It’s supposed to be a bedrock principle of our criminal justice system: A suspect is presumed innocent until proven guilty.
Yet the cynical side of each of us often leaps to conclusions about the guilt or innocence of a suspect long before a verdict has been reached, sometimes before charges have even been filed. And in some cases, before the suspect’s identity is even known.
We in The Media are guilty of it, and frankly so are law enforcement agencies and society at large.
This was illustrated in the past week by the fallout after a woman reported that she was raped in a parking lot outside a popular local sports bar.
Law enforcement officials, after interviewing the woman, told newspaper reporters that a rape had occurred. The reporters, in turn, wrote stories— in our newspaper and at least one other— reporting that a rape had occurred. Headline writers then wrote headlines stating a rape occurred.
That may prove to be the case.
One problem: No one really knew for sure, at the time, whether a rape had occurred. What we did know was a rape had been reported.
There is a significant difference between the two, and I think too often everyone involved in the dissemination of such information forgets the importance of preserving that presumption of innocence, at least when it comes to the language used.
I use the example of our story on the reported rape not to pick on any given reporters or editors— after all, the same approach was taken by the Sheriff’s Department and at least two different newspapers. Rather, I use this example to point out what seems to be a trend in reporting in general.
In this instance, all we initially had was a woman who claimed to be the victim of a horrible attack. I have no reason to doubt her; I have never met her, and if she was indeed the victim of a crime I think it’s important that we bring the perpetrator(s) to justice. There are few things more horrifying than rape, and it is not to be taken lightly.
But in the interest of accuracy and clarity, reporters and editors have to remember the importance of using “qualifier” words like, “alleged,” or “reported.” Without them, we have essentially convicted the suspects, whoever they may turn out to be.
Journalism textbooks will tell you those words don’t mean much in a legal sense; if you are accused of committing libel by incorrectly identifying someone as having committed a crime, it’s not likely to matter whether you said they committed the crime or “allegedly” committed the crime. Further, a lot of writers don’t like to use those words because they believe they unnecessarily “bog down” news copy.
But it does matter if we’re pursuing accuracy, which is obviously a goal of every self-respecting newspaper. It should matter to anyone who disseminates information on reported crimes.
At the time of that incident report, we did not know with certainty that a rape had occurred. We knew a rape had been reported, or alleged, and we knew we had an alleged victim who provided sheriff’s deputies with a harrowing account of that evening’s events. It’s our responsibility, then, to cast the story in those terms.
Too often these days, it seems media outlets— electronic and print—Êforget that responsibility. Arrests are reported as if the suspect is already guilty. The commission of a crime is reported as if it were known fact, when it is based only on the word of one person. Watch your nightly newscast and see if you can spot the instances in which a suspect is “convicted” prematurely.
To an extent, we even did it on the recent story of the three dogs being killed in Sand Canyon. Everyone pretty much leaped to the conclusion that the dogs were intentionally killed by someone, which does in fact seem likely, given the circumstances. Certainly, we know something killed the dogs, that much is obvious— but it has not been established with certainty that a crime occurred. Yes, that appears to be the case, but we don’t know it.
Often a criminal suspect, upon arrest, can’t help but be portrayed in a light that implies guilt. It’s nearly impossible to cover the crime beat without the accused being perceived by readers or viewers as being guilty.
Yet it remains our obligation to exercise due diligence, and to watch those fine points: Did a crime definitely occur or was one reported, with the facts to be determined later? When the circumstances seem to indicate a crime occurred, what does it take to verify it as fact? Did the police nab a robber or a robbery suspect? Is it a killer’s trial or a murder suspect’s trial?
These distinctions don’t jump out at you in news copy. But it’s important, in the pursuit of accuracy, to draw them.
Tim Whyte is The Signal’s managing editor.
