ArchiveSCV
the-signal.com. The Santa Clarita Valley Signal. Back to the collection.

· the-signal.com, Wayback capture

Black ’n Whyte

Dumping some trash thoughts on the City Council

Five letters to the members of the Santa Clarita City Council:

Dear Councilman Bob Kellar,

Bob, I owe you an apology. I’m going to eat a little crow here, and considering the circumstances, I am glad to do so.

I know you have been under unbelievable pressure the past couple of weeks, and I know you have been lobbied heavily by both sides in the debate over whether to sign a new contract with the existing trash haulers— Waste Management Inc. and Republic Services— or put the franchises out to bid to see if we can get a better deal for taxpayers.

I don’t know everything that happened behind the scenes, but going into Tuesday’s vote I believed the easiest thing for you to do would have been to side with Jo Anne Darcy and Frank Ferry, and hand the contract over to the current haulers without making them compete for it.

That’s what I thought you would do.

And I said so in this space— twice. I predicted a 3-2 vote that would benefit two national trash giants at the expense of local taxpayers. You were the “swing” vote, and it was the consensus among council observers that you did not relish the role.

I am glad to be wrong on this one.

Thank you, Bob, for your grace under pressure and for voting on taxpayers’ behalf to put the contracts out to bid. Thanks, too, for your eloquent explanation of what this vote was about— and what it was not about. It’s not about Karl McCarthy, Waste Management’s local general manager. This community likes Karl, and deservedly so. He’s generous, gregarious and hard-working . But this isn’t personal— this is, as you said, about getting the best deal for taxpayers, the best combination of service and price.

We may ultimately get that from Waste Management, but until the hauler is forced to compete for our business, we have no “hammer” to use in negotiations.

Your vote, and the speech that preceded it, showed courage in the face of immense pressure. You wrestled with a difficult issue and settled it on principle.

I have always respected you, Bob. But never more than I did on Tuesday night.

* * *

Dear Councilman Cameron Smyth,

A friend of mine told me he’s going to save a copy of the videotape of Tuesday night’s City Council meeting, so he can show it to you many years from now and tell you, “This is the night you became a man.”

A stretch? Maybe. But as a leader, this night was as pivotal as they come.

You have matured a great deal as a councilman in this past year. You are the junior member of the council, making decisions and casting votes with people who, for the most part, have been leading this community since you were a child.

You held your own. And you stuck to your guns. Your explanation of why the contract should be put to bid was eloquent, rational and delivered with level sincerity.

You stood up to Waste Management, whose attorneys sent you a threatening letter a week and a half ago. You stood up to movers and shakers who lined up in support of Waste Management in an attempt to protect their source of donations to their favorite charities.

Money buys influence. It takes guts to stand up to such a display of power.

And, in an exchange that I found entertaining, you shut down an activist from the San Fernando Valley who made disrespectful, out-of-order comments during your speech on the issue.

You told her that, here in Santa Clarita, we don’t interrupt the person who has the floor, and that while her behavior may be representative of how they do things down there in the city of Los Angeles, that’s not how we do them here.

Bravo, councilman.

You hit the nail on the head so many times on Tuesday— perhaps never more so than when you said you were elected to represent all of our community’s residents, including the ones who didn’t care enough to attend Tuesday’s meeting and even those who don’t care enough to vote.

I saw on Tuesday night a lot of the qualities of your father, Clyde, who is deservedly one of the most respected men in this valley’s history.

Build on that.

* * *

Dear Councilwoman Jo Anne Darcy,

One vote does not erase decades of outstanding community service. Through all of this, I firmly believe your record earns you a place among our most cherished citizens. Nothing you have done changes that.

But in a letter to me published one week ago today, you mentioned the trash vote’s potential impact on the legacy you would leave. I must respectfully disagree with your interpretation of that impact.

If a “legacy” were determined by one vote, this vote would have established you as someone who protected the few at the expense of many, as someone who fought for big, out-of-town businesses so taxpayers could provide a multi-million-dollar handout. It would have cast you as someone who promoted corporate welfare rather than the interests of all those you represent. It’s truly unfortunate: This was your last major vote on the council after serving for a decade and a half. I hoped you would depart on a stronger note.

Still, to use the popular current vernacular, “at the end of the day” I don’t think this vote is what will shape your legacy. If it had, it would have been a dramatically different legacy than the one you truly leave behind, the one that depicts the bigger picture of Jo Anne Darcy’s record of service to this community.

* * *

Dear Councilwoman Laurene Weste,

You have been portrayed in many circles as a councilwoman bent on ousting the city manager at all costs. While I may agree that a change in leadership at City Hall has the potential to benefit the city, it seems true that your aggressive approach last year diverted a lot of attention from the very real and legitimate issues related to the trash crisis.

Applying 20-20 hindsight, your biggest errors in the past year had a lot less to do with substance than they did with style. Wisely, in recent months you have backed off from some of the tactics that gave your opponents ammunition to use against you.

And at its core, you were right about the trash issue. As last year’s debate over the matter revved up, you were the first current council member to really start doing the homework. You were the first to start asking the tough questions. You made many people uncomfortable, and you took a great deal of heat for it. Your year was stressful, but you never wavered. You stuck to your guns, regardless of how much of a beating you took in the rumor mill and in a San Fernando Valley newspaper, which for some strange reason has been determined to protect the status quo in Santa Clarita. I respect your diligence and your resolve through difficult circumstances.

There’s a saying journalists like, and I think it also applies sometimes to government: “Comfort the afflicted, and afflict the comfortable.”

You have done that, Laurene.

* * *

Dear Mayor Frank Ferry,

There’s a line in “An American President” that goes something like, “You have a bigger problem, Mr. President. You just lost my vote.”

If the citizens of the Santa Clarita Valley were paying attention to your words and actions Tuesday, Frank, you would not be re-elected on April 9. But I’m sure they’re not, so you should have no worries at all.

Your handling of the trash issue provided insight into your method of being a politician: You protect your money people.

At no point during the debate did you address the real interests of all of your constituents. Instead, you focused on the injustice you believed was perpetrated on the haulers— particularly your friends at Waste Management, which donated $10,000 to one of your favorite local political organizations at the height of the negotiations for the new trash contract.

And, showing the mark of all desperate politicians, you blamed the media.

That’s where you really lost me, Frank.

In your pre-vote speech on the issue, you tried to hang the entire controversy on this newspaper. I demand a retraction of your false and defamatory statements, Frank. We did not end up debating the trash franchises Tuesday night because of “faulty reporting,” as you falsely claimed.

This newspaper and its staff are not perfect. We have had a misstep or two along the way, and we’ve made a couple of truly unfortunate errors. But our coverage on the whole has been accurate and has pointed out legitimate issues related to the franchises and the city’s failure to comply with state recycling law.

And then there’s The Video.

Frank, the only conceivable reason for you to dredge up The Video at this late date is that it was a tactic of desperation to cast the newspaper in a bad light, to divert attention from the real issue.

For those just joining the story: Frank contended Tuesday that this dispute occurred because this newspaper falsely reported on a videotape that was purported to show a top city official leaving a hotel room with someone other than his wife.

The details of The Video have not been repeated here since last May because, to be honest, I’m not convinced it exists, and in any case it’s not relevant to the matter that was before the council Tuesday night. In fact, the video became such a distraction from the real issue that I now regret publishing the information, even though our account of the public record was accurate. But Frank trotted out the matter again, and I feel compelled to respond.

Frank, I think you’re the only one who believes that video was relevant Tuesday.

Here’s what you said: “How did we get here tonight? There was an article, and the article in paraphrase said that our city manager, there was a video, and the video resulted in blackmail... and the rates were set high because there was this video and blackmail. And we have this meeting behind closed doors where we’re told there is no video, they only reported part of the story, so we say, ‘Slap on the hand, bad reporting,’ we give (the city manager) our confirmation, but another grenade was thrown in, and so all of a sudden, because of this video, we’re now going to go make sure our trash audit is OK.”

A couple of things, Frank.

First of all, the story did not conclude the video existed. The story reported on the public record of a former city employee’s harassment lawsuit against the city— a lawsuit that netted her a $325,000 settlement. That employee alleged the video to exist, but her allegation was never proven, and the story quoted a city attorney as saying there was no evidence whatsoever of its existence.

Regardless, the video was only peripheral to that story’s bigger question, and the bigger issues that have been on the table for the past year-plus : Why were city trash rates set in 1996 based on inflated hauler costs, thus giving Santa Claritans an artificially high rate, and why is the city failing to meet state diversion mandates?

Not one person in City Council chambers Tuesday night could honestly say the alleged video was the reason for that night’s trash debate. No one else did.

Send me the retraction, Frank, and I’ll publish it.

Your statements were a desperate, transparent move to blame the media and save the contract for your friends at Waste Management. You protected the Money People, not the taxpayers.

The final irony Tuesday night was when I met our reporter at TGI Friday’s to debrief after the meeting and you were there, sharing a table with the guys from Waste Management. They’re good guys. That’s never been the issue. Their customer service has never been the issue. The issues have been failure to meet diversion requirements, the extremely high cost of the service and the company’s success in influencing officials through its generosity to favored local organizations.

A council member can have a post-meeting debriefing with anyone he wants. There’s nothing illegal about that. But I believe that encounter at TGIF was a window into Frank Ferry’s position on the trash issue: Waste Management lost a key vote and you were there commiserating with them. You were influenced by all of the wrong factors, shirking your responsibility to represent the entire community, and all the while trying to wrongly blame the newspaper for the problems the city has had.

What I’m about to say may not worry you, Frank, because the polling I’ve heard has you at the front of the pack of 12 candidates on April 9. Your re-election is all but assured, due to a well-financed and well-organized campaign.

But if I may borrow from Annette Bening’s character in “An American President”:

You have a bigger problem, Mr. Mayor. You just lost my vote.

Tim Whyte is The Signal’s managing editor. His column appears Sundays.

Image not recoveredmugwhyte.jpg

← Back to 2002

About this record

How it was held, read and classified

Record details

Morris ID
Not a Morris ID. This record is keyed ts-df:/editorial/whyte/0302/033102b.html.
System
date-file pages (/desk/MMYY/MMDDYY.html)
Reading copy
the-signal.com
Chosen by: only copy held. On this copy: words 2,204 (e-mail addresses counted as one token); reader comments 0 (counted, not reproduced here); images 1.
Extracted by
datefile:START_STORY
signal-extract/0.15 (2026-11-16)

Other copies

Held
None. The holding has this article from one host only.

How it was classified

Label
clearly-local
Judgment
A machine’s (recorded as machine), kept as one so it can be revisited.
Classifier
signal-localclass/0.7 (2026-11-12)
Local signals
  • url:datefile_editorial
  • byline:staff_marker [managing editor]
  • text:valley_names [2 distinct/8 mentions: Santa Clarita, City Council]
  • text:valley_elected_official “Cameron Smyth”
National signals
none fired
Scores
local 9, national 0