There are too many things we don’t know. And, evidently, too many things our City Council doesn’t know— or hasn’t been told.
The discrepancy in the city’s recycling figures is, at first glance, alarming. And in the long run, it may indeed prove alarming—Êor it may prove to be a simple, harmless reporting error.
But what’s really worrisome is the fact that it took some nosing around by our reporters to prompt city management to inform the City Council of the discrepancy—Êdespite the fact that the council is in the midst of a controversial decision on trash hauling contracts.
It appears, unfortunately, that our council has been given the mushroom treatment. They’ve been kept in the dark and fed... well, you know.
I don’t like that one bit.
Here’s the rundown on what we do know, some of it, again, thanks only to the fact that our reporters were poking around, asking questions in anticipation of the council’s expected vote Tuesday night on whether to approve a new trash contract with the city’s three haulers or to go to an open bid process:
The council faces the choice of whether to approve a new seven-year contract— plus a three-year “evergreen” automatic renewal clause— with Atlas, Blue Barrel and Santa Clarita disposal companies. All three companies are owned by large trash-hauling conglomerates, but the local haulers have had long-standing , mostly positive relationships with the community and the city, despite a general belief around town that our trash rates are higher than they should be.
The council has to decide whether to approve a new contract with those haulers, or go to bid, which would mean new competition for the local haulers. Browning-Ferris Industries, which operates the Sunshine Canyon Landfill, has offered to cut Santa Clarita’s trash rates by as much as 20 percent and donate a portion of its property in Elsmere Canyon— long the site of a proposed dump— to the city in exchange for a long-term deal.
On the surface, that sounds attractive, but BFI wants a 20-year deal— which is far too long. So there’s no telling what would happen in an open bid process.
All of this has prompted much heated debate in City Council chambers.
And in the meantime, we come to find out that there has been a pretty significant blip in the city’s trash statistics reported to the California Integrated Waste Management Board, and no one bothered to make those figures known to the community or the City Council until we asked about them.
In 1998, Santa Clarita sent a reported 115,596 tons of trash to landfills, with a reported diversion rate of 51 percent— which means that, either through source reduction or recycling, just over half of our waste was diverted from landfills. In 1999, those reported numbers changed dramatically: 183,738 tons were reported as going into landfills, with a diversion rate of just 25 percent. That’s a 68, 000-ton spike in trash to the landfills.
There’s an eight-month lag time in the reporting of these numbers, so the stats for 2000 won’t be sent to the state until August. (One wonders how long it will then take for the staff to get around to telling the City Council...)
If the state finds that the city remains below 50 percent diversion for 2000, the city could be found in non-compliance with the waste-reduction goals of Assembly Bill 939. That could cost Santa Clarita taxpayers as much as $10,000 per day in fines.
I doubt it will come to that. Odds are the city will find a way to explain the spike as an anomaly. There are numerous possible reasons, and many of those possible reasons are innocent enough. It could just be a reporting error of mammoth proportions, or perhaps non-Santa Clarita trash was attributed to us, as Blue Barrel Manager Karl McCarthy believes.
As an aside, this would highlight the fact that the system of reporting trash disposal and tracking our waste diversion and recycling appears to be prone to error and/or fraud. Just how easy is it for someone to incorrectly attribute non-Santa Clarita trash to our city?
This is serious business, and if the error is not found— or if the 2000 numbers are just as bad— Santa Clarita is in serious trouble.
That’s the sort of information that should have been shared with the City Council by now, especially considering the controversy that has been swirling around the city trash contract situation.
This doesn’t necessarily mean the haulers did anything wrong, but it’s inherently pertinent to the council’s decision-making on the trash contracts, and it’s unconscionable that the council was not made aware of this fact while the city staff was in the midst of recommending that the council approve a new contract with the existing haulers.
The council was only told after Signal reporters started asking questions. That looks awful. One can’t help asking: Why was this information withheld from the decision-makers ?
City Manager George Caravalho told our reporters he was made aware of the anomaly on Thursday. Let’s assume that’s true: The numbers were reported to the state in August, so someone dropped the ball, or chose not to carry it, for more than half a year.
That’s disturbing. This is the sort of information that should have been marched right up through the food chain to the City Council, which has a difficult decision to make about trash contracts that are tied directly to the city’s efforts to comply with AB 939.
Once it became known our story was in the works, suddenly there was a scramble to alert the City Council to the numbers glitch. I’m also irked by the fact that, when Signal reporters stirred up the story, the information was then spoon-fed to a competing newspaper by someone at City Hall. It was a clear example of attempted spin control and rear end-covering by a city staff caught with its pants down.
Yes. Something stinks at City Hall. And it’s not just a barrel of kitchen scraps.
Tim Whyte is The Signal’s managing editor.
