Do the Porta Bella folks have any money or insurance? It’s the question of the week, and it’s a highly complicated one, so bear with us.
Porta Bella is the 996-acre area in the center of the city that is slated for 2,911 homes one day— after the land is cleaned of toxic and hazardous materials left behind from decades of munitions-making .
Some of the toxins found their way into four water wells near Bouquet Junction. Sensing that the Porta Bella owners were moving too slowly, the water companies that own the wells filed suit last week to force their cleanup. It could cost $35 million.
It would seem cut and dry. Some of the Santa Clarita Valley’s groundwater is contaminated, so the water companies are taking steps to clean it— by twisting the arms of the responsible parties.
But it isn’t cut and dry.
The current property owners aren’t the ones who polluted it. The polluters were the Bermite Powder Co., which manufactured explosives there since World War II, and Whittaker Corp., which bought out Bermite in the 1980s.
In 1986, the California Environmental Protection Agency got a court order making Whittaker responsible for the cleanup. Under the court order, as long as Whittaker exists, it must pay to clean the land, no matter who owns the property.
Trouble is, Whittaker doesn’t exist anymore. Corporate raiders split it up last year.
The City Council called a meeting last week to delve into the liability question, but the issue was put on hold because the answers are so murky.
The water companies think there might be some “historic insurance” on the property.
When Bermite started polluting the land 50 or 60 years ago, it may have had insurance to cover any mishaps. Insurance companies used to cover incidents on an “occurrence basis” rather than a “claims basis” like they do today, so there just might be an insurance company out there that’s still on the hook for past pollution, no matter when it “occurred.”
That would be good. But what if there isn’t? That’s where it gets dicey— and it raises an even more serious question: Might the city be responsible for some of the cleanup cost?
Five years ago the City Council signed a development agreement entitling the landowner to build homes at Porta Bella. Moreover, today the city is building Golden Valley Road through the property, and the city owns the roadbed.
Do those facts create a legal buy-in on the city’s part? Given the $35 million price tag for well-water cleanup, and more for the soil, it’s a frightening concept. We don’t know the answer.
City Attorney Carl Newton has said that when Santa Clarita LLC bought the property in early 1999, it assumed the legal responsibility for cleaning it.
Santa Clarita LLC officials have said they’re working with the state to clean it, and that they want to clean it, but that they don’t necessarily agree they’re legally responsible to clean it.
Last week Newton asked Santa Clarita LLC to show him its purchase agreement on the property, ostensibly to demonstrate how the company was absolving the city of any legal responsibility. Santa Clarita LLC refused. They also refused to “show the money” — or the proof of insurance— when The Signal asked for it on Monday.
Who exactly is Santa Clarita LLC? They won’t tell us that, either. “LLC” stands for Limited Liability Company, a legal entity that “limits” the “liability” of its “members” (the equivalent of officers in a corporation). The “managing member” is Remediation Financial Inc., an Arizona company that redevelops contaminated land. We’ve asked RFI officials who the other “members” of Santa Clarita LLC are, if any. They didn’t tell us.
Last month the contractor Santa Clarita LLC hired to do the actual cleanup quit because of the “severity” of the “collection problems” it had with RFI— something RFI disputes.
With all the secrecy, and faced with the fear that the city might end up holding the bag for the cleanup, we ask again: Do the Porta Bella folks have any money or insurance?
