What a difference a handful of votes can make. In the Newhall County Water District, just over 200 ballots separated the top and bottom vote-getters out of a field of four, with challenger Joan Dunn ousting one-term incumbent Valerie Thomas.
‘Given the personalities and philosophies on the NCWD board, we’re more likely to see 2-2 split decisions, with the fifth board member casting the deciding vote on growth-related issues.’
All four candidates— three incumbents and Dunn— garnered roughly the same support, yet the meager margin changed more than just a face: It changed the makeup of the board from what some perceive as a pro-growth majority to one that’s less likely to accommodate growth.
We don’t necessarily adhere to the notion that the prior majority was “ pro-growth ” or that the new majority is “ anti-growth .” That’s an oversimplification. But the fact is, given the personalities and philosophies on the NCWD board, we’re more likely to see 2-2 split decisions, with the fifth board member casting the deciding vote on growth-related issues.
Here’s why it’s important. As we’ve noted several times in recent months, the state Legislature and the courts are giving water utilities much more influence over matters of growth than they’ve had in the past. Under the “old” rules, when a city or county agency approved development, it was essentially the job of a water utility to go out and find enough water to serve the project.
Under the new laws that will soon take effect, cities and counties must prove there is enough water before giving the go-ahead to large housing projects. And how do they “prove” it? They rely on information provided by the water utilities.
The burden will be on the water utilities to investigate water supplies and availability more rigorously than ever before. The Legislature is making the utilities responsible for predicting how much water there will be in the future, and whether it will be sufficient to serve a growing population.
Most members of the so-called “water community” have taken the tact that their job is to safeguard the water supply and, if more is needed to serve new development, to go out and find it. With major development on the horizon for the Santa Clarita Valley, the Castaic Lake Water Agency has taken several steps to ensure the new growth doesn’t suck us dry; for instance, it has supplemented its future supplies by acquiring rights to water allotments in other areas.
But what if our water boards are stacked with people who would rather stop growth than accommodate it? Rather than figuring out how to make a housing project work without burdening existing residents, a slow-growth water board might simply choose to use its new legislative mandate to say, “No, sorry, there isn’t enough water for your development.”
This year’s NCWD board President, Randall Pfiester, is a past member of the CLWA board, and the NCWD’s Barbara Dore is the district’s representative on that board. Both are quite in tune with the philosophy of the water community when it comes to the need for an ample water supply for current and future residents.
Val Thomas was of the same ilk, but now she’s out, replaced by Dunn, who does not march in lock-step with the water community by any stretch of the imagination. In fact, Dunn and another NCWD board member, Lynne Plambeck, were two of the four individuals who sued the CLWA over its ownership of another water utility, the Santa Clarita Water Co., and both are outspoken critics of new development. They tend to view new residential growth as a threat to the Santa Clara River— our valley’s chief source of groundwater.
With Pfiester and Dore on one bank of the river and Dunn and Plambeck on the other, all eyes will be on the tie-breaker — Dick Unger, a retired engineer with a sharp analytical mind and a keen interest in protecting the interests of the agency and its rate payers.
Don’t expect to see this new NCWD board be anyone’s rubber stamp. Expect fireworks and, quite possibly, some well-thought-out initiatives that cut across philosophical lines. And don’t let anyone tell you a few votes don’t count.
