A pair of Newhall residents who were expected to enter a plea in the matter of their son’s murder declined a prosecutor’s offer Tuesday.
The child’s parents, Michael J. Shires and April Ann Starr, are being tried in the slaying of their 2-year-old son Kyle William Shires at their Newhall home on June 6, 1999. Testimony revealed the little boy was beaten to death.
After conferring with their attorneys, the co-defendants entered the Los Angeles Superior courtroom of Judge Dale S. Fischer with Shires shaking his from side-to-side while Starr slowly took her seat.
Deputy District Attorney Steven Slavitt told the court that the co-defendants had declined the terms of his offer. The plea bargain would have stipulated that Shires plead guilty to second-degree murder and Starr enter a guilty plea to felony child abuse resulting in the death of a minor.
Brady Sullivan, Shires’ public defender, said he expected his client’s trial to last about three weeks. He was optimistic about the possibility of separate trials.
“I made a motion for a second trial because the witnesses that the prosecutor expects to call will prejudice my client in front of a jury,” Sullivan said. “I’m confident that a second trial will be granted.”
Deputy Alternate Public Defender Drew E. Edwards represents Starr.
Under the prosecution’s offer, Starr, 37, would have faced a mandatory eight-year sentence in state prison, authorities said. By declining the offer, the couple faces 15 years to life imprisonment for their alleged role in the boy’s death.
Also, because the plea deal was not accepted by the co-defendants , there would not a similar opportunity in the future, according to court testimony.
“If we have to try the cases in front of a jury, that’s just what we’ll have to do,” Slavitt said. “Some of the evidence I’ll just have to present twice.”
Legal options for the co-defendants include the possibility of two separate trials or one trial in front of two separate juries, authorities said.
Shires, in addition to the murder charge, is being charged with felony assault on a child causing death. Starr, who was at work at the time of the incident, is charged as an accessory to murder and child endangerment.
Starr has been in custody since the day after the boy’s death. Her bail is $500,000.
Prosecutors and Los Angeles County Sheriff’s homicide investigators contend a continuing pattern of child abuse and endangerment eventually led to the child’s death.
The pair was convicted and served prison time in 1996 for their roles in abusing their first child, who was 6 months old at the time. They had relocated from Apple Valley in San Bernardino County to the Santa Clarita Valley.
Starr’s other six children reside with her ex-husband Richard Starr in Apple Valley.
Official records show that Shires called 911 soon after the incident and told the emergency dispatcher that he thought that the boy had drowned.
Shires later confessed to punching Kyle in a rage after Starr went to work and left him without a car or cigarettes, authorities said. He was arrested the day after the boy’s death and his bail was set at $2 million.
At a felony arraignment hearing Nov. 9, 1999, a county medical examiner testified that Kyle died as a result of “sustaining multiple blunt force trauma” within hours of being hit.
The examiner also confirmed the boy had been continually battered, noting that some of the wounds and bruises were less than 24 hours old.
But a judge concluded in October 1999 that the prosecution had insufficient evidence to proceed with the case against the couple.
“Photos of Kyle’s face and head showed obvious bruises,” Deputy District Attorney Patricia J. Titus said.
Slavitt was assigned to the case and promptly re-filed the charges.
Later, after witnesses and former co-workers began to provide additional information about Starr’s alleged knowledge of her live-in boyfriend’s violent mood swings but did nothing to protect Kyle from the abuse, Fischer was convinced that the two should stand trial.
