It’s always something of a coup for a journalist to obtain information that hasn’t been released to the general public— especially when the journalist knows the source of the information doesn’t want it released.
So there was some level of intrigue in the newsroom last week when one of our journalists obtained a copy of a supplementary Sheriff’s Department report on the car wreck that killed three Canyon High School students and a 45-year-old motorist Feb. 17.
Eighteen-year-old driver Marcus Lellan is in jail, facing four counts of vehicular manslaughter for the crash, in which his car careened out of control as he allegedly attempted to make a high-speed pass in the bike lane.
And here’s what was interesting about the supplementary report: It recounted the statements of three possible witnesses who just may have seen another car that was involved in the wreck. A warning to readers: Place extreme emphasis on the phrase, “Just MAY have seen...” We don’t know yet.
The supplementary report was stamped, “Not for press board.” That means it was not to be placed on the clipboard that the SCVSheriff’s Station maintains for the press’ perusal.
It’s easy to let one’s imagination run wild when you see that— especially when you’ve been trained, as a journalist, to question things. That’s what we do. Do that long enough, and it will make you just a tad bit cynical.
But there’s a funny thing about California public records law that the general public, and many journalists, don’t actually realize: Police reports aren’t necessarily public records.
Law enforcement officials are obligated to share with us certain basic facts about crimes and alleged crimes. They have to tell us who was arrested, and what they’re accused of doing, and a few other key things. But they don’t have to give us every scrap of paper that has the word “report” on it.
That goes against the journalist’s intuition, of course. As a profession we are staunch advocates of government disclosure, and we stand proudly on a soapbox from which we proclaim that, if it is a document and it was generated by taxpayer dollars, we should be entitled to inspect it.
But police reports, whether we like it or not, are different. And while I think state law could better address the importance of the media’s role as watchdog, there are times when public disclosure of that piece of paper stamped “not for press board” could hamper law enforcement’s ability to do its job.
It’s a delicate balance: No one wants police to operate in a vacuum, but we don’t want to shine the light so brightly on their investigations that we sabotage them. There can be valid reasons to keep a lid on things— for example, sometimes the police are seeking a suspect who could be reading the morning papers.
In this instance, we didn’t know the reason the supplementary report had not been disclosed. We at The Signal have a good working relationship with the local sheriff’s station, so we called the honchos over there and asked: “Why hasn’t the information about these three possible witnesses been released?”
The answer was amazing in its simplicity. In essence, it was:
“We’ve heard the same rumors you’ve heard— but we haven’t been able to confirm them.” They explained that, since they had not yet been able to corroborate the version of the incident in which a second vehicle was involved, they had refrained from disclosing it to the public so as to avoid the potential spreading of misinformation. Why put out information that may not be correct?
Now, of course, the information had gotten to the local newspaper through, ahem, sources.
We respect the work the local gendarmes do, and while we’re always eager for a scoop— and wary when we discover that information hasn’t been disclosed— we didn’t want to screw up the investigation, either. So we asked: If we run a story based on that supplemental report, will it hamper the investigating deputies’ ability to do their job? The answer was favorable: Actually, they thought that, in this case, if we ran with the story, it might help flush out other witnesses.
So we went with the story, relaying the witnesses’ accounts of the moments prior to the incident, in which another vehicle may have been seen following or pursuing Marcus Lellan’s Acura.
Here’s the thing: The Sheriff’s Department has yet to confirm whether that was a factor in the wreck, and they’d be extremely interested in talking to anyone who may have seen anything that could help them piece together the truth. They’ve heard the same rumors we’ve heard— and the same rumors that have roared through the community these past few weeks— but, like us, they have yet to be able to confirm them.
Local law enforcement and the local press have a common goal to find out what exactly happened on that fateful February night. In the end, we’re all seeking the same thing:
Truth.
Tim Whyte is The Signal’s managing editor. His column appears Sundays.
