The city of Santa Clarita considered it a victory Tuesday when the Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors voted to issue a continuance regarding the Southdown Inc. mine in Soledad Canyon.
The board voted 4-0 Tuesday to give the company and the city, county and town councils 90 days to find a compromise. Second District Supervisor Yvonne Braithwaite-Burke left midway through the meeting.
The county Regional Planning Commission denied the project 4-0 in December 1999.
Southdown Inc. is the parent company of Transit Mixed Concrete Co., which has plans for a mining project in the eastern Santa Clarita Valley.
The decision will send Los Angeles County, the city of Santa Clarita, town councils for Acton and Aqua Dulce, and Transit Mixed Concrete to the bargaining table to find a workable compromise.
“We viewed today’s decision as a victory and a win-win situation,” said Fifth District Supervisor Michael D. Antonovich. “It has forced the applicant to finally meet with the city and town councils and finally address the serious concerns that were raised today.”
U.S. Rep. Howard “Buck” McKeon, Santa Clarita’s original mayor, spoke against the project.
“I’m not surprised that the supervisors would postpone a decision on this because they heard a lot of very good reasons to reject the mining proposal and need to consider those very carefully,” he said.
“It is my hope that Southdown will sit down to the table and seriously negotiate, but they have a long way to go with establish some trust with the community.”
“We are very pleased with the decision today,” Mayor Laurene Weste said. “Six months ago TMC was invincible and today we come through with this major victory.”
“We really need to praise our supervisor and the others who worked through some tough questions.”
George Pederson, chair of the Los Angeles Regional Planning Commission, said Southdown got a serious wake up call Tuesday.
“They understated the power of the city,” Pederson said.
“This city can come together on major issues. The political reality is that these people are not going to take this lying down,” he said.
Pederson was one of the four commissioners who denied the project in December 1999.
“I think its just like Elsmere (Canyon),” City Councilman Cameron Smyth said. “The city has demonstrated we are going to take proposals that are detrimental to our community.”
Smyth was one of the 15 schedule people to testify before the board.
* * *
To start off the city’s testimony, Councilman Bob Kellar introduced a segment of an August City Council meeting where Southdown Vice President of Public Affairs Don Newquist showed the company’s approach to project. During the segment, Newquist stated that the county has to approve power because the federal government has jurisdiction over the land.
Following Kellar, McKeon, R-Santa Clarita, told the supervisors that officials from the Bureau of Land Management and the Interior Department were concerned about potential liability, should the agencies renege on it contract.
The congressman also said he had introduced legislation last year to stop all mining at the location, but it has not met with success.
Actress Linda Gray— a longtime Sand Canyon resident who played Sue Ellen Ewing on TVs “Dallas” — also spoke at the hearing.
“There should have been a checks and balances in place,” she said. “The lack of caring for the environment makes them a poor choice for doing business in Los Angeles County.”
Gray said she moved to the SCV because of its tranquility and natural habitat. “I’ve seen massive changes around here.”
Among those who testified were Weste, Smyth and Mayor Pro-Tem Frank Ferry. Longtime mine opponent Marsha McLean and Peter Kavounad, vice president of the Castaic Lake Water Agency Board of Directors, also testified.
* * *
One detail that kept the project from being approved was the project’s incomplete Environmental Impact Report.
When the board voted in October to extend the public hearing, it also extended the public comment period on the EIR until December, and the document is not yet finalized.
First District Supervisor Gloria Molina, whose district is home to the base operations for Transit Mixed, questioned why the item was brought back before the board when no decision could legally be made— since the environmental documents were not complete.
“There never was a final EIR because the Regional Planning Commission denied the project,” County Counsel Rick Weiss said.
County staff then recommended the board close the public comment period on the EIR, to which Antonovich asked what county staff was recommending what action the Board of Supervisors take Tuesday.
“Staff is supporting the Regional Planning Commission decision to deny the project,” Weiss said.
* * *
Transit Mixed then gave its presentation— at one point prompting Antonovich to urge Southdown officials to “stop reading statements and speak from the heart” — which included attempts to dispel what it considered false information being given about the project, testimony on the need for aggregate, and a video that was played for the Santa Clarita City Council at an August study session.
A representative from Cemex, which up until this point had remained in the background, also spoke at the meeting in favor of the project, saying one of the main reasons the company decided to purchase Southdown was for its projects in Southern California.
“Southdown has proven that it has a strong presence in the region,” Rosemary Clyburn, senior vice president of Cemex, said.
Also discussed was federal pre-emption , something officials from Southdown said gives the federal government jurisdiction over the project’s approval and the county’s say over environmental mitigation, as well as whether the company had ever tried before to work with the opponents of the project in the SCV.
After a staff report on the matter, the Board of Supervisors set aside an hour for Southdown and the city to each present its case— in October, the city had played a major role in persuading the board to extend the public hearing for 90 days, which was rescheduled for Tuesday.
First up was the testimony by Southdown and Cemex— which owns Southdown, which in turn owns Transit Mixed— which is looking to mine nearly 78 million tons to produce 56 million tons of concrete sand and gravel from a 460 acre parcel of land in the eastern SCV.
The project has already garnered the approval of the Bureau of Land Management, which administers the rights to the federally-owned minerals beneath the land, in the form of two 10-year permits which were obtained through the bid process.
The fact that the company has obtained federal approval has been a point of contention in the past, and became an issue at Tuesday’s meeting, with the company of the opinion that the county does not have any power over the approval or denial of the mine.
The city then presented its case against the Soledad Canyon sand and gravel mine, which included testimony by Weste, McKeon and Kellar, followed by public testimony which mostly came from opponents of the mine.
