Pursuing excellence can be a daring thing. And often, but not always, those who lead others to excellence are controversial figures. This is especially true in athletics, from the professionals right down to high school sports.
Witness Harry Welch.
Harry was one of three candidates to replace Larry Mohr as football coach at Canyon High School after Mohr resigned on the heels of a school district reprimand for failing to heed warnings that he should avoid potentially
compromising situations with the school’s head cheerleader.
Canyon Principal Vicki Engbrecht announced this week that, after interviews were conducted with Welch, Canyon assistant Jack Bowman and Canyon freshman coach Mike Kane, Bowman would be Mohr’s replacement as the varsity head coach.
Bowman was 36-27-2 as the head coach at my alma mater, Saugus High School, from 1991 until his resignation in 1996. (I’m always glad to see a coach build a winning record at Saugus, and I’m looking forward to the day when the Centurions’ program puts all the ingredients in place to win a championship or two— including the competition for The Signal’s Victory Bell, which hasn’t been in Saugus’ possession since I was a junior way back in 19-cough-into-your-hand .)
Bowman was touted by Engbrecht as the right guy for the kids at Canyon, and I have to give Engbrecht credit for that sentiment, because this is, after all, about what’s best for the kids.
I don’t know Jack Bowman, and I wish him the greatest success as a coach at Canyon. I’m sure he is an outstanding candidate for the job, and I’m sure he is a dedicated student of the game. I hope he is able to turn the Cowboy team into a winner, and I hope even more that he succeeds in teaching his students the many important lessons that accompany scholastic sports, regardless of wins and losses. I hope, frankly, that he and the Cowboys achieve such success that I will be forced to eat the following words.
But I still can’t help feeling this was an opportunity missed— and that Canyon High School has taken the “safe” route rather than the daring one.
What’s “best for the kids” is an overriding motive for all of us. And high school sports are about a lot more than winning and losing. But man, given a choice, I think we’d all rather have what is perceived as a real shot at excellence— even if it means taking a risk.
If you’re the one choosing the head coach, Harry Welch is a risk, except in the win-loss column. He had his share of controversial moments in his 12-year tenure at Canyon, during which he led the Cowboys to a 120-31-2 record, including a record 46-game winning streak and three CIF titles before resigning in 1994.
There was the well-publicized illegal Canyon practice that brought CIF sanctions against Welch, who took the high school sports governing body to court, alleging he was denied due process, and won an out-of-court settlement.
That was accompanied, in the early-1990s , by a post-game temper tantrum when an official’s bad call cost Canyon an important game, and a post-game altercation with a player’s parent.
Harry is a passionate guy. Appointing him head coach would come with an element of risk: Would he stir controversy? Maybe.
As an English teacher, he brings that passion to the classroom. As a football coach, he brought that passion to the sidelines. It manifested itself differently in the context of sport than in academics, but it’s there in both cases. (Harry once told me something like, “If you knew me outside of football, you’d never describe me as a jock.”)
But the appointment of Harry Welch as the coach of a high school team would bring with it instant recognition that the program means business— that a winner is under construction.
Does that guarantee success? Of course not. But there’s no denying the credentials of a guy like Harry Welch. To choose him would have been to thrust the program into a higher regional profile, and to impose upon it higher expectations of success, not only among Santa Clarita residents and media but also among observers from the greater Los Angeles area.
It would have been a daring move. It would have brought in a coach who is a colorful character with an unmatched ability to inspire, to extract excellence from high school kids, and give them an opportunity to taste victory in a fashion few people ever experience.
It wouldn’t have been the “safe” choice. But it sure would have been exciting, for Canyon High School and the entire Santa Clarita Valley.
I wonder what might have been.
Tim Whyte is The Signal’s managing editor. His column appears Sundays.
