And the backtracking begins.
Our city government, caught with its legal pants down on its 12th anniversary, is trying to creatively rewrite history to convince the public that nothing was wrong with the Sept. 7 closed session in which city resources were allocated to assist Councilwoman Jill Klajic’s lawsuit against the Castaic Lake Water Agency.
Further, much attention has been focused by those scurrying around City Hall on the “leak” that supposedly led to The Signal’s story on the issue Tuesday— rather than the fact that the City Council, on the advice of its attorney and city manager, engaged in a highly questionable, probably illegal, meeting and decision that never would have seen the light of day if city management had its way. Talk about misplaced priorities.
The city’s actions of Sept. 7 were wrong primarily on three points:
• The closed session discussion of whether the city should assist Klajic’s lawsuit— in which she and three other plaintiffs seek to block the CLWA’s purchase of the Santa Clarita Water Co. — never should have occurred in private. As soon as the council decided not to become directly involved in litigation, it was no longer a subject suitable for closed session— legally or morally.
• The vote should have been disclosed to the public, because the city had decided to intervene in the lawsuit by allowing City Attorney Carl Newton to provide research and counseling to Klajic and her fellow litigants. Newton says the action did not constitute “intervention,” but if you believe that we have some swampland to sell you.
• Klajic should not have participated in the vote, as it directly affected her economically by providing public resources to her private legal battle.
It wasn’t the first time the city has played fast and loose with open-meeting law, and in the past Newton has tried to justify closed sessions as discussions of “pending litigation” when no lawsuit had been filed or appeared imminent.
Further, Newton said in Tuesday’s council meeting that The Signal’s coverage was inaccurate and untrue. However, neither Newton nor city staff or council provided any information about factual inaccuracies in The Signal’s coverage. Newton has offered several legal interpretations and much Clintonesque spin-doctoring , but has not refuted a single fact reported in The Signal’s stories. Don’t hold your breath. It’s all unequivocally true.
What really happened Sept. 7? The city went into closed session and discussed anew whether to sue the CLWA. A City Council majority— and top city managers— had coveted the Santa Clarita Water Co., but lost out in a power struggle with the CLWA. The council Sept. 7 again decided to refrain from suing— in part, Newton says, because the city would be viewed in court as a jilted suitor— but then began discussing whether to support Klajic’s private lawsuit against the CLWA. That’s the point at which the meeting should have gone public, but it didn’t.
The council voted 3-2 — with Councilman Frank Ferry and Councilwoman Laurene Weste dissenting— to allow Newton to consult with Klajic’s attorney, and to provide a legal analysis for Klajic’s case that had been purchased by the city for $800.
Despite objections by Ferry and Weste, the vote was not revealed to the public, until The Signal learned of it and published a news story this week.
What the vote amounted to was a means for the city to pursue legal action without actually attaching the city’s name to it. Klajic and her friends were the city’s Trojan horse.
Newton contends the entire mess was legal because the city did not file a friend-of-the-court brief, and he did not write any of the motions or other official documents filed by Klajic’s attorney. What Newton conveniently overlooks is the fact that the city quite obviously intervened in the lawsuit by providing assistance to Klajic’s case— without telling the public. And that, friends, is a violation of the Ralph M. Brown Act, a state open-meeting law.
Carl Newton is a sharp legal mind, there’s no doubting that. But other sharp legal minds— like Terry Francke of the California First Amendment Coalition— disagree with his interpretation of whether the events of Sept. 7 were legal, and no legal or linguistic gymnastics he can concoct will ever justify these indisputable facts:
• That the council met secretly on an item that should have been discussed publicly
• That a secret decision was wrongfully kept from the public.
• That public resources were wrongly directed to aid a private lawsuit.
• And, that a city councilwoman was improperly allowed to vote on a decision that directly benefited her, saving her substantial legal and research expenses. In fact, Newton provided competent legal assistance that may not have been otherwise available to Klajic and her co-litigants .
There is much wrong at City Hall. And it’s time for our elected leaders to take a hard look at the advice they’re getting, particularly as it relates to the Brown Act and conducting the public’s business behind closed doors.
The Signal's opinion is always lableled "Editorial." All other views expressed on the Opinion pages represents individual opinions and are not necessarily those of the newspaper.
