CHRIS JAMES
NOLAN LEMAR
Odds are, you can remember seeing an experiment like this one — or even participating in it — in high school: A tennis ball is placed in a canister, fuel is ignited and the ball shoots out of the canister, like a projectile launched from a cannon.
It's an experiment that, while "routine" in the context of teaching high school science students a lesson in propulsion and acceleration, seems to have inherent dangers. Those dangers proved all too real last week at Hart High School.
Four students were injured — two of them seriously — when something went awry Wednesday and the methanol fuel ignited unexpectedly.
Chris James, 17, suffered life-threatening burns from the "invisible fire" created when the methanol ignited, and his classmate, 17-year-old Nolan LeMar, also suffered burns serious enough to warrant surgery.
Both students were transported to the Grossman Burn Center in Sherman Oaks — a renowned burn treatment facility — and have undergone surgery to repair the damage caused by the mishap. LeMar, who was burned over 12 percent of his body, may be fortunate enough to go home this weekend, while James is expected to undergo his third surgical procedure on Thursday. James suffered life-threatening injuries to his larynx and vocal cords when he inhaled superheated air, and on Saturday, burned skin was removed from 35 percent of his body.
As observers we can only imagine the nightmare being endured by the victims and their families — and put forth the question, "How can this be?"
Finger-pointing isn't healthy at this early stage, as the results of investigations by the county Sheriff's Department and Fire Department have not been released.
However, it's clear that the William S. Hart Union High School District — and other districts in which the methanol cannon experiment is performed — must conduct its own detailed evaluation of the experiment and its safety standards to prevent additional students from being hurt.
It's unclear whether better safety standards will reduce risks to acceptable levels — some students contend there was no fire extinguisher in the vicinity when the experiment was conducted — or if student participation in the experiment ought to be dropped altogether.
For example, would the same lesson be taught equally well if the instructor were to conduct a demonstration, with students observing from some reasonable distance?
And if that's not deemed acceptable, what other preventive measures can be taken?
In the weeks ahead, we hope not only for a successful recovery by the injured students, but also for an honest, introspective review of these questions by the Hart district — and a public announcement of what measures will be taken to prevent such a tragedy from recurring.
* * *
The Signal's opinion is always labeled "Editorial." All other views express individual opinions and are not necessarily those of The Signal or The-Signal.com.
