Compassion is a positive attribute. Those who are showing compassion for the homeless by attempting to establish a homeless shelter in the Santa Clarita Valley are to be commended for the compassion they show toward those who have no roof over their heads.
But the City Council is also to be commended, for balancing its compassion for the homeless with its compassion for business owners whose livelihood could be threatened by the presence of the shelter in a Canyon Country shopping center.
‘We don’t need to establish a homeless shelter so urgently that we offer up pre-existing businesses as sacrificial lambs.’
There are those who will refuse to see the compassion in that decision. But the council, in its 4-0 vote Tuesday night (Frank Ferry abstained), recognized that helping the homeless, while a worthy goal, should not come at the expense of existing businesses. It was a big-picture decision.
The shopping center on Sierra Highway was viewed by the Santa Clarita Community Development Corp. — the non-profit group backing the shelter— as a suitable location. And it may well have been suitable, from the perspective of operating a shelter.
But it absolutely was not suitable from the perspective of operating an adjacent business. The presence of a homeless shelter in a commercial center, like it or not, would be detrimental to the adjacent and nearby businesses.
This wasn’t the case at the shelter’s former location, on the grounds of the Santa Clarita Sports Complex. For three winters, the seasonal shelter occupied space on the city property, and all went well enough. The Santa Clarita Valley doesn’t have a homeless “problem” per se— about two dozen people used the shelter on a typical night. But the shelter provided a service to those people without having an undue impact on the city’s general population. Crime did not skyrocket in the area, no major incidents were reported and no one lost their business over it.
That site, however, was not adjacent to other businesses and was isolated from residential areas. So the “perception problem” of a homeless shelter really didn’t come into play.
Regardless of whether the shelter would actually result in an increase in crime or other undesirable behavior, the fact of the matter is the shelter’s presence alone would be enough to deter would-be customers from visiting those existing businesses. Not everyone views homeless shelters with an open mind, and its close proximity to pre-existing retail businesses would have a very real effect.
The council recognized this— but also recognized that there may still be something that the city can do to help. For example, Councilwoman Laurene Weste wondered aloud whether modular buildings could be added to the city’s property near the sports complex. While that may or may not prove to be a viable solution, it’s just the sort of creativity that’s called for in a situation such as this.
There really are very few places that are “suitable” for a homeless shelter in Santa Clarita, and the need for one is minimal. Further, whatever shelter is established should be a seasonal, overnight-only operation, like the one at the sports complex was. We don’t need to create a homeless problem by putting out the welcome mat to the homeless of neighboring valleys.
And we don’t need to establish a homeless shelter so urgently that we offer up pre-existing businesses as sacrificial lambs.
Hopefully, some middle ground can be found— both literally and figuratively. But for now, the council has made the right decision, and balanced its compassion
