ArchiveSCV
the-signal.com. The Santa Clarita Valley Signal. Back to the collection.

· the-signal.com, Wayback capture

Black 'n Whyte

What do numbers really say about Nordy deal?

You can make a survey say anything you want. Just ask any political scientist or survey researcher. It's all in how you ask the questions — and how you tabulate the results.

The Newhall Land and Farming Co. knows this, too. Witness its research campaign designed to gather steam for its proposal to bring a Nordstrom to the Valencia Town Center mall.

Let the record reflect that I have nothing against Newhall Land or Nordstrom, other than the fact that my wife would surely get to know all the sales clerks on a first-name basis. Further, I'm not yet sure whether I'll favor or oppose the incentive deal calling for Newhall Land to front the retailer $32 million to come home to Valencia, then for the city to kick back most of the increased sales tax revenue over the first decade or two after the store opens to reimburse Newhall Land for $20 million of the incentive. It all depends on what shape the final terms take.

On one hand, such a deal rankles; why should we pay them for the privilege of having them open a profit-making store? And on the other hand, such is the real-life politics of attracting major retailers these days, and the growing, sophisticated SClarita population wants a big upscale store like a Nordstrom. The only way to get it these days is to use incentives, often involving a share of the increased sales tax. We can pay, and have Nordstrom, or we can not pay, and continue letting sales tax escape the SCV as shoppers head over the hill into the "other" valley.

I suspect the right thing for the city will be to simply strike a more appealing deal. Any good negotiator will tell you never to bite on the first offer. It's a matter of getting from the asking price to the best price. Newhall Land's asking price is $20 million. The city, guaranteed, is working at knocking that price down, altering the terms, or getting other goodies out of Newhall Land (or maybe a combination of all three). If there's more in it for the city than a mere guarantee that sales tax revenue won't actually drop (and that's about the size of it right now), maybe it'll be more palatable to the masses.

Remember: There's always the possibility that Nordstrom and Newhall Land will put a store on other Newhall Land property, outside the city. There ought to be some way to keep it in Santa Clarita, decrease the city's long-term obligation, place more of the burden on the developer or get substantial concessions in return.

Those details aside: We are here today to talk about Newhall Land's research strategies —Êfocusing in particular on two recently used vehicles.

First, there was the survey.

Newhall Land commissioned a professional research firm to survey residents about the plan to bring Nordy into town, including their attitudes toward the proposed $20 million deal.

The report came back sounding quite convincing: Newhall Land announced 68 percent of those surveyed viewed the "incentive program" as positive or neutral.

Wow! Convincing, yes?

Not really. Take out the "neutral" people — including 4 percent who "changed their opinion" when confronted with a follow-up question asking whether they'd approve of the incentive package as a "last option" —Êand you're left with 43 percent who actually viewed it in a positive way to begin with.

Further, you can crunch the numbers the opposite way: 57 percent viewed it as negative or neutral.

See? You can make a survey say anything. It just depends on how you want to use the results. This doesn't mean all survey research is skewed; it merely means survey research can be skewed, and in this case, creative tallying painted the results in a positive, yet misleading, light.

If there's real value in the results with respect to that question, it can be broken down as follows: 43 percent viewed it as positive, 21 percent were neutral and 36 percent were opposed. So, the "positives" outnumbered the "negatives" by a margin of 43-36 percent — certainly not a mandate, and certainly not as impressive as the original 68 percent figure.

That creative number-crunching, by the way, is not unusual. Everyone who commissions a survey does it — including your own city. I just think everyone ought to have their eyes open about it.

Newhall Land's second research vehicle was put in action only recently, and the results aren't in yet, but I guarantee this: It will result in Newhall Land being able to claim X number of local residents expressed support for the incentive deal.

You see, they sent out a mailer with "response cards" on which people can say that, yes, they support the deal. But there's no box where you can check "no."

Further, the accompanying information sheet is clearly worded to evoke a positive response — which is basically fine, except it goes to the point of being disingenuous. It's a marketing tactic, not a vehicle for objective information.

For example, it concludes that the incentive deal would come at "no cost" to the city. Well, that's a matter of semantics and speculation. It seems as if the odds favor increased mall sales tax revenue if Nordy comes to town, but given all the imminent growth in the area it seems as if the odds favor increased mall sales tax revenue even if Nordy doesn't come here. Who's to say conclusively which part of the sales tax increase will be attributable to Nordstrom? (By the way, the behind-the-scenes word is that all parties acknowledge this, so don't be surprised to see the proposal restructured accordingly.)

I may endorse some version of this deal, but even I recognize there may be a "cost" to the city. If nothing else you can look at that $20 million as a "cost." The question is whether the benefits outweigh the costs. They probably will, to the extent that the city may realize a net gain even after the sales tax kickbacks, but we should at least be forthcoming about it.

One more thing. Remember that survey? Well, here's how those results were referred to in Newhall Land spokeswoman Marlee Lauffer's letter accompanying the fact sheet: "Recent research studies show an overwhelming desire of area shoppers to have Nordstrom in the community, and approval of the incentive arrangement that is needed to bring them to a new location — a financial arrangement Newhall Land would underwrite and would be at no cost to the city."

Cripes, Marlee. You're one of my favorite people in the whole world, but that's an awful generous assessment of the numbers. Remember, only 43 percent of the survey respondents liked the incentive plan, 36 percent didn't and the jury was out for 21 percent. If it were put to a referendum today (which, I think, is a bad idea), I doubt it would be approved by an overwhelming majority.

Then there's the matter of those "yes only" response cards.

Some folks may not fault Newhall Land for this ploy, and in a sense, I guess I don't, either: They're trying to build a case, so they're not interested in how many people oppose it. But the problem is, when the material is so obviously skewed to elicit a specific response, and the only response option is to endorse the deal, credibility goes out the window. When those response cards are tallied and Newhall Land reports that, say, 2,500 people sent in postcards indicating their support, there's no way to tell how many would have sent in postcards indicating their opposition if that had been an option.

Not that the number of responses should be a deciding factor. Ultimately, City Council members will have to decide whether to accept, reject or counter-offer based on their own independent assessment of what's in the city's best interests — not on some unscientific straw poll.

Besides. I'm sure by now our City Council knows: You can make a survey say just about anything you want.

Tim Whyte is The Signal's managing editor. His column appears Sundays.

← Back to 1999

About this record

How it was held, read and classified

Record details

Morris ID
Not a Morris ID. This record is keyed ts-df:/editorial/whyte/040499.html.
System
other
Reading copy
the-signal.com
Chosen by: only copy held. On this copy: words 1,350 (e-mail addresses counted as one token); reader comments 0 (counted, not reproduced here); images 0.
Extracted by
datefile:SLUG_to_rule
signal-extract/0.15 (2026-11-16)

Other copies

Held
None. The holding has this article from one host only.

How it was classified

Label
clearly-local
Judgment
A machine’s (recorded as machine), kept as one so it can be revisited.
Classifier
signal-localclass/0.7 (2026-11-12)
Local signals
  • byline:staff_marker [managing editor]
  • text:valley_names [7 distinct/41 mentions: Santa Clarita, SCV, Valencia, Newhall, Newhall Land, City Council, Town Center]
National signals
none fired
Scores
local 6, national 0