I’m told you don’t care, Santa Clarita.
That’s one of the reasons local power brokers keep throwing at the wall to see if it’ll stick before your local trash franchise is renewed.
You see, you’re paying more than you should. And if you don’t make enough noise at City Council chambers on Tuesday night, you’ll continue paying more than you should.
I’m not sure just how much your trash bill is inflated. No one really is, because your city has not bothered to comparison shop. I know your rates were set in 1996 based on inflated numbers representing haulers’ landfill fees. That’s a fact, not speculation. I don’t know who’s to blame— either the city or the haulers, but that question will never be answered.
I know you pay $22.13 per month. I know Waste Management Inc., the same hauler that serves 85 percent of the city of Santa Clarita, recently signed a new contract with the city of Carson to provide residential service for $10.98 a month, according to a Carson City Council member. Yep. We pay WMI double what Carson does.
I know Republic Services, the other Santa Clarita hauler (also a subsidiary of a national trash company), which has the remaining 15 percent of the franchise, has already said it could do the job here for $18.50.
So the magic number, even allowing for amazing profit and recognizing that it might be more expensive to do business here than in Carson, is somewhere between $10.98 and $18.50. In any case, I’d bet dollars to doughnuts that the “right rate” is lower than any last-ditch proposal the haulers might pull out of their hats Tuesday.
But you don’t care. And you won’t show up at Tuesday’s council meeting to tell your elected representatives you do care. And when the council hears testimony from a parade of business leaders who are trying to protect their friends at Waste Management— and keep the WMI gravy train rolling to their favorite pet causes— the council will, in all likelihood, vote 3-2 to renew the franchise at the inflated rate.
I think if you really understood how much money we’re talking about, you would care. Let’s say for the sake of argument we could save $4 per month, per household. Multiply that by the city’s 35,000 or so single-family households, just for round numbers. That’s $140,000 per month, not even including multi-family units or commercial services, which haven’t even entered the public discourse yet.
It’s $1.68 million per year, just on single-family homes. Over a 10-year contract, you’re talking $17 million.
That’s a low-ball estimate. And it’s not just your $4 or $5 per month. It’s a lot of money. Imagine how much it would be in the “ best-case ” scenario, if we could get a rate of $15 or even less.
The extra money leaves this economy— remember, despite what Councilwoman Jo Anne Darcy and other Waste Management shills are preaching, WMI is a heavy-hitting multinational company. A portion of the extra cash is redistributed by Waste Management, which is, admittedly and to its credit, one of the biggest corporate donors in this town.
It can afford to be.
In essence, WMI is bribing Santa Clarita with our own money. We pay extra for trash hauling, and the hauler gives money back to good local causes to keep the local power brokers happy.
As one of my colleagues put it, “Boy, are we a bunch of rubes. We’re getting city-slickered to death by those guys.”
There’s nothing wrong with a business making as much money as it can. You won’t find a bigger supporter of the local business community than me, and I’m all for free enterprise. But this isn’t free enterprise: It is a government-guaranteed monopoly. You can’t comparison shop for a hauler because it’s against the law to do that in Santa Clarita. Go ahead, try it.
Unfortunately, it appears your City Council won’t comparison shop for you. Too bad you don’t care, and the council won’t hear from you Tuesday night, when the council meets at City Hall— 23920 Valencia Blvd. — to make its next move on the trash franchises, two weeks after abandoning an audit of the haulers before the audit answered any of the key questions it was supposed to address.
The audit was expensive, and moving very slowly, at least in part because the big hauler in town, the multinational giant Waste Management, was stonewalling.
Strange. Just after the council decided to punt on the audit, the auditing firm signed a mega-deal to handle the hauler’s books. What a grand coincidence.
An aside: The City Council in Carson stuck with its own audit of WMI, and the hauler ended up paying a $3. 6-million settlement and lowering its rate from $14.41 to the aforementioned $10.98. That one came to a conclusion just last month— and there’s no reason Santa Clarita couldn’t sign another contract with WMI, too, after going to bid and forcing the hauler to make a better offer.
It bears repeating: This isn’t about “getting” Waste Management, and it’s not necessarily about giving the contract to another hauler. I have no allegiance to one hauler or another— these are not local “ mom-and-pop ” businesses. All of the players are major national trash companies and the answer to the question, “Who can you trust?” is, “None of the above.” I don’t care which one hauls my trash, so long as the franchise enforces a certain level of service and so long as I know we’re getting the best deal.
I suspect, if you ask most Santa Claritans, they’d agree with that notion.
The Santa Clarita City Council probably won’t hear much about that. And the council won’t hear from citizens who ask: “Why is Carson paying $10.98 for the same service from the same hauler and you expect me to pay $22.13 without questioning it?”
It’s too bad, because angry mobs have been known to have a lot of influence on the City Council in Santa Clarita.
But the council members won’t hear from the silent majority who would advocate an open bid process in the interest of good government.
They will hear, I’m betting, from a parade of people who want to protect the lucrative franchise held by their friend. They will hear from movers and shakers who want to keep those corporate contributions coming to one pet cause or another. (Never mind the fact that any hauler who gets the contract would in all likelihood pick up at least some of the slack... and never mind the fact that city franchises do not exist in order to redistribute money from your pocket to local causes, no matter how good those causes may be.)
They’ll hear from people who have had their arms twisted as part of the mad behind-the-scenes rush that has occurred this week. They’ll hear from people who are blindly loyal to a friend, even if it means you, the taxpayer, will continue to be ripped off for the next decade.
They’ll hear, too, from disingenuous people who say a successful recycling program is a good reason to stay with the existing haulers. News flash: Even after a city consultant got through tweaking the numbers, we’re still not meeting the state’s 50-percent waste diversion mandate— the consultant says we’re just under 44 percent.
That’s better than previously believed. But it’s still not “success.”
They’ll hear from people who say it’s silly to care about such things, since the vast majority of Santa Claritans don’t mind paying the exorbitant fees. If you don’t mind paying it, why should anyone go to bat for you? Maybe we are a bunch of rubes.
And the council will hear from people who blame this newspaper for this issue being on the table, as if there’s something wrong with calling attention to a city contract that charges taxpayers a fee that’s much higher than what they could otherwise pay.
Ask yourself: What possible reason could there be to sign this contract without even testing the waters to see what better deal might be out there?
There is no ethical reason.
It’s a sad commentary. If all goes as expected Tuesday night, money and power will win out over what’s right. The council will cast that 3-2 vote, and three council members will protect the few, the moneyed influential interests, rather than the common taxpayer who does not care enough to object.
And the fleecing of Santa Clarita will continue.
Tim Whyte is The Signal’s managing editor. His column appears Sundays.
