Your heart can’t help but go out to the parents of the 13-month-old girl who died Dec. 11, suffocating as a popular toy became stuck over her nose and mouth.
The loss of any child is a tragedy. The heartbreak that the little girl’s death left behind is assuredly a tangible, gut-wrenching thing.
However— and it’s difficult to put this delicately enough— the reaction to this particular tragedy has consisted of the consummate 1990s overreaction and blame-placing .
The “villain” in this case: A Burger King “Pokémon” ball, one of many millions distributed with children’s meals in the past couple of months at the fast-food chain’s outlets.
The Pokémon toys have been immensely popular, thanks to an animated children’s television series and movie about the small fictional creatures and their “trainers.” Each toy came enclosed in a small red and white “ball,” consisting of two halves that open to reveal the toy inside.
Unfortunately, Burger King’s kids’ toys were labeled as being safe for all ages. What was unforeseen was the possibility that one half of the ball could become stuck on a child’s face, blocking air passages. It’s the sort of eventuality that one may not envision until it actually occurs.
‘There ought to come a point at which we all say, yes, the world is full of objects that can be dangerous in the hands of unsupervised children, and once we have recognized such objects, we should rely on parents to both watch their own children and keep danger at a safe distance from the little ones.’
That’s what happened to the 13-month-old girl in Sonora, Calif., who was found in her playpen with one-half of a Burger King Pokémon ball stuck over her mouth and nose.
Burger King, in response to the tragedy, voluntarily recalled 25 million of the Pokémon balls and recommended that parents take the balls away from all children under age 3. The fast-food chain has offered a small order of fries in exchange for any Pokémon ball returned by a parent.
But— and here’s where our typical modern overreaction comes in— a federal official says that’s not enough.
Russ Rader, a U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission spokesman, said Burger King should recall millions more of the balls— perhaps bringing the total to as many as 70 million— because older children who got the Pokémon ball may have younger brothers and sisters who could be endangered.
That’s akin to saying any toy labeled as unsafe for children under age 3 should be banned from the market altogether, because older kids may have younger siblings.
Obviously, such an assertion in a broad context would immediately be dismissed as absurd. But when it is in the context of a reaction to a terrible accident, it is taken seriously.
We mean no insensitivity to the tragedy in Sonora. Any parent cringes upon hearing such news. And we also have no intention of assigning blame, to either Burger King or those responsible for the little girl. This was an unintentional, horrible accident, and every parent of a toddler should learn from it and keep the Pokémon balls out of little ones’ unsupervised hands.
But there ought to come a point at which we all say, yes, the world is full of objects that can be dangerous in the hands of unsupervised children, and once we have recognized such objects, we should rely on parents to both watch their own children and keep danger at a safe distance from the little ones.
Living life in such extreme fear of common objects— toys, plastic cups, plastic bags— that we legislate them out of existence is not the answer.
Vigilance is.
The Signal's opinion is always lableled "Editorial." All other views expressed on the Opinion pages represents individual opinions and are not necessarily those of the newspaper.
