More than 65 percent of the Santa Clarita Valley’s voters on Tuesday favored Measure A, a ballot initiative to provide much-needed funding to renovate the community’s aging fleet of junior high and high schools while also qualifying the local high school district for state matching funds that would build new schools to alleviate overcrowding.
Sixty-five percent voted yes. Thirty-four percent voted no.
And the measure lost.
In what should be a simple exercise in the democratic process, the minority dictated to the majority, thwarting a plan that was crucial to the education of thousands of Santa Clarita Valley children. Measure A would have cost the average SCV homeowner about $35 per year in property taxes.
The measure failed thanks to California’s requirement that local bond initiatives like Measure A earn a two-thirds majority in order to pass.
What does that mean? It means that a minority of the voting public can dictate to the majority. Merely by scraping together 34 percent of the vote, an opposition campaign can defeat an initiative like Measure A.
In the case of the William S. Hart Union High School District’s $52 million ballot measure, 9,222 yes votes were cast and 4,881 no votes were cast. In any other type of election, that margin would be considered an astounding victory.
That’s a testament to just how difficult the two-thirds requirement is to meet. It doesn’t create an environment for fair elections. Rather, it creates an environment in which the minority can control the destiny of important issues like the education of a community’s children.
But there is hope.
In March, California voters have an opportunity to end the madness.
Proposition 26 on the March 7 ballot would reduce the voting requirement for local bond initiatives to a simple majority.
Voters in 1993 rejected a similar proposition, but hopefully this time around the message will be better received: So long as local bond initiatives require a two-thirds majority, and so long as such initiatives are a prerequisite for state school construction funds, the children in communities like Santa Clarita will suffer because school districts will be hamstrung by a minority of the voters.
It’s too late for Measure A, but given the close margin by which it “lost,” having drawn almost twice as many yes votes as no votes, one can’t help but wonder whether there may yet be relief in sight for the students of the Hart district.
In that respect, the statewide Proposition 26 could prove to be just as important to the Santa Clarita Valley as Measure A should have been.
