OK, let’s get one thing straight: Nobody thought the fund-raising calendar was going to be like something from Playboy.
Not for one second.
No one was talking frontal nudity, even for a nanosecond. No one believed the respected women leaders of this community were going to do the full monty for the camera, and no one was going to be taking their posing directions from Bob Guccione or Larry Flynt.
But what was under consideration, according to the information we received earlier this week, was the following:
A tastefully done calendar in which local women leaders would have been pictured in poses and situations that led the viewer to believe the women were naked.
In other words, strategically placed props would have been employed, covering all of the important parts but showing a bare shoulder here, a calf and wiggly toes there, to create the illusion of nudity, in a lighthearted and playful way.
It’s a concept that had been employed elsewhere, and some sources led us to believe that a group of local women were considering just such a project, as part of a fund-raiser to benefit the Santa Clarita Valley Boys and Girls Club, Henry Mayo Newhall Memorial Hospital or both.
Other sources close to the project said there would, in fact, be no nudity at all— and that our initial information was all wet.
That’s what our story reported in Wednesday’s paper. By the time it got into print, it wasn’t the original story we thought we had. What we ended up with was a story that reported the existence of the rampant speculation about the possibility of a “nude” calendar— and the speculation had become pretty rampant— along with the fact that at least two sources close to the project said the speculation was incorrect, that the “nude” calendar idea was not part of the fund-raiser plan.
Was it really?
That’s very hard to say.
But whatever the truth, the story earned some criticism that was stinging. And it stung all the more because of the fact that it came from some sources that I hold in high esteem.
If I had it to do over again, I’d go to greater lengths to ensure that the story explained what the calendar was not:
It was NOT conceived as a calendar featuring full nudity, with anyone’s nether regions exposed.
When you say such a calendar might include “nudity,” without clarifying that it’s more of an “illusion” of nudity, people can jump to the wrong conclusions.
And jump they did.
The inevitable posts found their way to our online Tell It to The Signal forum (the ones in bad taste were promptly deleted) and the inevitable phone calls were made to some of the women who were considering participation in the fund-raiser :
“What’s this I hear about you taking it all off for the camera?”
I regret that, I truly do— and I wish I’d done a better job of clarifying exactly what our information was.
And, of course, I wish some of those readers had done a better job of reading exactly what the story said: That there had been speculation about the possibility of doing such a calendar, but that sources close to the project said the calendar would not, in fact, feature nudity or even the illusion of it.
This can be a tough business— we make decisions on stories like this “on the fly,” often with deadline rapidly approaching. We try to do our best to consider all of the ramifications, and sometimes we wake up the next morning wishing we could unring the bell.
Of course, you can’t do that. So hopefully you learn a lesson that can be applied next time.
On the lighter side: Even in my conversations with those who were upset with us for running the story, we all came around to the question, “Hey, if there WERE going to be a nude women of the SCV calendar, who would we like to see added to the list?”
Heh. I’m thinking of a few names...
Tim Whyte is The Signal’s managing editor. His column appears Sundays.
