I have fond memories of what kids used to wear to school. After all, I got to high school just in time for those “Dolphin” shorts to become popular with the young ladies.
Ask any red-blooded American male who went to high school in the early-’80s to tell you about the many positive assets of Dolphin shorts. (No lie, some of them were so short, they showed cheek.) It was a fashion phenomenon that did not go unappreciated by the young men on campus— but it frustrated many an educator.
There were other sources of frustration for school administrators. I remember surfer kids getting sent to the dean’s office for wearing “Sex Wax” T-shirts , and I remember some rock band concert T-shirts being flipped inside out after an administrator found some of the artwork to be objectionable.
But “gang attire” wasn’t so much an issue in the SClarita Valley of 1978-84 , the years during which I attended first Arroyo Seco Junior High, then Saugus High School. Sure, you could tell a lot about someone by the way they dressed— whether they were a jock, a preppy, a stoner, whether they were into hard rock, or new wave— but the issue of gang identification didn’t really crop up while I was getting my education from the William S. Hart Union High School District.
And we never dreamed of donning a school uniform— a topic that has sparked a great deal of controversy locally as a La Mesa Junior High School student has “opted out” of the so-called “required” uniform program.
It wasn’t even an issue when I was in junior high and high school. Sure, back in “my day,” when you joined an extracurricular activity, there were clothes you’d wear as a condition of participation. On our high school football team, we were all required to wear a “game day shirt” to school on Fridays during the season. But there’s a big difference between optional activities and everyday wear.
I’m not opposed to uniforms per se. I think a uniform— or, if you prefer, “school logo wear” — is a fine way to show unity and school spirit.
I do, however, have a problem with making them “mandatory.”
I’m sure having all the kids in uniforms makes the teachers, parents and administrators at La Mesa, Sierra Vista and Placerita junior high schools feel better about campus safety. But for all the panicked-sounding rhetoric in favor of school uniforms, few people seem to notice that, across town, the uniform-free Arroyo Seco Junior High School doesn’t seem to have any different level of safety— or any less effective learning environment— than the other three junior highs.
So the uniforms serve primarily to give the adults peace of mind. In fact, it’s something of a joke when you see some of the photos we’ve had of kids in “uniform” at the local schools: One of our photographers captured an image of a kid who had “punked up” his school uniform with accessories that made it clear the kid wasn’t exactly Goody Two-Shoes .
But effectiveness aside, I think putting all of our kids in uniform sends the wrong message. Yes, discipline is a good thing— and so are rules. Kids shouldn’t get to wear whatever they want to school, and kids shouldn’t be able to wear a gang “uniform” as an alternative to a school uniform.
But individuality is a good thing, too. And by telling our kids they all have to dress exactly the same in order to be safe, we’re telling them that it’s not OK to be an individual. If you think about that sort of thought being carried to extremes in a society that is supposedly “free,” it can be scary.
Further, if “required” school uniforms don’t give us a generation of automatons, they will most certainly give us a generation of kids who will be even more inclined to rebel against authority when they get older.
And what sort of message does it send when that very authority lies to you in order to get you to comply with its wishes?
I realize the Hart School District didn’t create the lie, but the district perpetuates it every time it uses words like “mandatory” or “required” to described its school uniform policy.
That’s a lie that was created in state law. In typical government double-speak , the state law on school uniforms says they can be made mandatory, but individual students can “opt out” of the “required” school uniform program.
By definition, if you can “opt out” of something, it is not required. Period.
You don’t even have to be an English major to recognize that it’s a lie. It’s not a question of semantics. It’s not a question of interpretation. It’s a lie, right there in state law.
The law ought to be changed. It ought to clearly state that school uniforms are optional— because they are, and if they weren’t, there’d be some serious constitutional issues with which to contend. The law ought to further state that school districts must clearly identify school uniform policies as optional— not “required” or “mandatory” with an “opt out” policy obscurely noted in the fine print.
That’s not to say there should be no rules for kids’ attire. While everyone should be generally free to choose their own clothes— and parents, as legal guardians of children, must retain final say-so on any attire— certain things can legitimately be described as detrimental to the overall educational environment and can reasonably be restricted by the school district.
For example, any clothing that promotes illegal activity— say, a T-shirt with a cannabis leaf on it— ought to be verboten, as should any clothing that is too sexually suggestive.
Of course, my perspective on some things has changed now that I have a young son and an adorable niece. I stand more firmly in favor of a serious dress code, one that allows kids a certain amount of freedom to be individuals but draws a sharp line at things that are profane, or suggest drug use, or are just too damn revealing.
So, as much as I may have appreciated certain fashion trends when I was a young buck— and as much as I think mandatory uniforms are inherently wrong— I’d have no problem if the school administration imposed a reasonable, strict dress code.
And cripes, I must be getting old if I’m really about to say this, but here goes: They can start by outlawing those Dolphin shorts.
Tim Whyte is The Signal’s managing editor. His column appears Sundays.
