ArchiveSCV
the-signal.com. The Santa Clarita Valley Signal. Back to the collection.

· the-signal.com, Wayback capture

A view from this side of the closed door

Those of you familiar with the raising of mushrooms might recognize a popular analogy that can be applied to local government lately: They've been keeping us in the dark and feeding us ... ahem, manure.

The outcomes are still to be determined, and the public may yet end up with happy endings, but a couple of stories on the city and education beats have given us cause for concern. In both sets of circumstances, the most disturbing thing isn't real harm done to the public interest — at least not yet.

Rather, it's a mind-set of non-disclosure, of doing the real business behind the scenes and only feeding selected information to the masses.

First, there was the matter of the William S. Hart Union High School District's lawsuit settlement with the insurers of the earthquake-damaged auditorium at Hart High School.

Today is the fifth anniversary of the shaking that rendered the historic auditorium unusable, and it's still closed, waiting for repairs to be completed.

In the months following the quake, the fact that the building was insured somehow escaped the district, and when it was later discovered that insurance did exist, the district sued the insurer and the broker in an attempt to obtain the much-needed funds.

The case was settled a couple of months ago, but in one of the more monumental local government blunders in recent memory, the district agreed to keep the settlement confidential.

The district has since acknowledged the error, but it's bothersome that it occurred in the first place. The district ended up in an untenable position: It would either have to violate state law and keep the terms secret, or violate the settlement by releasing them, and risk a breach-of-contract lawsuit. District officials either received very poor legal advice or just figured they could get away with flouting public records law.

As a result of a California Public Records Act request filed by The Signal, a court hearing is scheduled Jan. 27 to determine whether the district can release the information to the public.

As it stands, the public has no ability to evaluate whether the district settled the lawsuit in taxpayers' best interest. Adding arrogance to injury, some Hart district officials initially lamented the fact that The Signal asked to see the settlement. One board member even went so far as to imply that, if the deal fell apart, it would be the paper's fault.

Despite its initial errors, the district has been cooperative in the past few weeks, and is filing a motion with the court that explains why the material should be released. The motion cites legal precedents that establish that public agencies cannot keep lawsuit settlements confidential. Hopefully, it will be granted — and I'm glad to see the district has changed its posture.

Then, just weeks after the Hart district situation unfolded, The Signal became aware of the fact that, without disclosing it to the public, the Santa Clarita City Council had held a closed-session meeting on the possibility that the city might purchase — or maybe seize through eminent domain — the Santa Clarita Water Co.

The closed-door meeting may have been legal, as there is an exception to state open-meeting law that allows public bodies to meet privately to discuss personnel and pending litigation, including decisions on whether to seize property through eminent domain.

Clearly, there is no litigation "pending" in the water company case — a red flag we immediately looked for because the city pulled that kind of stunt a few years ago, using "pending litigation" as a reason for closed-door meetings about the Elsmere Canyon landfill despite the fact that litigation was probably years away. Those meetings, by all appearances, were illegal.

But to privately discuss whether to invoke eminent domain can be legal, so that doesn't appear to be where the city strayed in this case. Rather, it strayed by failing to post the topic of the meeting — as is required by state law.

In other words, when a city council or school board is planning to hold a closed session, they have to tell you what it's about, and if it's regarding a lawsuit, they have to identify the case.

That didn't happen when the council discussed the possible water company deal Nov. 24, and were it not for a tip we received, the public probably still wouldn't know, because the city intended to keep it as quiet as possible.

In all fairness, we probably haven't done as good of a job reporting on the Castaic Lake Water Agency's end of the deal as we should have. The CLWA is also considering a deal to buy Santa Clarita Water Co., and it wouldn't surprise me to find out the CLWA board has engaged in discussions similar to the City Council's — but we haven't held their feet to the fire as much as we have the city, and we should.

However, in the CLWA's favor is the fact that it voluntarily went public to state its intent to negotiate for the purchase of the water company. The city, on the other hand, only grudgingly acknowledged it after The Signal got wind of it via a leak at City Hall.

What's most disturbing about both sets of circumstances — the Hart district's and the city's — is the fact that some of our government officials don't seem to have the proper sense of urgency about doing the public's business in public. They may not think that assessment is fair, but that's the view from this side of the closed door.

Obviously, exceptions to open-meeting laws exist for a reason, and in a few select circumstances it's prudent for elected officials to hold closed session matters close to the vest. But it seems our government agencies lately are erring on the side of secrecy — for example, slipping up on the details of open meeting posting rules, or keeping things quiet when it's questionable, maybe even illegal, to do so.

Let's hope they rethink that posture, and err on the side of openness rather than giving taxpayers the Mushroom Treatment.

* * *

Tim Whyte is managing editor of The Signal. His commentary appears on Sundays.

← Back to 1999

About this record

How it was held, read and classified

Record details

Morris ID
Not a Morris ID. This record is keyed ts-df:/editorial/whyte/011799.html.
System
other
Reading copy
the-signal.com
Chosen by: only copy held. On this copy: words 1,033 (e-mail addresses counted as one token); reader comments 0 (counted, not reproduced here); images 0.
Extracted by
datefile:SLUG_to_rule
signal-extract/0.15 (2026-11-16)

Other copies

Held
None. The holding has this article from one host only.

How it was classified

Label
clearly-local
Judgment
A machine’s (recorded as machine), kept as one so it can be revisited.
Classifier
signal-localclass/0.7 (2026-11-12)
Local signals
  • byline:staff_marker [managing editor]
  • text:valley_names [9 distinct/14 mentions: Santa Clarita, Castaic, Hart High, Hart district, William S. Hart, City Council]
National signals
none fired
Scores
local 6, national 0