ArchiveSCV
the-signal.com. The Santa Clarita Valley Signal. Back to the collection.

· the-signal.com, Wayback capture

Black ’n Whyte

Is BFI deal a win-win or a win-lose ?

It’s easy to get caught up in the initial excitement of the offer by Browning-Ferris Industries, which is trying to muscle our local waste haulers out of the contract with the city of Santa Clarita.

After all, in addition to a 20-percent residential rate cut, BFI is dangling Elsmere Canyon as an industrial-sized carrot: “Give us the city trash contract, and we’ll give you Elsmere Canyon.”

The name resounds with the many residents who spent the better part of the 1990s battling a proposed trash dump in Elsmere Canyon, part of the Angeles National Forest right at the city’s southern edge.

But once that initial excitement subsides, we must all take a deep breath, take a step back and give the BFI proposal a more measured evaluation. Fortunately, there’s time to do that, because of the nature of the existing franchise agreements: Each of the haulers is entitled to five years’ notice that it may be replaced.

BFI’s offer may prove to be a deal that’s too good for the city to refuse. But it may not, and we shouldn’t dump our local waste haulers lightly.

I say this particularly with Blue Barrel Disposal in mind. Blue Barrel is no longer locally owned— it and Santa Clarita Disposal are both owned by Waste Management Services— but the company has had a 35-year relationship with the Santa Clarita Valley.

That relationship is still going strong. Yes, a lot of residents aren’t happy with the city’s franchise agreements with Blue Barrel, Santa Clarita Disposal and Atlas Disposal, but locally operated companies like Blue Barrel are integral parts of the local business community.

Karl McCarthy, Blue Barrel’s general manager, is one of the Santa Clarita Valley’s all-time good guys. He’s responsible for numerous charitable contributions of not only money, but also the company’s resources and his own personal time.

That may not show up as a discount on your monthly trash bill, but it has a real value. I consider Karl McCarthy a friend, and I also consider him and his company to be true friends to this community.

Blue Barrel is a player in so many good local causes, and today is an example: The company is sponsoring SCV Kings Night, a fund-raiser for the Michael Hoefflin Foundation for children’s cancer research. To kick off sales for the game on March 31, Kings players Ian Laperierre and Eric Belanger will be at River Oaks Shopping Center from 3 to 4 today, signing autographs.

Blue Barrel’s name is associated with a wide variety of other local events and philanthropical efforts. And those sorts of things are what make the BFI proposal so hard to consider. If there weren’t a strong connection to the existing haulers, it would be all too easy to tell the city, “Take the rate cut and the land and sign with BFI as soon as possible.”

But under the local circumstances, the decision becomes much more difficult.

Again, it’s easy to get caught up in the excitement of the prospects of securing Elsmere Canyon and protecting it. There are those, however, who contend that it no longer needs protecting— that thanks to legislation by Rep. Howard “Buck” McKeon in 1996, and to the successful battle waged by the city and local residents, the political will no longer exists on the part of those who at one time considered Elsmere as a suitable location for the world’s largest trash dump.

Others disagree, and say it will only take a few well-placed legislators to turn the situation around.

Regardless, it seems the city ought to consider the Elsmere part of the deal on its merits: What is this land worth to us, strictly in terms of securing public open space, trails and parkland? Those things are significant factors, even without the threat of a landfill.

And when you get down to it, the biggest factor of the BFI proposal is cost. The city has a responsibility to get the best deal it can for local taxpayers, and as it stands SCV residents’ trash rates aren’t exactly rock-bottom .

There are, of course, other factors that must be considered. What kind of service would the out-of-town BFI provide to the SCV? How would they handle complaints? How would they go about being a player in the community?

From the emotional side of things, I feel inclined to battle for local good guys like Karl McCarthy and Blue Barrel, and give a lot of weight to Blue Barrel’s role in the community. From the analytical side, I think the city should view the 20-percent rate cut as a starting point for negotiations with all of the haulers— and should carefully weigh the value of gaining Elsmere Canyon vs. the value of continuing the long-term relationships with local companies. “Shop Local” is a good philosophy, and the big question here is whether other factors are sufficient to warrant shopping elsewhere. I don’t have the answer in this case.

It is often said that if something sounds too good to be true, it may well be—Êand the BFI offer, during the initial excitement, indeed sounded too good to be true. But there would be a real community cost associated with switching from local haulers to BFI, a factor that makes this decision anything but a slam-dunk . Yes, it’s a tremendous opportunity to cut a better deal for residents, but it could also prove to be a gut-wrenching decision.

Whatever the outcome, I don’t envy our decision-makers at City Hall.

Tim Whyte is The Signal’s managing editor. His column appears Sundays.

Image not recoveredmugwhyte.jpg

← Back to 2001

About this record

How it was held, read and classified

Record details

Morris ID
Not a Morris ID. This record is keyed ts-df:/editorial/whyte/0201/021101b.html.
System
date-file pages (/desk/MMYY/MMDDYY.html)
Reading copy
the-signal.com
Chosen by: only copy held. On this copy: words 926 (e-mail addresses counted as one token); reader comments 0 (counted, not reproduced here); images 1.
Extracted by
datefile:START_STORY
signal-extract/0.15 (2026-11-16)

Other copies

Held
None. The holding has this article from one host only.

How it was classified

Label
clearly-local
Judgment
A machine’s (recorded as machine), kept as one so it can be revisited.
Classifier
signal-localclass/0.7 (2026-11-12)
Local signals
  • url:datefile_editorial
  • byline:staff_marker [managing editor]
  • text:valley_names [3 distinct/15 mentions: Santa Clarita, SCV, Elsmere]
  • text:valley_elected_official “McKeon”
National signals
none fired
Scores
local 9, national 0