The Santa Clarita Valley’s leaking pipes could be the equivalent of a smoking gun for the developers of various local housing tracts.
As in any legal proceeding, the accused should be officially presumed innocent until proven guilty. But if the claims of numerous local homeowners prove true, some Santa Clarita Valley developers had better break out their checkbooks and buy some new water pipe— and given the widespread nature of the claims, it seems likely that at least some of the claims will prove to be substantial.
The claims, outlined in a series of class-action lawsuits first reported by The Signal in July, paint a picture of low-quality water pipes installed in homes built in various Santa Clarita Valley developments.
The lawsuits allege the inferior, Korean-made galvanized pipe works fine for a few years, then starts to corrode and leak prematurely.
At least six homeowners groups have filed lawsuits against developers including The Newhall Land and Farming Co., Dale Poe Development Co., Presley Homes of Irvine, Pacific Bay and Paragon Homes and Monteverde Development Co. The cases generally involve homes built between 1986 and about 1995, when developers generally stopped using foreign-made galvanized steel pipes.
Damage claims range from $5,000 to $35,000 per home.
There are several issues to be decided by the courts as the cases wind their way through the system in the next year: Were the pipes in fact poorly constructed or inferior? If so, did the developers knowingly install a product that was not likely to perform to a homebuyer’s reasonable expectations? Have the pipes in fact failed to meet those expectations?
Assorted homeowners in tracts from Castaic to Valencia to Saugus say the answers to these questions is “yes.”
If that’s the case, the developers would have a moral obligation— and, hopefully, a legal one— to take whatever steps are necessary to give their customers what they should reasonably expect: Homes where the toilets flush, the water is clear and the pipes don’t leak.
