If I came across a genie and he granted me just one wish, I wouldn’t wish for wealth or fame. No, I would wish that I could order the perfect meal off a menu.
Of course that’s a little ridiculous because we all know that genies don’t grant just one wish, they grant three, so in reality I could wish for wealth and fame on top of that perfect order on the menu thing.
Then again, whenever a genie grants you a wish it always comes with some sort of twisted consequence, so maybe a genie’s not the best way to go.
But why can’t I order something off a menu without winding up regretting it?
Jack Burditt
It’s not fair.
Every time I go out to a restaurant, I’ll study the menu like it’s a midterm and weigh all my options and project various dining scenarios until I’ve chosen what I know in my heart is the perfect dish. And then without fail someone at the table, or even more likely, everyone at the table will wind up with a better meal than me.
All I can do is look up to the heavens and bellow, “Why must you mock me!”
As you can imagine, there’s some eateries I’m not allowed to go to anymore.
It’s not fair.
The more I think about it, the worse it gets. The pressure weighs so heavy on my mind that I’ve flat-out choked. Not on the food, but on the ordering. I suppose the worst example happened a few years ago.
We had gone to our favorite family restaurant, one of those spots that offer a wide-ranging variety of meals.
As always, Amy was interested in what I was going to order. That’s because, as my wife, she has exclusive rights to snatch up to one-fourth of my meal off my plate. I know, it doesn’t seem fair. But what can I say, it was in our vows.
Anyway, there we were at the restaurant...
AMY: “What are you getting?”
ME: “The pot roast or the barbecued chicken sandwich.”
AMY: “Well, which one?”
ME: “I don’t know. Can’t decide.”
AMY: “Just pick one.”
ME: “Ssh. Must concentrate.”
The waitress came and took everyone’s orders. Finally, she got to me.
WAITRESS: “What would you like?”
ME: “The cod.”
Amy looked shocked. My kids looked shocked. Even the waitress looked shocked. Let’s face it, cod is one of those things they have to have on the menu but that no one ever really orders.
As the waitress went back to the kitchen, Amy turned to me.
AMY: “Did you want the cod?”
ME: “How long have you been married to me?”
AMY: “Too long.”
ME: “Right. And in all those years, have I ever wanted cod?”
AMY: “So change your order.”
ME: “It’s too late.”
AMY: “Go tell the waitress.”
ME: “What’s done is done.”
The truth is, even if I had changed my order it nevertheless would have been the wrong thing. I know my limitations.
Still, I spent long hours trying to figure out a way to reverse my menu ordering luck. In other words, I needed to turn my restaurant frown upside down.
I was tired of seeing my wife and kids flaunting their ordering superiority over me. To add insult to injury, no one in my family ever finishes a meal. So invariably I wind up looking at a bunch of unwanted tasty tidbits, but not until late in the dining experience, at which point I’m always too full from my unsatisfying meal.
I know what you’re thinking. “Wrap up the tasty tidbits, take them home and eat them later.”
Sure, it’s a good theory. But, come on, you know the reality. The moment you remove leftovers from the restaurant premises, they turn to tasteless clay. Even my two stupid wolf-dogs , who would eat my car if they hand the chance, turn up their noses to restaurant leftovers.
So I continued to live with the regret of being a bad orderer.
And then a couple of months it came to me. In a glorious moment of clarity and enlightenment I realized how to beat the system.
I took my family to a restaurant and didn’t order anything. Amy thought I had lost my mind. Of course, Amy often thinks I’ve lost my mind.
But it was brilliant. By not ordering anything, I could have everything. All those great meals that I would bitterly envy would all be mine.
I let my family order what they would normally order. And once their meals arrived I gnawed on some crackers, and waited.
Yes, I waited until they were full. Then I went to work. I finished up the steak and potatoes on one plate, the chicken brochettes on another, and then swooped in for some shrimp stir-fry . It was like a smorgasbord. And it was perfect.
I even came up with a name for myself: The Closer.
Suddenly I wanted to go out to restaurants every night. Never again would I suffer the frustration of knowing that I ordered poorly. Never again would I weep from meal envy.
The Closer was in.
Then last week we went to El Torito.
Amy ordered shrimp fajitas. Excellent. Our 19-year-old ordered a caesar salad. Yummy. Our 16-year-old went with a combination plate, our 12-year-old quesadillas and rice and our nine-year-old some tacos. Woohoo.
I nibbled on chips and waited for the call. The call for The Closer.
And then something horrible happened.
For the first time in history, everyone polished off their meals.
I wanted to cry.
Then Amy reminded me that there was some leftover pizza in the fridge at home. In the world of leftovers, there’s nothing better than pizza.
The Closer was back in business.
I hurried home. Like always, there was a teenage boy at our house.
Like always, he hadn’t been invited but decided to make himself at home anyway. And on this particular night he had made himself at home by eating the last of my pizza.
A dark cloud settled over my new-found Eden. The Closer had a closer.
It’s not fair.
Jack Burditt is a TV writer. His column appears Sundays.
