This has been a difficult few weeks for a lot of people around town. Lots of politicking. Lots of wrestling with personal loyalty vs. professional obligation. Lots of accusations of one kind of impropriety or another.
Lots of hurt feelings.
Not the easiest of times in community politics, but in many ways our city is at a crossroads. And it goes well beyond the question of who will pick up our trash. But that, for the moment, is the pressing question for local politicos, and a City Council that has been bitterly divided over whether the city should renew its contract with three existing waste haulers or open the franchise up to bid.
The issue has taken on a sense of urgency due to an impending deadline: The council has to decide in the next couple of weeks whether to extend the contract held by Blue Barrel and Santa Clarita Disposal (both owned by Waste Management) and Atlas Disposal (owned by Republic Industries).
A third giant company, Browning-Ferris Industries, threw a wrench into the works recently when it announced its wishes to take over the Santa Clarita trash franchise— and not only is it willing to do so for less money, in terms of a 20-percent rate cut, but it’s also willing to throw in the land it owns in Elsmere Canyon, long the site of a proposed landfill just outside the city.
There are, of course, many details to consider. There is the question of the duration of the pact sought by BFI, which wants a 20-year deal (under no circumstances should anyone get 20 years). There is the question of seizing this opportunity to make needed changes to the franchises, no matter who the hauler is. There is the question of how real that rate cut would be, and how the service would compare.
And, there is the fact that Waste Management has been a terrific corporate citizen in Santa Clarita, and its local manager, Karl McCarthy, is well-liked and deservedly recognized for his philanthropy, not only on his company’s behalf but also in terms of his own time and hard work.
I know Karl has been agonizing over this. He takes the entire thing very personally. But he shouldn’t. This is not about whether this community likes Karl and Blue Barrel. We do.
It’s about professional obligations and duties.
I say this with regard to not only the decision facing the City Council, but also the decisions we have had to make as a newspaper. Both entities are facing similar sorts of challenges.
For our part, we have had to cover the news with an eye toward providing the public relevant information about a controversial story. Not all of that information has been comfortable for the people connected with the story, which has put us in an uncomfortable position, too, because we hold those people in high esteem.
For example: There was the story we published this week about a $10,000 contribution Waste Management made to the local Republican Headquarters, a committee chaired by Councilman Frank Ferry.
The contribution was entirely legal. But it was made during a time when Waste Management was in negotiation with the city, and Ferry is one of the decision-makers on the contract. One of the people close to the story asked me, before we published it, if our intent was to “slant” the story to make it look like Ferry’s support had been “bought.”
My response was that we would simply report the facts and let readers formulate their own opinions. We do our level best to keep our opinions confined to the opinion page, and stick to the facts in our news coverage.
Unfortunately for Ferry and Waste Management, the facts in this case are unappealing in the eyes of many readers: When a city contractor gives that kind of dough to a committee headed by a City Council member while contract negotiations are under way, then that council member adamantly argues that the contract should be renewed without considering a competing proposal, it looks bad.
No “slanting” is needed.
We shouldn’t be naive. That sort of thing happens all the time in politics. One hand washes the other, political contributions are made, and the “money people” have more influence on politicians than Joe Sixpack.
It is our job, as the local newspaper, to inform you of it, and sometimes to editorialize against it. No matter who is involved.
All parties in this case should have realized how bad that $10,000 contribution would look, especially when Ferry so ardently opposed the notion of investigating BFI’s offer.
When we came to find out that the $10,000 contribution had been made, we had to ask ourselves, “Is it news?”
We came to the inescapable conclusion that it was. I even played the role-reversal mind game with myself: Suppose I’d found out about a similar story about one of my political rivals— say, former Councilwoman Jill Klajic. When I asked myself if I would have thought that was news, I had my answer for the Ferry-Waste Management situation.
Of course it was news.
A government franchise-holder gives a five-figure donation to a committee headed by a City Council member who is on the verge of deciding whether to renew the franchise. Damn right that’s news. Heck, Waste Management only gave $5,000 to Bob Hertzberg, the speaker of the whole state Assembly. The decision to run the story was simply uncomfortable because I have long considered the parties involved to be allies and/or friends.
But I couldn’t let that decision be a personal one. It was news, and that’s that. This can be a tough business.
Likewise, the City Council cannot let personal loyalties affect its decision-making on the trash franchise.
When push comes to shove, the council has to make the decision that’s in the best interest of Santa Clarita taxpayers. That may mean opening the trash contract up to bid— a move that would not necessarily preclude Waste Management from landing the contract, but would open the door to competition from companies like BFI.
Yes, Waste Management’s track record as a good local citizen must be considered a factor. But that’s not a matter of personal loyalty; that’s a matter of weighing the very real public benefits derived from the company’s role in the community.
Other factors that must come into play are, of course, cost, quality of service and, yes, perhaps, other incentives like the possibility of turning Elsmere Canyon over to the public— although frankly this last item, in terms of the trash franchise, is vastly overrated. As we’ve said editorially, if Waste Management and BFI came in with identical bids except for the Elsmere land donation, Waste Management should get the nod based on its track record.
But it should not get the nod just because we like Waste Management’s local manager, and it should not get the nod because Waste Management helped finance the SCV Republican Headquarters in its inaugural year.
The council is obligated to view this from a business perspective. What’s the best combination of quality trash and recycling service, price, and, yes, community service for the residents and businesses our city serves? That may prove to be Waste Management. It may prove to be Atlas. It may prove to be BFI. It may prove to be a hauler yet to be named, or some combination of the above.
But whatever the outcome, it’s a business matter and a matter of public policy, not a personal one.
It can’t be.
Tim Whyte is The Signal’s managing editor. His column appears Sundays.
