The connection between Valley Street and Calgrove Boulevard should have been opened long ago— and now, just when the issue appears to be coming to a head, there are still those who want to wait even longer, and let the courts decide.
That would amount to a municipal cop-out , as this is a decision that can and should already have been made by our local elected officials, who were put into office to make just this kind of difficult decision.
Fortunately, the city Planning Commission and a City Council majority are pressing for a local solution first. The Planning Commission has recommended the road connection be opened— with “traffic calming” measures— and the City Council has voted to expedite the commission’s recommendation.
Open or closed, the final decision on the Valley-Calgrove connection will leave some constituents angry.
As it stands, the link between the two streets is blocked off, except for a private secondary access through which only residents of Hidden Valley can pass. Their private gate is the only means of going directly from Valley Street to Calgrove Boulevard, and vice versa.
This elitist approach to connecting two public streets dates back to the 1980s, when Hidden Valley was developed. The gate system was enacted because of concern from residents on the Valley Street side of the connection who were worried that an influx of new traffic would harm their neighborhood’s rural character.
The end result is a public road that is closed to the public— an especially aggravating contradiction in terms for a community that supposedly cites better traffic circulation patterns as one of its most pressing needs.
Earlier this year, the city began studying the possibility of placing permanent cul de sacs at the ends of each of the two streets, thus closing off the connection for good. That would be a shame.
The City Council long ago should have recognized that it should have chosen the path that created the greatest good for the greatest number of residents. The Valley-Calgrove connection would, certainly, experience greater traffic if opened— but the traffic on that link has been artificially restricted for years.
Suppose the government blocked off access to your neighborhood’s streets except for those who live there. You’d like that, wouldn’t you? And certainly if you had occasion to become accustomed to it, you’d be upset if someone proposed a change.
But it’s not a realistic luxury, especially when improving overall traffic circulation is such a pressing need.
Now, with a Jan. 26 court date looming for a pair of lawsuits over the issue, the city seems to be moving forward to open the connection. Still, two members of the City Council—ÊBob Kellar and Frank Ferry— say they’d rather wait and let the courts decide.
However, as we’ve seen with the presidential election, as good as our court system is, it is still subject to variables. Going to court can be a crapshoot. And, frankly, this is a decision that is easily within the purview of the local elected body. It’s a decision that should be made by that body.
