The picture was jolting: A mangled, overturned pickup truck, reduced to wreckage along a curvy two-lane road because of an error in judgment— or, maybe, a series of them.
And in the foreground was the driver, his covered, dead body still at the scene as the authorities cared for his wounded passengers and, then, tried to piece together just what happened.
No one wants to see that.
It’s an image that instantly alters one’s thoughts, steers the emotions toward sorrow, even anger, that such avoidable losses persist despite the best efforts of educators, parents and safe-driving publicity campaigns.
That’s precisely why we published the image in the newspaper.
We all try to teach our young drivers to use good judgment, to keep the speed down, to avoid drinking and driving. Yet highway patrol officials speculated this particular driver had failed to learn at least one of those lessons.
There were those who, understandably, objected to our publication of the photo. We received several letters and e-mails in the past week from readers who were appalled that we printed the picture of the scene from the wreck that killed driver Michael David Carlson, 19, and injured his two passengers on Bouquet Canyon Road.
I don’t blame them at all. Their anger is absolutely understandable. Yet I still believe we did the right thing.
When a photo like that is published, it makes the tragedy all the more painful for those who are close to it— and it brings it closer to those who aren’t.
“How would you feel,” they ask, “if that were your loved one?”
The answer is easy: I’d feel horrible. And the picture would pour salt into those emotional wounds.
That’s why the decision to publish such a photo is not so easy. While I’m sure there are those who are convinced otherwise, newspaper editors don’t take such a decision lightly. We don’t relish the opportunity to exacerbate anguish.
It’s our job to report news, and to provide an accurate portrayal of things that happen in our community. Sometimes the news is quite good, and there are many very positive stories to be told in a community such as this.
Sometimes the news is disturbing, maddening. We have to tell those stories, too. And we feel an obligation to tell those stories, sometimes bluntly.
There are, obviously, boundaries of taste for individual newspapers and the media in general— and those boundaries shift as society’s own boundaries do. There are clearly photos none of us would even consider running. Some things are simply too graphic.
But other images tell the story in a powerful way, without necessarily crossing that line. We don’t all agree on where that line is, which is what makes the decision so difficult: publish or don’t publish?
The wreck in which Carlson was killed reminded me of an incident that occurred last year on State Route 14. The wrecks had few similarities, but they resulted in similar dilemmas.
It was around spring break, and several young people from the Antelope Valley were driving on SR 14, their cars packed with their friends en route to a spring break excursion.
They were apparently racing along the freeway, just east of Santa Clarita city limits, when a lane change went tragically wrong.
Several teens were killed as the car rolled off the freeway and down an embankment, and they were ejected from the vehicle.
Then, as now, there was a photo:
The overturned vehicle was at the center of the image, and you could make out the outlines of several of the victims. At the bottom of the photo, a highway patrol officer was in the process of covering one of the bodies.
It wasn’t graphic, per se. But it told the story in a stark way.
We debated whether to run the photo— and our top editorial staffers were divided. Several of us were going back and forth, debating whether to publish the picture. Along came a staffer who was a mother of three. She took a look at the photo and said:
“If it makes even one kid buckle up, I’d run it.”
My decision was made. I ran the photo.
Similarly, last week we had to choose whether to publish the image from the fatal accident on Bouquet Canyon Road.
Speed and alcohol were listed as suspected— though not confirmed— factors in the crash, which was just the latest in a year that has been horribly notable for its youthful highway carnage in the Santa Clarita Valley. Even as Carlson’s truck came to rest on Bouquet Canyon Road, local residents were debating whether Marcus Lellan had been sentenced appropriately for his February crash that killed three of his Canyon High School classmates and an unsuspecting motorist.
We knew the photo would cause pain to those who knew Carlson. But could the photo also spare the pain of those whose traffic wrecks can still be averted? It’s a case of balancing the pain of a tragedy vs. the potential pain of a tragedy yet to occur.
What if even one kid saw that photo, and made a good decision instead of a bad decision?
Even one.
Tim Whyte is The Signal’s managing editor. His column appears Sundays.
