When a government decision is made that won't be enacted until a decade later, it's pretty easy to procrastinate when it comes to things like complying with new regulations.
Witness the city's sign ordinance.
Adopted by the City Council in 1990, the sign ordinance replaced the former county sign ordinance with a more restrictive code. As a result of concerns raised at the time by the local business community, enforcement of the ordinance was delayed until Nov. 13, 1999, with respect to previously existing signs.
Goodness, how time flies. Here it is, almost a decade later, and for much of that ensuing time, the city's sign ordinance has been a non-issue. But the hour of enforcement is approaching, and it understandably has many business owners worried.
Signs can be expensive. And replacing an existing sign can be a costly proposition, especially for a small "mom and pop" business (a typical storefront business could be looking at a $2,000 tab if it has to replace a sign). That was one of the big reasons the City Council included an amortization period in the first place: To give local businesses time to not only plan compliance with the ordinance, but also to get some use out of their existing signs. That was a wise move, given the fact that it's estimated that 65 to 75 percent of pre-1990 signs will have to be replaced.
Time is almost up. Recognizing that local businesses would develop an increasing sense of urgency about the issue as the amortization period wound down, the city in 1996 appointed a task force to advise the city about the transition and to ensure that businesses' questions and concerns about the ordinance are addressed and taken into account.
That has resulted in a series of recommended revisions to the sign ordinance that are scheduled tonight to be considered by the city Planning Commission.
The city is in something of an awkward position. Some of the provisions of the ordinance adopted in 1990 seem excessively restrictive, and perhaps ought to be modified. However, if the city were to significantly back down from its sign ordinance, it would — understandably — receive complaints from some businesses that have been working to comply with the new requirements and have invested capital in new signage.
One can almost envision City Hall being positioned smack dab in the middle of two signs: one that reads "Rock," and another that reads, "Hard Place."
But some of the provisions of the ordinance do seem onerous, and some of the revisions going before the Planning Commission make sense.
For example, the ordinance as written does not allow square monument signs.
That is, it states that all monument signs are to be rectangular. No squares.
Perhaps, at the time of the ordinance's writing, that seemed to make sense to the authors. But any legitimate purpose in banning square signs escapes all reason nine years later. So that one is easy: The city ought to welcome square signs as well as rectangular ones. (Do we hear any clamor for circles and triangles, too?)
Other revisions also seem reasonable. For example, the city is considering the revocation of a strict height limitation and replacing it with a case-by-case review process. Similarly, a review process is being considered for scenic murals that may otherwise be outlawed. Also being considered are new rules allowing the placement of temporary signs for limited-time functions.
In addition, parts of the ordinance are being rewritten to make it more user-friendly, and a matrix is being developed to act as a guideline for business owners to help them understand the ordinance's provisions.
It's too late, really, for the city to completely scrap the sign ordinance and start anew, because if nothing else that would be unfair to those businesses that have been investing time and money into compliance. However, the city seems focused on making the sign ordinance more business-friendly than it was when written in 1990, and that, if you'll pardon the expression, is a positive sign.
* * *
The Signal's opinion is always labeled "Editorial." All other views express individual opinions and are not necessarily those of The Signal or The-Signal.com.
