Los Angeles County Superior Court Judge Haley Fromholz ruled in favor of disclosure Wednesday morning, decreeing that the William S. Hart Union High School District can release full documentation of an insurance settlement for the earthquake-damaged Hart High auditorium.
The Signal filed a California Public Records Act request on Dec. 10, after Hart officials refused to release details of the November settlement, citing a nondisclosure agreement with insurance broker Arthur J. Gallagher.
The Hart district filed suit against Gallagher, the broker responsible for the auditorium, in 1996 after it was discovered that the company had not paid for damages the auditorium sustained in the 1994 Northridge quake.
But The Signal contended that, as a public entity, the Hart district is prohibited by law from entering into confidential settlements.
Seeking a ruling on whether it could disclose the settlement, the district asked for a ruling from a judge.
Fromholz agreed with a motion filed by the district that said it should be allowed to disclose the settlement amount.
After establishing from information provided by Gallagher attorney Randy Moss and Hart attorney Evangeline Fisher that the case was in fact settled to all parties' satisfaction, Fromholz said, "The public is entitled to the information."
In the case of a public entity, Fromholz added, "The legislation is clear. Public interest overrides the confidential agreement."
