The owner of the Porta Bella property in central Santa Clarita has counter-sued the Castaic Lake Water Agency and other local water purveyors, saying they should take responsibility— and pay for— the cleanup of the contaminated groundwater beneath the property.
Named in the suit with CLWA is the Newhall County Water District, Santa Clarita Water Co. and Valencia Water Co. — all of whom initially sued the current and former Porta Bella property in November to force them to clean the groundwater.
The property was used for munitions manufacturing and testing during much of the 20th Century by the Bermite Powder Co. and its successor, Whittaker Corp. Left behind in the soil and groundwater were some 275 different contaminants including perchlorate, which was detected at high concentrations in wells owned by the NCWD, SCWC and Valencia Water Co.
The controversial Porta Bella property is slated for 2,911 homes, a school and shopping center once the Department of Toxic Substances Control deems it safe. Portions of the land and the groundwater is believed to be contaminated with perchlorate, a component of rocket fuel.
The Phoenix-based Remediation Financial Inc., managing partner of Santa Clarita LLC, purchased the property from Whittaker-Bermite in January 1999 for $15 million.
A water agency official said the water companies decided to file suit because it was not clear Santa Clarita LLC was planning to clean the groundwater.
“We haven’t seen the willingness on behalf of Santa Clarita LLC,” said Bob Sagehorn, general manager of CLWA, during a November City Council study session.
CLWA alleges that the closure of four wells because of perchlorate contamination results in a loss to the Santa Clarita Valley of 8,000 gallons of water every minute.
In the lawsuit, CLWA said it would cost $35 million to replace the wells.
Last week, Santa Clarita LLC signed a legally enforceable agreement requiring the development company to investigate the contamination at the site, including the groundwater beneath it, and clean it to the extent deemed necessary by the state DTSC.
Santa Clarita LLC officials estimated it would cost $25 million to $45 million to clean the soil— on top of the cost of cleaning the groundwater, if it is proven that the contamination stems from the property.
While Santa Clarita LLC agreed to clean the property, it stopped short of saying it would pay for the cleanup.
In its countersuit, Santa Clarita LLC contends that the water companies “have permitted and-or contributed to, and are continuing to permit and-or contribute to, releases or threatened releases of hazardous substances and and-or from the (groundwater and other water sources).”
Santa Clarita LLC asks the federal court to rule that the water companies are legally liable for the contamination and asks for them to reimburse the cleanup costs.
“(Santa Clarita LLC) is an innocent victim of the contamination for which (the water companies) are responsible,” the suit contends. “(Santa Clarita LLC) is not liable... for the response costs.... (The water companies) are liable to (Santa Clarita LLC) in contribution for these costs.”
CLWA spokeswoman Mary Lou Cotton said the countersuit did not come as a surprise.
“No,” said Eric Lardiere, general counsel for Meggitt-U .S.A. Inc., when asked to comment on his company’s responsibility for cleanup. Meggitt purchased the bulk of Whittaker’s assets after Whittaker was broken up in a hostile takeover in late 1999.
Before further commenting on the countersuit between CLWA and Santa Clarita LLC, City Attorney Carl Newton said he wanted to conduct a thorough review of the enforceable agreement and compare them with the demand of the 1994 Whittaker-Bermite consent order.
* * *
Santa Clarita LLC signed an “enforceable agreement” last week, legally requiring the company to investigate and clean up the site, as well as the groundwater beneath it.
An enforceable agreement legally binds the owner to remediate the property and have it reviewed by the California Department of Toxic Substances. Supposedly the signer enters into the agreement “voluntarily.”
However, Santa Clarita LLC began discussions with the DTSC about the agreement in March 1999, two months after purchasing the land, and signed it on Feb. 14, almost two years after discussions.
“If it has not been signed, we would have employed other methods,” said Ken Baez, project director for the DTSC.
The DTSC obtained a consent order from a state court in 1994, holding the prior owner Whittaker-Bermite responsible for cleaning the site. Since then, Meggitt-U .S.A. Inc. purchased a majority of Whittaker, and it is unclear if the DTSC will also hold Meggitt responsible for the clean up.
The consent order is a judicially mandated agreement that Whittaker-Bermite was forced to sign.
“We are pleased the agreement was entered into,” said City Attorney Carl Newton. Newton is hesitant to discuss the document until a full review is conducted.
The city of Santa Clarita has been trying to obtain the purchase agreement between Whittaker-Bermite and RFI since December.
RFI and Santa Clarita LLC has said providing private documents to public agencies is not common practice and they are not legally bound to do so. The city originally requested the documents for proof of insurance and financial stability. RFI has not turned over the documents to the city yet.
