A couple of weeks ago, a friend here at the office told me a local gay activist wanted to meet with me. She suspected it had to do with an objection to our policy on letters to the editor.
More than once, a member of the gay community has called or written to object to the way we handle letters that, for example, oppose gay marriage.
The people who write the anti-gay letters are usually thumping one version or another of the Bible. One can't help but think of them as Swiss cheese: Holier than thou.
The letters, to say the least, irk the local gay community — God, you've gotta give these guys credit for being "out" in a conservative town like Santa Clarita — and when I heard of the request for a meeting, I knew I was going to be put on the hot seat.
That was before Wyoming college student Matthew Shepard was beaten to death and tied to a roadside fencepost, left to die — because he was gay.
It was only one kind of senseless murder, and I watched with some discomfort as it was elevated to a political cause; Shepard did not deserve to die, and it's maddening, absolutely maddening, that he was chosen as the crime victim because he happened to be gay.
But it's also maddening when an innocent child takes a gang member's bullet. It's maddening when an abused wife dies at the hands of someone who vowed to love and cherish her. It's maddening when a drunk driver plows through an intersection and takes the life of an unsuspecting teen-ager.
It's all senseless. It's all detestable.
But every senseless, detestable, maddening murder does not become a national news hook. This one did.
And I can't help but wonder if people intending to show respect for Matthew Shepard, the victim of senseless murder, inadvertently dis-respected him. It almost felt as if the gay community was using the murder of one of its own to make a point. I know the motives, for most, were pure, and the grief, for virtually all, was real. They didn't know Shepard personally, but the crime hit home because any one of them could have been in his place.
But the fallout became almost surreal. It was as if a PR machine swung into action, using Shepard's death to further a cause. On the other side, another PR machine, an evil one, also swung into action, as ultra-religious wackos proclaimed, "God hates fags."
It makes you sick.
All of this brought me back to thinking about those letters. Those damn letters. I know we haven't received the last of them, and we haven't been criticized for the last time for running one.
I'm pretty close to someone who is gay, and maybe they're just being nice, but it seems that he and the man he's dating understand why I handle the situation the way I do. I only hope the rest of the gay community does, too.
Sometimes, it seems as if they don't.
I have my own distaste for these letters. I don't agree with the Derick Dimrys of the world — those who wish to impose their own moral standards on the rest of society.
I've met Derick Dimry, an oft-criticized writer of letters to the editor. I know his wife. They're a nice couple. I don't agree with Derick on the gay issues. Heck, most of his views on other issues are way out there on the right wing, too, so I don't agree with them, either. But he's not one of those who says, "They deserve to be beaten and killed because they're gay." He's a peaceful guy. He sincerely believes homosexuality is a sin, a behavior, not necessarily an inherent quality.
I don't know who's right about that — I suspect Dimry is wrong, but I'm no authority. It's not as clear-cut as, say, skin color. Activists on the gay rights front like to equate positions like Dimry's with racial bigotry — a line of thinking that, I suspect, Dimry would find ironic.
Would I publish a letter, for example, that says black people should not be allowed to marry? Hell no. But I'll run a letter in which someone says gay people shouldn't be allowed to marry, and I resent it when I'm told it's the same as publishing racial bigotry. It's not: One is a skin color, another is a sexual orientation, and they are different if nothing else than by virtue of the fact that they aren't the same thing.
Simple, right? But it's not, and in a way, I see their point. In some sense, Dimry's positions are bigoted: He judges others and, as Webster would say, is "obstinately and unreasonably wedded to a particular belief or creed."
I don't agree with him. But I run his letters, and those of others like him. I take a good deal of heat for it. Sometimes, I let myself resent that heat too much; I become offended when someone accuses me of agreeing with something by virtue of the fact that I allowed it to be expressed in newsprint. In that respect, I need a thicker skin.
In this business, you have to learn to tolerate that with which you disagree. Part of preaching tolerance is tolerating the intolerable. I can't begin to count how many letters we've run that weren't in line with my way of thinking, but this business is all about the free and open dissemination of ideas.
The flip side, of course, is that we can and do set limits. What's within the boundaries, and what's beyond them, so far into the realm of bad taste that we refuse to publish it?
Some calls are easier to make than others. If I get a letter that advocates the beating or killing of people, for any reason, including sexual orientation, it's a no-brainer, an obvious no-run.
However, with topics like gay marriage on the state legislative agenda, and our state senator leading the charge against recognition of gay marriage, it would be tough to say, "We're a First Amendment newspaper and we only publish one side of the debate."
That meeting my friend told me would be requested? I haven't had it yet; the activist was supposed to call me, but hasn't. I suspect the murder of Matthew Shepard put it on the back burner. Understandable. But the subject will be back. And we'll keep making the run- or no-run decisions, on a case-by-case basis.
And not everyone will agree.
* * *
Tim Whyte is managing editor of The Signal. His commentary appears on Sundays.
