Lisa Foust is president of the Henry Mayo Newhall Memorial Health Foundation, the fund-raising arm of the local community hospital and provider of health care education and wellness programs for the Santa Clarita Valley. Foust talked with Signal reporter Blanca Cordova this week about the hospital’s present condition and its future in the context of recent developments. The following are excerpts.
20 Questions
with...
Lisa Foust
President of the
HMNMH Foundation
Q: There seems to be some confusion publicly about who owns the hospital. Who owns it?
A: The hospital is owned essentially by itself. It is a self-governed organization, overseen by a 16-member board of directors who serve without compensation. These are community leaders, business leaders, civic-minded individuals, civic-minded physicians who together comprise the governing structure for the hospital.
Q: What is the difference between the board of directors of the hospital and the board of the Health Foundation?
A: The hospital board governs the activities and overall direction of the hospital. The Foundation board (directs) which fund-raising activities will be carried out and they help plan them and execute them. Their role is critical because their efforts collectively help the Foundation collect about $1 million each year to contribute toward hospital programs.
Q: What is the makeup of the Foundation board?
A: It is a 35-member body with representation from the business community (and) the groups that support various patient care programs. We have the Auxiliary, the Guild, the Home Tour League and the Flame of Life volunteers. Each group’s president serves as a voting member of the board. We have medical staff representation on the Foundation board.
Q: How big is the hospital’s service territory? How many people does it serve now? 20 years from now?
A: It is 450 square miles, the largest in geographic size in Los Angeles County. Presently (the population is) 196,077. The fact that the SCV is one of the most dramatically growing communities in the state (is) certainly not lost on the hospital board. That is the prime reason why we are searching for a merger partner. As the community grows, its demand for appropriate health care services which can effectively respond to that growth is very challenged. In 20 years, a medium scenario... projects that our population will grow to about 409,00 people.
Q: Are the hospital’s current services adequate to meet current needs?
A: In certain services, yes. In other services, no. In the critical care services, for example, we have a 12-bed intensive care unit which is really too small to serve a community of this size, particularly because we operate one of only 13 remaining trauma centers in Los Angeles County.
(Our) 12-bed unit (fills up) pretty much all the time. We also have a growing senior population, and (they tend) to be more acutely ill and be more in need of intensive services. As that population grows— four-fold over the next 30 years— it taxes our ability to respond to intensive care needs. Another service that tends to be terribly impacted by the size of our community is definitive observation, which is a step down from intensive care.
Emergency care is very much a prioritization. While our lobby may be full of people who have been triaged (and) have been sent back to the lobby to wait, it’s because we’ve got cardiac patients who have been brought in by paramedic ambulance through the back door, we’ve got trauma patients being delivered to us via helicopter, and those folks have to be cared for and treated first and moved through our system as smartly as possible.
We absolutely need to expand the size of our emergency department. We know that that is a significant source of dissatisfaction for the community when they have to wait longer than they expect to for services.
Q: How do the services at Newhall Memorial compare to the services at other Southland hospitals?
A: Through very innovative planning by hospital leadership, and I’m talking about administration and the board of directors, we’ve been able to bring resources to this community hospital that you probably wouldn’t find in a community hospital this size.
For example, we operate a trauma center. That is a unique and wonderful resource for this community that, in fact, the Foundation board has worked very hard to make... viable. A lot of other community hospitals that began a trauma program ended up closing them because of the financial strain. (In) trauma care, you treat all comers (including) large proportions of people who have no means to pay for their care.
Q: What does it mean to have a Level-2 trauma center?
A: It means that 24 hours a day, 7 days a week, we (have) the equipment and staff, the technology and the physicians to provide trauma care.
It brings to bear... not only an in-house trauma surgeon 24 hours a day, but an entire panel of medical specialists— neurosurgeons; plastic surgeons; ear, nose and throat doctors; cardiologists; what have you. When a code “trauma” is paged overhead, everyone who is a part of the trauma team stops what they are doing and they all descend on the trauma center to greet the patient.
There is a very stringent set of criteria that a hospital, in order to be designated as a Level-2 trauma center, must meet all the time, without exception. This is a program we are extremely proud of.
Q: What role do the nurses and doctors have in the service you provide?
A: We really look at it as a team. It includes the board of directors, (which) provides the place where the physicians practice their craft... but it’s the physician who admits the patient, follows the patient through our facility and discharges the patient, so we are very interested in making sure our team works well together and that everyone does his or her share to treat our patients with efficiency and a great degree of skill.
We have almost every type of health-care professional represented here. There are a few things we don’t offer because our community isn’t big enough yet to launch certain programs, but it’s certainly growing in that direction.
Q: Describe your emergency room expansion plan. How much have you raised?
A: We want to add four treatment beds to the existing 12 for a total of 16. We will literally be increasing the size of it by 25 percent. We can do that in the... space that’s currently deployed as the emergency department.
We have raised, to date, about $660,000, and we have about $350,000 to go because we need to reach $1.1 million to complete Phase 1. We are very fortunate that the city of Santa Clarita... offered a matching grant (of) $1 for every $2 we raise from Oct. 13 to the end of the campaign, (up to) a total of $200,000 from the city. So if we raise up to $400,000 (after Oct. 13) they’ll match it as we go.
Q: Do you foresee a new urgent care facility on the east side of the SCV?
A: The (hospital) board has known for quite some time that there is a need to be responsive to the growing numbers of people residing in Canyon Country.
The master facilities plan for the hospital includes the development of ambulatory care facilities on the east side of the valley. We envision perhaps a 60,000- to 70, 000-square-foot facility that contains, under one roof, urgent care, imaging services, perhaps laboratory services, pharmacy services and even physician offices.
As developers have developed larger parcels on that end of the valley, we have (said), “As you look at your residential parcel development and your commercial along with it, have you considered... what a resource (a medical facility) would bring to bear for this residential community you’re developing? If you plan for that, we’d love to work with you.”
To predict when exactly it will occur would be a very tough job, given how challenging health care is today. But it is a continuing focus of the (hospital) board.
Q: The hospital is said to be operating in the red. What has cut into your revenues?
A: About 70 percent of hospitals in California are losing money. California and New York have higher enrollment rates than other states in managed-care plans— where you receive a fixed rate of reimbursement for a broad array of services. (Also), Congress and President Clinton passed the 1997 Balanced Budget Act, which will reduce this hospital’s reimbursements from Medicare by over $7 million over 5 years.
The ability to continue to operate a hospital in the black is disappearing from pretty much every hospitals’ radar screen. You have to manage your resources under fixed revenue, if not declining revenue, even though the cost to deliver the care you’ve always delivered may be rising with inflation.
Hospitals with foundations (such as Newhall Memorial) are likely to be the ones to survive. Traditional reimbursement really just pays for mediocrity. Philanthropy and the amount of contribution that the Foundation’s work can do for the hospital, that’s what provides the measure of excellence. The Foundation has been... able to buy capital equipment that the hospital might not have been able to afford. We’re able to expand services because of the very generous community in which we live.
Q: What steps have been taken to cut costs?
A: We would like to work closely with physicians to manage the length of stay of Medicare patients as efficiently as possible. That takes teamwork on the part of the hospital... and the physicians to move the patient along though the system, through the hospitalization as efficiently as possible. Nobody wants to be in the hospital any longer than they have to be, and certainly we recognize the importance of that, because we receive a fixed level of reimbursement. That is a major initiative.
I don’t want to characterize that as, we’re trying to push the patient out the door. We would never discharge patients before it is appropriate to discharge them. But we need to (operate as efficiently) as possible so physicians can make appropriate, timely decisions about the disposition of their patients.
If (patients) require more hospitalization or more resources than we’re going to be reimbursed, well, that’s what we’re here for. That’s what we do every day.
Q: Given your financial challenges, can you afford to hire more staff?
A: In certain areas we have to. In certain areas there are shortages. There is a nursing shortage up and down state, (especially) in Southern California. Every (hospital) has been scrambling for nurses. The registries are tapped; it’s very difficult for nurses who work so hard to be asked to work extra shifts to meet (the needs of our high patient volume). So yes, in certain areas it is absolutely critical that we fill open positions with skilled staff.
Q: You’ve seen two union drives in recent months, involving a total of three-fourths of the hospital’s 1,000 employees. Many have said the hospital is understaffed and lacks adequate equipment. How do you respond?
A: I can really appreciate members of the hospital’s staff feeling stressed, particularly as it applies to their specific shift and assignment, because health care is an extraordinarily difficult place to be these days.
A lot of hospitals are in same boat. We try very hard to pay fairly and competitively. We are not the highest payer, but we aren’t the lowest, either.
(As to alleged) understaffing, the (state’s nurse-to-patient ) staffing ratio bill was endorsed by the California Nurses Assn., the union that represents our nurses. Before the bill was passed, we interpreted it to make sure we were meeting the guidelines. In all but one unit, we were meeting the staffing ratios mandated by the bill or we were exceeding them.
(As to alleged equipment shortages), in most cases it was an equipment deployment problem, not a shortage. Equipment wasn’t in the right place. A lot of equipment was acquired in the last year to equip each unit with the equipment they felt they weren’t getting timely enough.
Q: Why does the hospital oppose unionization?
A: We believe any time a third party (comes) between our ability to communicate with our employees, it’s not a good thing. Management prefers to deal one-on-one with its employees, and the very nature of a union removes that ability. We respect the right of all of our employees to make an informed decision— not only those who wish to organize (but also) those who oppose organizing. Management has a responsibility to all employees, so that when they go to the ballot place on Feb. 23 and 24 to vote whether or not to have the United Electrical, Radio and Machine Workers Union of America represent their interests for the purposes of collective bargaining, they know what they’re voting for, what union representation can achieve and what it cannot achieve. We would be derelict in our duties if we didn’t take the opportunity to provide education in that regard.
Q: Duffy Watson, the hospital’s chief executive, resigned last week. Why?
A: I would prefer not to try to forecast his reasons. I haven’t a clue what was in his mind.
Q: When the hospital announced Watson’s resignation, the board said it wanted to take the hospital in a new direction. What direction?
A: Mr. Watson left an enormous legacy with this hospital. Being the administrator for 23 years, he (brought) the hospital from its 99-bed beginning to a 217-bed , comprehensive community hospital with extraordinary services.
In the life span of a hospital, leadership changes are inevitable.... New leadership can bring fresh approaches, fresh ideas, perhaps inspire people to work more closely together. I think there is a definite, palatable feeling of optimism in the organization that we’re going to move into a new millennium with new approaches, new ideas, and sometimes it takes a new person to shed light on some of those issues.
Q: How could a merger partner solve the hospital’s financial troubles? How would services change?
A: We are completing (a 4-year earthquake retrofit). The good news is, if there is a major seismic event here, you’re going to be very safe. The bad new is, that cash reserve is what typically we would draw from to expand and develop new services. We feel as though (our) ability to... grow the hospital to be responsive to the community’s growing needs— we can’t meet that need anymore. That’s the primary reason the hospital board is seeking a merger partner.
We think (a merger partner) would... help to calm the impact that health-care reimbursement volatility has on our facility. (As part of) a larger network of hospitals with which to share our liabilities, it would provide a measure of financial stability we don’t have on our own as a private hospital.
We need a merger partner that shares our vision of service to the community. The hospital didn’t want to choose any old merger partner that shows up on our door with a bag full of money. It’s happened in other places.
Q: Who is Tenet? Is its acquisition offer still on the table?
A: The board is still in discussion with Tenet. I believe they own 32 hospitals in Southern California. We were interested in a system that had a significant presence in Southern California because we recognize the strategic benefit.
Q: What will happen to the hospital’s alliance with the UCLA Medical Center in light of a possible takeover?
A: We have clinical affiliations with university-based teaching facilities including UCLA and USC, but that’s all I can say.
