The Santa Clarita Planning Commission voted 4-1 Tuesday night to back a proposed housing development that had challenged the city’s Hillside Preservation Ordinance, garnering approval based on the project’s “innovative” characteristics.
American Beauty Development is proposing to build a 272-home project on a 176-acre parcel of land in Canyon Country north of Soledad Canyon and east of Sand Canyon. The site is not currently inside city limits, but will be annexed if approved.
Because of the city’s hillside ordinance, the number of homes allowed is limited to 145, according to city officials.
To increase the density of the project, the builder requested the project be approved as “innovative,” a request that tested a development parameter and could have served as a benchmark for future developments by setting a standard for other developers who want to stray from city code.
But Planning Commission Chair Dennis Ostrom, the dissenting vote, said the commission determined it will continue to look at developments on a “ case-by-case basis,” regardless of Tuesday night’s decision.
“This hasn’t resolved the issue of innovation,” Ostrom said.
The issue has been before the Planning Commission six times before Tuesday night’s meeting, including a Jan. 2 meeting at which the developer was instructed to come back with significant changes to the project, which would allow it to be built under the exemption from code.
Tuesday night, the developer returned with computer drawn images in place of the sketches that had been shown at earlier meetings, representing the only change in the proposal from the last meeting.
“All changes that were made were done prior to the Jan. 2 meeting,” Ostrom said.
City Senior Planner Fred Follstad said staff made the “same recommendation,” at Tuesday night’s meeting as it has maintained since the introduction of the project, which was that it did not meet the innovative criteria, and that the number of homes allowed should remain at 145.
The development had stalled in earlier meetings of the Planning Commission because of the potential impact of the project, and the parameters that approval of the project could set for other developers.
Only one other project has been approved using the innovative clause in the city code, according to city officials, which was the Robinson Ranch Golf Course in Sand Canyon.
Tuesday night’s Planning Commission meeting was the first of two this week. The other, a site tour of a proposed development of 22 duplex units on a nearly 27 acre site near the Friendly Valley Housing Development, will be held today at 4 p.m.
