What was the big rush?
Obviously, Los Angeles County ought to be processing the Newhall Ranch proposal in a timely manner — but given the fact that the development is being planned on a timeline of decades as opposed to months or even years, it seemed odd last week that it went before the Santa Clarita City Council as an "emergency" item.
The issue before the council last week was a 14-point compromise proposal that had been reached several days earlier in a meeting of officials from the city, county, Santa Monica Mountains Conservancy and the developer, The Newhall Land and Farming Co.
The rush job irked some observers, and resulted in misinformation winding its way through the rumor mill; some citizens after the meeting even had the mistaken impression that the council had formally lifted its opposition to Newhall Ranch in favor of a position of neutrality, without offering the public an opportunity to have input.
There indeed was no advance notice for the public, but the council, in fact, only reached a consensus on a series of compromise points, and did not formally adopt an overall position of neutrality on the proposed 70,000-resident community to the west.
The compromise proposal had not been finalized in time to be placed on the City Council agenda, and council members did not receive the material for evaluation until the morning of the Nov. 10 council meeting. County officials wanted the council to review the compromise — and, hopefully, endorse it — in time to allow it to be presented at the county Board of Supervisors' next hearing on the project, scheduled next Tuesday.
Thus, a controversial item like the city's possible endorsement of the 24,000-home Newhall Ranch project was placed on the council agenda as an "emergency" item, a move that required a four-fifths vote of the council.
Obviously, the county ought to move through its hearing process in a timely manner. And, the city actually has no real authority over the project, since it is outside city limits. But Newhall Ranch will, no doubt, have effects on the city — and compromises should be put forth in a public forum with adequate notice to the community.
In the end, it appears the council handled the item appropriately; most of the compromise dealt with the so-called "High Country," a significant portion of the Newhall Ranch site west of Interstate 5 that is to be dedicated as open space accessible to the public.
There has been significant debate about the High Country — including questions about which entity should manage it and at what point in the development process the land should be dedicated for public use.
On the surface, the compromise itself appears to be an improvement over the old plan, in which Newhall Land planned to dedicate the property to a private, non-profit land management organization. Under the compromise, the High Country would be dedicated to a joint powers authority that would include representatives of the county, city, Newhall Land, the Santa Monica Mountains Conservancy and the Center for Natural Lands Management.
The city wisely refrained from adopting the 13th point of the 14-point plan, which stated that the city would officially adopt a neutral position on Newhall Ranch, thus lifting the position previously adopted by the council — that the city opposes Newhall Ranch as it currently stands.
It may become warranted for the city to lift its official opposition, but it would have been extremely bad form for the council to do so in a meeting in which Newhall Ranch wasn't even on the posted agenda.
After all, a two-decade, 24,000-home development shouldn't have to be an "emergency."
* * *
The Signal's opinion is always labeled "Editorial." All other views express individual opinions and are not necessarily those of The Signal or The-Signal.com.
