ArchiveSCV
the-signal.com. The Santa Clarita Valley Signal. Back to the collection.

· the-signal.com, Wayback capture

Black ’n Whyte

Why you can’t shoot from the bushes anymore

The timing couldn’t have been better— or worse.

It was Sept. 10, and we had executed a decision that had been a long time coming: We pulled the plug on the online version of Tell It to The Signal.

The following day, of course, will live in infamy, as terrorists attacked American military and commercial landmarks, and there were those among the Tell-It regulars who were angry that they could not go to the-signal.com and have an instantaneous, live discussion of the day’s tragic events.

I had planned to write a column for the following Sunday, explaining the decision, the reasoning behind it and The Signal’s ongoing efforts to provide Santa Claritans the most open public forum opportunities possible. Needless to say, when Sept. 11 arrived, I put that on hold— along with other aspects of dealing with Tell-It .

In that way, the timing of the online forum’s demise was both blessing and curse. It was a curse to those who were regulars on the forum, and it was a blessing to a community newspaper editor who was better off focusing on the paper’s localized coverage of a national crisis than he would have been if he had to also focus on patrolling a chat room to determine if anyone used the F word when talking about the terrorists.

That, unfortunately, is what Tell-It had become.

It started out as a means of contributing to the newspaper’s longstanding phone-in commentary venue, Tell It to The Signal— which became fondly known to regulars by its unintentional acronym, TITTS.

But the forum quickly evolved from a way to make an online contribution to the TITTS column in the newspaper into a chat room, the material from which was mostly ill-suited for publication, for a wide assortment of reasons ranging from the conversational nature of the posts to the aforementioned affinity for the F word— and alternate ways to spell it that outsmarted our computerized ban on dirty words.

Regardless, TITTS was quite popular, and it developed its own personalities. There were assorted regulars, and most of them used online “handles” that concealed— for the most part— their real identities.

There was Desir Ray, known as much for her cleavage as for her commentary. There was Jammer, who participated religiously despite living out of state. There was Porky the Pig, whose posts were routinely vulgar and quite funny— so funny that, sometimes, I had mixed emotions about removing them from the forum. And there was Deputy Dawg, who ended every post this way: “Deputy Dawg, Woof!”

Some of the commentary on TITTS was pedantic, some of it thoughtful, some of it frisky. It had its up sides.

But it was also a high-maintenance mistress.

The thing that made TITTS so popular was its immediacy. In our instant gratification society, people liked to make a comment and have it appear instantly on the site. That, it would prove, would also be the forum’s downfall: Its “ real-time ” nature prevented the posts from being screened prior to appearing on the site.

There were too many “bad apples” who broke the rules, posting profane or defamatory statements under cover of anonymity. On many occasions we engaged in a frustrating dance with bad-mouthed computer geeks: They would break the rules, we’d remove their posts, they’d break the rules again and we’d ban their IP address from the forum, only to have them find another way around the ban.

Patrolling the forum became a time-consuming , exhausting and never-ending task, one that drained resources that could have been better spent on other aspects of our operation— which, if you’ll remember, exists to produce a community newspaper. Our Web site augments our newspaper, and provides a daily sample of the things you’ll find in each day’s edition of The Signal. We post some, but not all, of our news stories, on the Web site, and while I could see the site’s role expanding in the future, that’s its role now. Our core product is the newspaper, and the TITTS chat room got to the point where it was consuming a disproportionate share of our editorial resources.

And there was, of course, the long-standing and valid philosophical problem many people had with the nature of the forum: Even operating under the rules, people could “shoot from the bushes,” taking potshots at their local political rivals without having to put their name to their comments. I, for one, have always had a great deal more respect for those who are willing to state their opinion and put their name on it. Anonymous commentary is a coward’s commentary.

Despite all this, I admit feeling conflicted about the decision to pull the plug on the online forum. As General Manager Ethel Nakutin and I discussed it, we wrestled with concern about ditching something that appeared to drive a lot of traffic to our Web site. Sure, there were a core of 50 to 75 “regulars” who contributed the vast majority of the posts, but TITTS was a sort of journalistic freeway wreck: It generated a lot of spectator slowing, people who would visit the Web site just to see what the TITTSters were up to.

But in the final analysis, the online TITTS was causing too many headaches, and from a business standpoint it didn’t make sense to keep investing resources to manage it.

So on Monday, Sept. 10, we shut it down, and in its place we added a “send a letter to the editor” link on the Web site that allows readers to click onto a form they can use to send us a letter to the editor for publication. I’m gratified to see that this method of sending us a letter has already proven quite popular. About half the letters we have received about the Sept. 11 terrorist attacks have come to us via that new link— and writers are putting their names to their opinions.

Meanwhile, we’re still offering the phone-in TITTS (you can submit a comment by calling 255-2617 ), and for now we have decided to let the phone-in feature live or die on its own.

If we get call-ins , we’ll run them in the paper, and if we don’t get many calls, I guess you could say our TITTS will shrink until they disappear altogether.

Sorry. I guess I’ve still got a little bit of that chat room humor in me.

Tim Whyte is The Signal’s managing editor.

Image not recoveredmugwhyte.jpg

← Back to 2001

About this record

How it was held, read and classified

Record details

Morris ID
Not a Morris ID. This record is keyed ts-df:/editorial/whyte/0901/093001b.html.
System
date-file pages (/desk/MMYY/MMDDYY.html)
Reading copy
the-signal.com
Chosen by: only copy held. On this copy: words 1,075 (e-mail addresses counted as one token); reader comments 0 (counted, not reproduced here); images 1.
Extracted by
datefile:START_STORY
signal-extract/0.15 (2026-11-16)

Other copies

Held
None. The holding has this article from one host only.

How it was classified

Label
clearly-local
Judgment
A machine’s (recorded as machine), kept as one so it can be revisited.
Classifier
signal-localclass/0.7 (2026-11-12)
Local signals
  • url:datefile_editorial
  • byline:staff_marker [managing editor]
National signals
none fired
Scores
local 6, national 0