It's not the most important issue facing our nation, not by any wild stretch of the imagination. It is a problem that has no impact whatsoever on world peace, democracy as we know it or even our economy's struggles.
But it is a source of frustration for many Americans, and it should be addressed:
How do we determine which college football team wins the national championship?
Any sane person would agree, of course, that college football is far from a pressing issue in the America of today. But college football, like all other major sports, does serve an important role as a healthy diversion not only for college students and players, but also for many millions of casual, and not-so-casual fans across the nation.
College football is one of our prized escapes from the rigors of our own daily lives. Fans don't live and die over their teams' successes and failures, but they share joy and anguish, and revel in the relative frivolity of it all.
And, as is the case with many of our diversions, we Americans canÕt help asking the question:
"Who's the best?"
And, as is the case with most questions we Americans ask, we expect a straight answer. Now.
College football and its system of bowl games have long struggled to provide just such an answer, and over the years the answer has largely been provided through a system of polls, which are, by nature, subjective. In years when the "top two" teams did not happen to play each other in a bowl game, the so-called "national championship" has been a mythical one at best.
The Bowl Championship Series was supposed to end all of that.
Certainly, in some respects, the BCS has improved the situation. It pits two teams against each other in a so-called national championship game based on a complex mathematical formula that appears to be the approximate equivalent of multiplying the top teams' poll rankings by their opponents' won-loss records and dividing by each team's collective bowling average or golf handicap, whichever is lower.
The end result is that a computer calculation, not head-to-head matchups on the field, determines who meets in that national title game.
This year, that computer formula has resulted in some heated debate: Miami, the undisputed No. 1 team after the regular season, will face Nebraska in the BCS title game. Problem: The polls have Nebraska ranked No. 4 and instead rank Oregon at No. 2, with Colorado at No. 3.
We're not here to tell you the BCS is wrong, nor do we dispute the polls. We yield to the fact that the computer, the coaches and the college football media know a lot more about these matters than we do.
But what is obvious is that the national title is being decided in a subjective way, even if a computer is involved. Even though the NCAA built a better mousetrap with the BCS, it still hasn't caught the mouse.
There are those who say the computer formula is as accurate as anything else out there, and that may be true Ñ with one notable exception: It's not as accurate as letting the contenders battle it out among each other for the right to play in the championship tilt, and awarding the title to the victor in a game matching the last two teams standing.
Even in a playoff system, there would be some subjectivity involved - but its role would be sufficiently reduced so as to remove all question from the national title. For example, if an eight-team playoff were conducted, it's inevitable that poll rankings would somehow come into play to select the eight teams. But the vast majority of fans would agree that the top eight would be a good place to start in looking for the best of the best. The eight-team playoff would mean three rounds for a total of seven games: A round of eight, a round of four and the title game.
A playoff system would, no doubt, complicate matters a bit when it comes to scheduling. But for crying out loud, the Rose Bowl, this year's BCS title game, is being played on a non-holiday Thursday. It's difficult to believe another week or two of scheduling to accommodate a playoff would kill anybody.
Yes, there are more important issues confronting America. But the solution to this one seems so simple: Put the best teams in a playoff and let them slug it out on the field in a battle for all the marbles. It works in pro sports and it works in college basketball, so there's every reason to believe it would work in college football, too.
It would sure beat letting a computer pick the winner, and it would satisfy Americans' hunger for that elusive answer:
Who's the best?
