Note to Michael Walsh, author of the new novel, "As Time Goes By": Here's to beating you soundly over the head with a sock full of nickels, kid. Walsh is the latest money-grubbing Philistine to lumber onto the marketplace and attempt to pollute one of our purest and best-loved legends, in this case, "Casablanca." His novel is supposedly a prequel and a sequel to 1943's Academy Award-winning Best Picture.
Of course, Walsh is not alone in his sin. Writers get goofy ideas all the time — trust me — but some merciful god usually keeps their worst flights of stupidity out of print (unless your name's Robert James Waller). Here, we have Warner Books as the offending party, who not only published this thing, but reportedly encouraged Walsh to write it.
The basic plot casts Rick Blaine (Humphrey Bogart, of course, in the film) as a former New York gangster who reunites with Victor Laszlo and his wife Ilsa (Paul Henreid, Ingrid Bergman, of course) in war-time Prague, where they work together to assassinate top Nazi Reinhard Heydrich. Walsh said this plot came after "immersing" himself in the film.
Excuse me: WHAT? I don't know what Walsh was immersed in — a tub of cold water might have been a better idea — but it sure wasn't "Casablanca." In the movie (which is set in 1941), Bogart's Rick is 37 year's old; in 1931 he was "looking for a job"; in 1935 he was running guns to Ethiopians fighting Mussolini; in 1936, he fought for the Loyalists in Spain; in 1940, he was involved with anti-Nazi Resistance in Paris (I'm not making this up, it's all clearly stated in the film). So where does Walsh get his Bugsy Siegel persona for Rick? With Prohibition still two years from repeal in '31, a New York mobster was "looking for a job?" Only if he was the most inept gangster ever to work Manhattan. Horseradish. Sad to think a tree had to give its life for this stuff.
But there's another issue here, beside which the sloppiness of Walsh's research doesn't amount to a hill of beans in this crazy world: Will the people with dollar signs for eyes kindly keep their money-counting mitts off our modern mythology? Because this happens a lot. Anybody remember Alexandra Ripley's ham-handed attempt to reunite Scarlett O'Hara and Rhett Butler a few years ago (that was made into a TV mini-series, about which, the less said the better). In terms of "Casablanca," there was a TV series in 1983 — the second attempt at a TV series, the first being in the 50's — with David Soul as Rick (no, seriously, David Soul). The series actually showed some respect for the film, and Soul's major problem was that, as an actor, he showed more guts than brains in trying to represent Bogart. The series lasted three weeks.
Movies actually come from a long, honored tradition of human story-telling. We no longer gather in caves around small fires to hear tales of heroism and love and wisdom and sacrifice. Now we cluster at the local Mann's in stadium seats, and the firelight glows on the screen. But the process is the same. And the stories — the good ones — show us how to live our lives, illuminate our best qualities, and attempt to guide us from our worst impulses. "Casablanca" is one such myth, as exciting and potent and enriching as the Arthurian legends, the tales of ancient Irish kings, the folklore of Native America, the narratives of African-American story-givers, or the plays performed in the Parthenon.
I resent somebody messing around with all that for no better reason than to make a buck. If storytellers want to give us a morality tale based on their own dreams and visions and universal truths, bueno. If you can't do that, take a job writing ad copy, but leave our cherished memories the hell alone.
Not that Walsh or Ripley or any of the other hacks do a tremendous amount of damage. Their work doesn't survive. It's only in the short run that they somewhat diminish our culture. For those of us who truly value the story, Rick and Ilsa will always have Paris, and "Casablanca," and so will we.
* * *
Chris Dickerson covers the city beat for The Signal.
