Greater size does not necessarily equate to greater need— yet when it comes to school construction and modernization projects, the State Allocation Board has bought into the myth that the bigger the dog, the bigger the bone.
‘Such an arrangement favors the “big dogs,” like the Los Angeles Unified School District, and shoves aside the comparatively smaller districts, like all of those in the Santa Clarita Valley.’
Unfortunately, as a result of a settlement struck by the allocation board, the question of whether the Santa Clarita Valley gets its share of school construction funds might come down to “how many big dogs are at the bowl,” says Marc Winger, superintendent of the Newhall School District.
This, as a result of a settlement in a lawsuit filed by civil rights law firms and activists who contended that the allocation board had been discriminating against large, urban school districts with its first-come , first-served system of allocating construction funds. The plaintiffs had alleged that the larger districts were unable to react to such a system, rendering it unfair to the urban districts.
That may have been partly true. Certainly, larger districts may potentially have greater needs and their bureaucracies may not be as nimble as the administrations of smaller districts.
Problem is, in agreeing to the settlement, the allocation board has replaced one unfair system with another.
The settlement of the lawsuit— Godinez v. Davis— calls for the establishment of a priority point system that uses school district enrollment figures to establish priority.
Such an arrangement favors the “big dogs,” like the Los Angeles Unified School District, and shoves aside the comparatively smaller districts, like all of those in the Santa Clarita Valley.
“It’s devastating to all schools in the area,” Bill McDermott, director of personnel and business services for the Castaic Union School District, told The Signal this week.
A more fair system would take into account not just the size of the district, but the size of the need, and distribute the money proportionally.
The local districts belong to a consortium of small school districts called Coalition of Adequate School Housing, and CASH has filed a complaint of its own, alleging the State Allocation Board has unfairly tilted the scales— or, rather, the bowl— toward the metropolitan districts.
Let’s hope that complaint succeeds. Because if size is all that matters, then our local school districts will be hungry pomeranians while the “big dogs” like L.A. Unified slurp up all of the kibble in California.
