A veterans memorial is a perfectly fitting idea for downtown Newhall: It’s the sort of honor any hometown should bestow upon its citizens who have taken up arms in the cause of freedom, and it’s also the sort of historic tribute that fits well in a revitalized downtown district.
‘If the primary purpose of acquiring the land is for the city to develop a veterans memorial, and the city doesn’t like the asking price, then the city should look elsewhere for a site.’
So far, so good.
But in its efforts to establish a veterans memorial in downtown Newhall, the city of Santa Clarita is dangerously close to a substantial misstep.
That misstep has not yet occurred, really. But it’s poised to occur.
The City Council has authorized city staff to pursue eminent domain, if necessary, to acquire the proposed site of the veterans memorial, the so-called “Newhall triangle” at the intersections of Newhall Avenue, Walnut Street and Market Street.
Eminent domain is a legal process through which municipalities acquire private property for public improvements— typically things like new freeways—Êat what is determined to be a fair market price.
In the case of the Newhall triangle, the property owner’s asking price is $250,000— too high for the city’s taste, which prompted the council to add eminent domain to the menu of options.
The price indeed may be too high. But that’s not really the point. Rather, the point is that if the primary purpose of acquiring the land is for the city to develop a veterans memorial, and the city doesn’t like the asking price, then the city should look elsewhere for a site.
Santa Clarita must not become the sort of city that tromps around, taking what it wants from private citizens, merely in the interest of fulfilling its vision for the city’s development.
Property rights should still mean something, and if the public benefit of seizing private property is the establishment of a veterans memorial, that’s not sufficient justification for eminent domain. Veterans memorials can be effectively located in many different places.
A side issue with the Newhall triangle property is that, if the city acquires the land and develops the memorial, it will also enable road improvements to occur on two of the three streets adjacent to the property.
Now, if the real reason for eminent domain were to improve roads and thus overall traffic circulation for the greater good of all of the city’s residents, that might be a case for eminent domain. But with all due respect to the city’s admirable plans for a veterans memorial, if that’s the primary purpose for the acquisition— and the price is too high— the city should simply pursue another site rather than executing a legal land grab.
That land grab has yet to occur, and may not. Most people close to the situation seem to think an amicable arrangement can be made with the land owner. Let’s hope that’s the case.
