divine inspiration. Instead it must necessarily work within the bounds of imperfect laws created by man.
It’s great that The Master’s College has grown to a point where it needs new facilities to meet current needs. The college does good work and has been a fairly decent neighbor, over the years, to those with whom it shares a small canyon in Newhall.
But Placerita Canyon, like Sand Canyon, has a “special standards overlay,” a set of unique planning codes designed to protect the rural nature of the canyon. In creating these special standards, the city and the canyon residents determined that Placerita Canyon is a special place that should not be overdeveloped.
Which is not to say building can’t happen in the canyon. It does happen, but usually in a manner consistent with the special standards that call for ranch-style homes to be constructed on large lots.
Placerita Canyon residents who oppose the college’s plans for a 1, 200-seat auditorium contend that it would grossly violate the special standards.
If the city allows a developer— again, be it The Master’s College, The Newhall Land and Farming Co. or the Porta Bella people— to violate special planning codes, then what good is having the special codes in the first place?
Robert Hotten, vice president of operations for the college, said after Tuesday’s denial that the “building size can easily be mitigated.” It isn’t yet clear what that means. Hopefully it signals an intent for the college to do the right thing— the same thing other developers do when they wish to gain community support for a project: They hold meetings in the neighborhood, establish dialogue and solicit ideas from those who stand to be impacted the most. If the college has already met with neighbors, it needs to do so again, and it needs to listen.
Hopefully it is not too late. Hopefully the rift between the college and its neighbors has not grown so wide that there is no chance for meaningful dialogue. Everyone should take this opportunity— this “breather” ordained by the Planning Commission— to get together and figure out what will work for the college and other canyon residents, all of whom have an equal stake in their neighborhood and a vested interest in its future.
We haven’t heard the college say where it plans to grow in the years ahead. It is difficult to imagine the college growing much more and staying entirely within Placerita Canyon. Perhaps the college will decide that satellite campuses and facilities are the way to go, much like UCLA and CSUN and Pepperdine have done, and establish multiple sites in different parts of Santa Clarita.
It’s not a far-fetched idea. College President John MacArthur already delivers a Sunday sermon over nationwide Christian radio from a facility in the Valencia Industrial Center.
The college could show good “faith” by going back to the drawing board and planning the auditorium on the 40 acres the college already owns on the south side of the hill, away from Placerita Canyon.
In any event, where and how the college will grow is something that must involve the community, and ultimately will have to yield to the imperfect— though in this case correct— decisions of our governmental leaders.
