Are we that weak?
I don’t think so. As I celebrate the Fourth of July today with my family, I’m comfortable in the knowledge that this nation is strong enough to withstand many challenges: Economic crises, foreign wars, political strife, social upheaval.
A burning flag.
We can handle that, can’t we? This nation has survived a civil war,
two world wars, a plethora of various other battles here and abroad. We’ve bounced back from a major depression, we’ve mourned, then set our collective jaw and moved on when our presidents were assassinated. We’ve fought each other over civil rights, we’ve rebuilt after inner-city riots and we even got through that whole Monica Lewinsky thing relatively unscathed.
Surely, a nation capable of these things cannot be threatened by the symbolic burning of a flag, even if it is the one we hold most dear.
Make no mistake: Even the vast majority of those who say it should be legal to burn the flag find such an act extremely distasteful, and cherish the values that the flag represents.
First and foremost among those values is freedom.
That’s what our veterans have fought for. They haven’t fought and died for the symbol itself. They fought and died to preserve what the symbol represents.
I know many of those veterans take the burning of our flag in protest as a personal insult, and I don’t blame them. In fact, Signal Publisher Will Fleet and I were talking at an awards luncheon last weekend, and he told me about the column he had written for the next day’s paper on this very subject.
He told me he wanted to make it clear to the readers: If he saw someone burning a flag in protest, he’d intervene physically in an attempt to stop them from doing it. In other words, he’d risk criminal assault charges to stop someone from carrying out such a protest.
“That’s how strongly I feel about it,” he said.
But on the flip side of that, he firmly believes, as I do, that the government should not, under any circumstances, make flag-burning illegal— unless, of course, the act of burning a particular flag violates some other legitimate law, like a fire safety ordinance.
Those two feelings may seem in conflict to some, but they’re not. It’s possible to passionately, sincerely love that flag and what it represents, yet believe in your heart of hearts that it would be wrong, even a violation of the First Amendment, to pass legislation that outlaws the destruction of the cherished symbol.
Like Will, I want to make it perfectly clear that I do, in fact, cherish that symbol, but I cherish what it represents even more. When I go camping with my family this weekend, I’ll fly the stars and stripes over my trailer, and each time I see the flag, I’ll be reminded of the freedoms that it represents.
It would, in a way, be an insult to that very flag if our government were to start diminishing those freedoms and rights by selectively applying them through legislation.
Our House of Representatives, stirring up a debate that probably didn’t need stirring unless you want to wrap yourself in the flag in order to get elected (talk about desecration...), has passed a proposed constitutional amendment to outlaw destruction of the stars and stripes in protest. The proposal next goes to the Senate, where many believe it will not gain enough votes to pass.
Let’s hope not.
This is not a matter to be taken lightly. Our Constitution has been amended just 26 times, including the initial 10 amendments contained in the Bill of Rights, since it was enacted in 1791. We have amended it for a few silly or superfluous purposes— Prohibition comes to mind— but mostly for noble ones, like guaranteeing women the right to vote and putting an end to slavery.
And of those amendments, the one that was deemed so important by the crafters of that Constitution so as to be listed first, is the one guaranteeing our right to free speech. The First Amendment does not say, of course, “You have the right to burn the flag.” But it does say the government shall make no law infringing upon our freedom of speech, or of the press.
Burning a flag, in the context of political protest, is a form of speech. It’s a means of making a point, and provided that it does not create a danger toward others, or damage public or private property, it’s a form of protest that must be tolerated.
Aren’t we strong enough to handle that?
Is this nation so weak that it must# create a new law— amend its most carefully crafted governing document— in order to ban a form of protest that disturbs many, yet physically harms no one?
I hope not.
Tim Whyte is The Signal’s managing editor. His column appears Sundays.
