I really hated to see Howard & Phil’s go, and not just because I like cowboy hats and expensive boots.
Howard & Phil’s was one of those terrific staples of a town like Santa Clarita: It was a locally founded and owned business that had gone “ big-time ,” with locations sprouting up in malls all over the Southwest. I had no personal connection with the business, but I was proud to see one of Santa Clarita’s own succeed on a broad scale.
The business had been started nearly 40 years ago with one store in Canyon Country, and at its zenith was a chain of 52 stores. The founders—ÊHoward and Phyllis McKeon— had passed the family business on to their five sons, one of whom would become Santa Clarita’s first mayor and, then, a respected member of Congress.
It was an all-American success story, but things started to head south in the mid-1990s , and by the time the Howard & Phil’s Chapter 11 reorganization plan was invalidated by a federal bankruptcy court, the western wear chain had assets listed at $2.8 million against liabilities of $7.7 million.
And now, the chain formerly owned by Rep. Howard “Buck” McKeon and his four brothers has closed— including the relocated version of that very first store in Canyon Country— and its assets have been sold for a little over 10 cents on the dollar to a Utah boot company, Montana Industries. Montana has reopened the former Howard & Phil’s in the Valencia mall and plans to reopen additional stores under the new name.
I won’t get into all of the details, nor will I profess to know the real causes of the fall of Howard & Phil’s— but factors that have been cited by various observers include declining popularity of western wear, the 1994 earthquake and an overly ambitious expansion plan. (One of the congressman’s former aides actually had the audacity, when the initial bankruptcy story broke a few years ago, to blame the western wear chain’s problems on the economic policies of the Clinton administration. It’s amazing he didn’t throw out his back creating that kind of spin.)
Regardless, it’s unfortunate. Howard & Phil’s was something of an institution in this community, and the McKeon family has long been among the most respected clans in the valley— and deservedly so.
But there’s a threat that the legacy of Howard & Phil’s will be tarnished beyond any damage that can be done by the mere failing of a family business:
They haven’t paid all of their employees.
Eleven former Howard & Phil’s employees in June filed complaints with the state labor board, seeking to recover a combined $11,600 in lost wages.
Again, without getting into the minutiae, the bottom line is that when these employees went to cash their paychecks, the money wasn’t there. In fact, we’re told that in all $25,000 in back wages are owed, but some of the former employees did not file claims out of loyalty to the McKeons.
That’s admirable— but every employee who put in an honest day’s work for an honest wage ought to get paid.
And in truth, some of them may have. We’re not privy to all the details of any arrangements that may have been made with Montana for the former Howard & Phil’s employees, and you never know how some of these situations may have been handled behind the scenes. As we become aware of any new information on that front, we’ll pass it along.
But by all appearances, it looks as if some of the former Howard & Phil’s employees are going to be outta luck: A spokesman for the state Department of Industrial Relations told The Signal last week that, short of filing individual lawsuits, it appears doubtful the employees will be paid.
If they actually have been paid, I applaud the McKeons for making good on those lost wages, and respectfully ask that they let the community and the voters know: Every worker has been made whole.
But if they haven’t been paid, something needs to be done, and it needs to be handled directly by those who owned the business, including the congressman. Regardless of the fact that he hasn’t been involved in the chain’s day-to-day operations since his election to Congress in 1992, he remained part-owner until the end.
In fact, this issue is all the more important to Buck by virtue of his position as an elected official.
Obviously, not every Howard & Phil’s creditor will be paid in full. It’s a fact of life that, when businesses go under, creditors eat it. Banks, suppliers, vendors. They all take a hit, and that’s unfortunate to be sure.
But the one thing that should be sacred is an employee’s wages. They’re the people who should be paid first— and the loss means more to them than anyone else. It really can translate directly to food on the table, rent, diapers... you name it. I guarantee you that lost $11,600 means a helluva lot more to those 11 workers than it does to any bank, or even to the five McKeon brothers.
That’s why they should make good on it, even if it means opening their own personal wallets. Even if their own financial situations now dictate a monthly payment plan. Even if the fine points of the law mean they have to do it surreptitiously.
For five individuals who have done as well as they did for most of the past several decades, $11,600— or, even, $26,000— shouldn’t be too daunting, especially split five ways.
Do the right thing, guys. If there’s one more legacy that Howard & Phil’s should leave, it’s that the McKeon boys paid the people who worked for them.
Tim Whyte is The Signal’s managing editor. His column appears Sundays.
