Suppose I have a tree in my back yard.
And suppose I decide I want a little more sunlight and a little less shade in my back yard.
Who should decide whether I get to chop that tree down? Isn’t it my tree?
Obviously, matters like 1, 700-home developments and 1, 800-space college parking lots are much more complicated than that, and I admit it wouldn’t be fair to boil those questions down into such simple terms.
But I got to thinking about the trees quite a bit lately, thanks to a pair of local issues and a much-appreciated vacation. I saw trees on my vacation, a needed break from Newspaper Hell.
I mean, I really saw trees. I saw nature. Rubbed some of it all over my legs, arms and face. Sweated on dirt trails. Stumbled over rocks. Peered at vast expanses of scenery from scary-high perches. Ate lunch under a river-carved rock overhang, which was dripping hundred-year-old water that finally seeped its way out of sandstone.
We camped and hiked in Zion National Park and the Grand Canyon, which starts to look like a whole lot more than a big hole in the ground once you actually get below the rim.
Those things, folks, are treasures. And while I’m as fond as anyone of the mighty Santa Clarita Valley oak tree, I’m not sure I can see elevating it to the same status. Especially when it sits on someone else’s property.
Yet that’s exactly what some local activists wish to do.
Don’t get me wrong. I love the oak trees and I think as few of them should be chopped down as possible. And I think it’s a damn shame when some developer axes a 200-year-old oak. But we can’t simply label every tree as a public resource just because we can see it. Sometimes, a tree is private property.
A few weeks back, when The Newhall Land and Farming Co. had the audacity to actually chop down trees on its own property, the developer’s foes lamented the demise of the oaks.
Never mind that, under the terms of Newhall Land’s county-granted approval and a recent court victory, it had a green light to clear out as many as 146 oaks to build its 1, 712-home Westridge golf course community.
And never mind that, even if 146 trees were removed, the project still preserved about 89 percent of the 1,375 oaks on the site, along Interstate 5.
And never mind that the trees were on private property.
“What a resource we are losing,” lamented an activist.
We?
Again, don’t get me wrong. I love trees. I cherish my chances to visit places that have been preserved, protected and made available to the public, places like the Big Sur coast, the gold country of the Sierras, and now, Zion. I cherish the national forest that surrounds the SClarita valley— God help anyone who tries to touch that— and I cherish the oaks that give character to local hills. Sometimes I think we should have found some way, over the years, to bring more of those hills into public ownership.
I even cherish those trees in that Westridge savanna along I-5 . And I think any development on an oak-studded site should do whatever it can to preserve as many trees as possible, while still allowing the land owner to develop property within reason and without causing undue burdens on the neighbors.
But unlike the trees in a national park, those aren’t my trees. They belong to someone else. We can’t make them “ours” by merely saying it is so. And other than providing a nice view as I zip along I-5 , those trees aren’t available for my enjoyment at all. They’re behind a fence and gates with prominently posted signs that indicate trespassing isn’t such a hot idea.
“What a resource we are losing.”
I can relate to the emotions. If I were king, and I didn’t need to make a buck by building a golf course and “executive” homes, I’d leave oak savannas like the Westridge site alone. I wouldn’t chop down a single tree. Frankly, I wouldn’t build Westridge at all. I’d turn the site into a park and open it up to the public with nature trails.
As much as that new golf course will benefit the community, I’ll be disappointed the first time I drive by and don’t see the view I’ve seen for nearly a quarter-century . But it boils down to this: It’s not really our resource. I’m not king. It’s not my land. It’s not public land. It’s a private ranch.
Those trees are on someone’s private property. And while I agree with development regulations that compel a landowner to take the trees into account and replace them twice over, it’s not our place to go so far as to say, “Not one of your trees shall be touched by a chainsaw.”
The situation at College of the Canyons this past week was a little different. Those were, in fact, our trees; it’s a public community college, and oak preservationists had every right to consider those trees “our” resource.
But the COC board of trustees did the right thing: It modified plans for a new parking lot so half as many trees would be destroyed— thus giving due consideration to the project’s impact on the oaks— yet, the board recognized the overriding considerations and challenges facing a college that soon will be expected to educate twice as many people as it does now.
The two instances— Westridge and COC— were very different in that one of the sites was public, one was private. But in both cases, it seems a significant effort has been made to consider the impact on oaks.
These are not easy decisions, to be sure. And I don’t think we should chop down oak trees with joyful abandon.
But we have to balance our love of the trees with a healthy dose of reason, and recognize that, sometimes, other considerations come into play.
And sometimes, the trees aren’t ours to keep.
Tim Whyte is The Signal’s managing editor. His e-mail address is [email protected] .
