A lawsuit was filed against the city of Santa Clarita on Thursday claiming the city hasn’t turned over public documents requested by the company proposing to mine sand and gravel in eastern Soledad Canyon.
Cemex Inc., the Louisiana subsidiary of the Mexican mining giant Cemex S.A. de C.V., filed a complaint against the city in county Superior Court alleging the city hasn’t disclosed certain public records requested by the mining company that concern endangered species near the proposed mining site in Canyon Country. The company said it has also asked for— but not received— city expenditures spent on its mine fight.
The Transit Mixed Concrete Co., a subsidiary of Cemex, was granted two 10-year permits in 1990 to mine 78 million tons of sand and gravel in eastern Soledad Canyon.
This is the second lawsuit from the company in a week after it sued Los Angeles County on Jan. 25 claiming county officials have exceeded their limited authority and knowingly prevented the project from moving forward.
Cemex spokesman Brian Mastin said the city’s constant focus on endangered species in the area caused the company to request more documentation from the city.
“This (the lawsuit) will all go away if they choose to hand over the documents,” Mastin said.
The complaint contends that the city hasn’t been consistent in its environmental policy, especially regarding the recently approved Golden Valley Ranch project.
City Attorney Carl Newton said the city gave Cemex all the documentation it is required to give by law.
“The city has spent considerable energy in support of the Golden Valley Ranch project, which is located in critical habitat for the California gnatcatcher,” the complaint states.
Despite the critical habitat designation, the council approved the project during a special meeting Jan. 24. Cemex also claims the city hasn’t developed any documentation referring to the California red-legged frog.
City spokesman Jason Smisko said the lawsuit and approval of the Golden Valley Ranch project are not related.
“There’s no clear link to the vote the council made to approve Golden Valley Ranch and TMC,” Smisko said. “It’s an apple-and-oranges comparison.”
Final approval of the mining project was put off last summer when southwestern arroyo toads were discovered near the project site. The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service reviewed the project and its impact on the toad and found it wouldn’t have any effect on the endangered species.
The city has claimed the project would severely impact the toad, gnatcatcher and three-spined stickleback. It has requested to establish a critical habitat for the toad along the Santa Clara River near the project site and in Bee Canyon.
However, the city— as well as The Newhall Land and Farming Co. and other landowners along the Santa Clara River— pressed the Wildlife Service in 2000 to change the toad’s critical habitat designation inside the city limits. The agency did so in January 2001.
Smisko said the lawsuit isn’t going to divert the city’s focus and it is buckling down for the Feb. 26 Board of Supervisors meeting.
“We are going to continue to prepare to go before the board and give them our understanding of why the (environmental documents) need to be circulated,” he said. “This is a pattern by Cemex to redirect our behavior. We’re not going to bite for that.”
Cemex also alludes to adjacent landowner and miner Ben Curtis in the lawsuit. The complaint states Curtis, who bid on the project and lost to Transit Mixed in March 1990, launched a six-year campaign against the project, and later brought in the city to help fight his battle. The lawsuit specifically cites a Dec. 3, 2000, article in The Signal.
“It doesn’t bother me,” Curtis told the Signal on Friday. “They’re doing what they can. When things get going bad, they are going to sue everyone.”
Curtis said of Cemex’s allegations, “Some are a stretch of the truth and some outright untruths.”
Newton said a Superior Court judge on Friday denied Cemex’s request for an expedited hearing, which is now scheduled for sometime in March.
