“What’s he doing?”
It was my almost-4-year-old son, handing me the morning newspaper. Luc was pointing to the front-page photo of a police officer, a SWAT team member.
The SWAT guy was pointing a rifle toward a van, and he was looking for a killer.
His quarry was the man who had sprayed 20 to 30 bullets into the lobby of the North Valley Jewish Community Center, wounding five people— one of them a 5-year-old boy whose wounds would cost him 30 percent of his blood. Authorities believe the same man— who later turned himself in to police in Las Vegas— was also responsible for the shooting death of a postal worker, a Filipino-American who was murdered because he was, according to the suspect, “a target of opportunity” who worked for the government and was non-white .
Luc handed me the newspaper.
“What’s he doing, Daddy?”
The previous day, when I heard about the tragedy in Granada Hills, my heart had gone out to the parents of the children who were hurt, especially the parents of that 5-year-old little boy who was fighting for his life. Now, blindsiding me the next day, came these questions from my own little boy.
“Why does he have a gun, Daddy?”
“He’s a policeman, Luc.”
“What’s he doing?”
“He’s looking for a bad guy, Luc.”
Luc didn’t accept that explanation as being complete. No self-respecting 3-year-old would. He asked the logical follow-up question, as all 3-year-olds do: “Why?”
I mumbled something about how the naughty guy had broken the rules and the policeman was trying to find him to put him in jail. Luc went into an animated role-play about how, if he were the policeman, he’d find the naughty guys and tie them up and put them in jail forever.
That’s the spirit, kid.
The exchange stayed with me that day, as news of the suspect’s arrest and other details of the shooting began to unfold: The suspect had a history of membership in white supremacist groups. He had told the police, when he turned himself in, that he wanted the incident to be a wake-up call to Americans to “kill Jews.” He had been under the impression— fortunately, a false one— that he had “killed the kids” in Granada Hills.
Unfiltered evil.
Later that morning, I passed by the television in the newsroom. The volume was down, but the text on the screen told me the news network was covering a debate that was obviously linked to the Granada Hills shooting:
Should children be told about tragic news stories?
I was too busy to stop and watch, but the question renewed an inner conflict that has hit me on more than one occasion.
I’ve made it no secret to my son that Daddy works at the newspaper. The kid can’t read yet, but when The Signal lands on our porch every morning, Luc knows it’s connected with my job.
And I’ve never really come to grips with what I’m going to do when he does start reading. Will I have to shield my own son from the product I help generate, until we decide he’s old enough to be exposed to the world’s harsh realities?
I think so. Obviously, we’re a community newspaper and we try as much as possible to provide content that’s suitable for family consumption. But sometimes, the news itself shouldn’t be rated any lower than PG-13 . I can’t snap my fingers and change that. So, as proud as I am of our paper, I have to get to it before he does, and make sure I’m comfortable with whatever he may see, or read.
It’s bad enough that pre-schoolers already pick up expressions like “kill the bad guys” in role-playing games played with their peers. I don’t remember teaching my kid the word “kill,” but he seems to have picked it up anyway. And a couple of months back I only reluctantly told him we were flushing one of the fish from our aquarium because said fish was “dead.” Explaining that one was a bear, let me tell you. As a parent, I wasn’t ready for it.
I don’t want him to grow up excessively sheltered, and I remember playing good-guy / bad-guy “games” as a child and still managing to grow up as a basically law-abiding citizen. But I also don’t think kids need to be exposed to some of the world’s more heinous evils.
That’s a conundrum that, I suspect, faces most parents. Kids ask a ton of tough questions, and you have to decide, on the fly, how to handle topics ranging from hate crimes to kids who throw sand at the playground.
I faced both scenarios this week. They were, admittedly, widely varying degrees of evil— one pales in comparison to the other— but they evoke similar questions and similar struggles for answers.
A couple of days after the Granada Hills shootings, we took Luc to a local park to play on the swings and the slides. As Luc was walking from one piece of play equipment to another, he started passing near another little kid who had “brat” written all over him. The kid had a sand shovel, and yes, as Luc passed, the kid threw sand at Luc’s face, unprovoked.
“HEY!” I yelled, instinctively. The kid’s face jolted in my direction, his shocked expression telling me this was not someone who was used to being held accountable for his actions.
Luc was unharmed, and went on his merry way. The other kid threw more sand, this time at no one in particular, but it blew back in his own face, and he walked away rubbing his eyes.
I smiled broadly to myself. Kid had it coming.
Later, on our way home, Luc began the questioning: “Why did that little boy throw sand at me?”
“Well, Luc, maybe his parents didn’t teach him very good manners.”
You know the next question, don’t you? Say it with me: “Why?”
“I don’t know, Luc. Maybe it’s just because some people are nice, and some people are not.”
It’s all as simple as that, and infinitely more complex at the same time. And even though I can’t summon a good answer for it, I don’t blame him one bit for asking the question.
Why?
Tim Whyte is The Signal’s managing editor. His column appears Sundays.
