It didn't take long after the Valencia Town Center mall opened in 1992 for the queries to start being made:
When are we going to get a Nordstrom?
It seemed that whenever groups of Santa Claritans would get together to brainstorm about local needs, Nordstrom would end up on the list — at or near the top — and would be there by name, not some generic reference to a desire for an upscale department store.
Officials of The Newhall Land and Farming Co., which developed the mall and the Valencia communities that surround it, have always quietly acknowledged that they were "working on it," then smiled and nudged as if to say, "Don't worry. It'll happen. Fairly soon."
Now, the quiet nudging has become a little more public: The developer and the city of Santa Clarita acknowledged this week that they are in the early stages of discussions of a deal that could bring the high-end chain into the Valencia mall, as part of an ongoing expansion of the retail offerings in and around Valencia Town Center.
It also became evident that the latest city research shows Nordstrom may not even be at the top of Santa Claritans' wish list anymore, but the fact remains that Santa Claritans have long desired a Nordstrom for the local mall, and even if it has dropped a few notches on the list, Santa Claritans still covet a high-end store of the Nordstrom genre. And since Nordstrom is the one seated at the bargaining table, let's go from there:
The details have yet to be agreed upon or fully determined, but what has become clear is that there is a price tag associated with that shiny new upscale store.
And the price is $20 million.
That's a lot of sweaters and scarves, but that's the way the retail game is played these days: The big guns want a guarantee that a new store will be profitable, and what better way to get such a guarantee than to demand cash up front? If they don't get it, they walk away.
The current thinking is that, to lure Nordstrom here, Newhall Land would front the $20 million and the incentive would be reimbursed to the developer via a percentage — perhaps as high as 85 percent — of all new mall sales tax revenue generated by the store.
In other words, the city would be guaranteed that there would be no reduction in its sales tax revenue.
All of this raises the question: Should we be paying national chains for blessing us with their company?
Intuitively, one would want to say no. But this is, unfortunately, the way business is done today. Similar packages have been put together, for example, to bring retailers like the Price Club and Home Depot to Santa Clarita. In a sense, one could call it corporate welfare; but communities that want these new amenities are between a rock and a hard place.
We can have a Nordstrom or we can not have a Nordstrom. The choice is up to Santa Clarita: Are we willing to pay the price? And if we don't, which of our neighbors will?
On the surface, $20 million seems hefty, but it's important to remember that the incentive will be paid for by revenue that would not be generated without the presence of Nordstrom. Hence, the city would not actually be losing anything.
With that, we endorse the concept of luring an upscale retailer to Santa Clarita. But there are a few caveats. One: If there is to be any risk assumed, it shall be assumed by Newhall Land, not the city. Developer officials assure us this will be the case, so this does not appear to be a stumbling block. And two: Before any deal is finalized, the city, Newhall Land and Nordstrom shall produce hard data from previous new store openings that demonstrate the likelihood that Nordstrom will in fact increase the mall's sales tax revenue. Anecdotal accounts won't suffice.
All of this talk is exciting; it doesn't seem long ago that the mall opened — and the community had waited for its own regional mall for the better part of two decades. Now, a scant six years into the mall's life, the area surrounding it is bustling with new commercial development, like Town Center Drive and the new Hyatt hotel, and we're hearing loud noises about the possibility of a major new retailer coming to town.
So long as the city is indemnified against any fiscal harm, Nordstrom would make a nice addition to the local retail mix — and even if that doesn't work out, Newhall Land could always give Macy's or Bloomingdale's a jingle.
Let the shopping begin.
* * *
The Signal's opinion is always labeled "Editorial." All other views express individual opinions and are not necessarily those of The Signal or The-Signal.com.
