Federal agents raided Keysor-Century Corp. in Saugus on Tuesday, searching for evidence to back up allegations that the plastic-manufacturing company systematically covered up the illegal release of toxic and hazardous waste into the local groundwater and air since 1996.
In a 35-page affidavit, Special Agent Kathleen J. Giles claims “probable cause” to suspect Keysor of felonious violations of the federal Clean Water Act, Clean Air Act and the Resource Conservation and Recovery Act, and of making false statements to a federal agency.
The affidavit lists evidence to be seized to substantiate claims the company was illegally dumping vinyl chloride, trichloroethylene and other pollutants into the city and county storm drain system; illegally dumping hazardous waste without a permit; illegally releasing pollutants into the air; and making false statements to the federal Occupational Health and Safety Administration and Environmental Protection Agency.
The affidavit singles out the late company president Howard Hill, plant manager Scott Speakman and foreman Frank Celeya, alleging they “knew of the continuous falsification of environmental exposure and emissions data that were submitted to local, state and federal regulatory agencies.”
Kathy Keysor-Smith , one of five company owners, declined to comment on advice of counsel.
Manny Abascal of the Los Angeles law firm of Latham & Watkins, representing Keysor-Century , said he was “just being made aware” of the allegations.
“The company is going to cooperate in the investigation,” Abascal said, adding that Keysor-Century would continue to be up and running today.
Keysor-Century Corp. is owned by five children of the late James B. “Bud” Keysor, who founded the firm in 1946 and moved it in the 1950s to the Saugus industrial complex on Springbrook Avenue, east of Bouquet Canyon Road. The company has been a leader in the manufacture of long-playing records and has branched out to produce resins used in floor tiles, credit cards and molded plastic bottles.
The company’s emissions of vinyl chloride, a cancer-causing chemical, were cited as one of the reasons for the permanent closure of Saugus Elementary School during the 1977-78 school year. Located across Bouquet Canyon Road, the former school is now a shopping center.
The new FBI affidavit cites allegations that Keysor “has been running (polyvinyl chloride) production over capacity,” causing equipment to “release dangerous amounts of vinyl chloride.”
FBI spokesman Matthew McLaughlin said Tuesday’s raid was carried out by officials from the FBI, the South Coast Air Quality Management District, the state Environmental Protection Agency’s Department of Toxic Substances Control, the local county sanitation district, county department of public works and others under the umbrella of the Los Angeles Federal Environmental Crimes Task Force.
He did not specify what evidence was removed from the premises when the search warrant was executed, although the affidavit outlines a variety of items to be seized— from plumbing apparatuses and venting systems used in the treatment and disposal of hazardous waste, to personnel records and receipts, to computers and other instruments “capable of concealing any calibration record or profile or otherwise capable of concealing any artifice or contrivance to store, process or manipulate data.”
Giles states that the claims in her affidavit were based on her personal observations, discussions with other law enforcement agents and members of regulatory agencies, and review of agency reports.
She states that some of the evidence of criminal wrongdoing came from a confidential ex-employee who worked in the plant’s laboratory for 14 years. The ex-employee provided paperwork showing falsified vinyl chloride worker exposure records and emissions monitoring reports, while another confidential ex-employee provided photographs showing illegal hazardous waste dumping, she states.
In addition, Giles states that Scott Hamilton of the city of Santa Clarita’s Environmental Services Division “described several illegal discharges by Keysor,” while Cal-OSHA and South Coast AQMD officials provided other information. Sanitation district officials provided reports after the department responded to “an unauthorized release of pollutants,” and the Los Angeles County Fire Department’s Health Hazardous Materials Division provided a report on a Hazmat incident last October.
In the affidavit, Giles claims knowledge that Keysor-Century “had frequent, unreported spills of reactor wastewater.” (A reactor is the apparatus used to turn raw vinyl chloride into a polymer.) The affidavit alleges that managers “ordered employees not to take water samples” from certain areas of the manufacturing plant “in order to avoid having to report discharges in violation of (permitted) limits.”
After one of the confidential ex-employees told her the company’s parking lot would fill “as often as once a month” with foul-smelling water that would “come gushing out of the small manholes located in Keysor’s parking lot” and flow off the premises, she examined a storm drain with city officials on Oct. 19, tracing it to a pipe leading back to the company where she found “what appeared to be white PVC residue and powder.” Sampling results showed discharges that “exceeded (the) permit limits for the hazardous chemicals TCE, VC, vinyl acetate, as well as other chemicals,” she states.
The sanitation district issued a notice of violation for wastewater discharge on Oct. 29, and the fire department issued a Hazmat citation “for an intentional or suspicious act that caused the illegal release of vinyl acetate and trichloroethylene off Keysor’s property and into public storm drains. Three thousand gallons of waste liquid (were) recovered and transported,” she states.
One ex-employee reported that the company burned off an acetaldehyde byproduct in a gas-powered boiler, which corroded and exploded in 1984. A new boiler had a “large spill” that went unreported, she states, and two days after the ex-employee warned managers that the new boiler would explode, it did.
Giles states that one of the ex-employees was asked to help cover up violations of air quality standards.
“In an attempt to deflect unwanted governmental scrutiny and civil fines, Keysor would alter... emission results that (the ex-employee ) gathered,” she states.
Air samples were taken from 14 intake ports throughout the day, she states, and the results were fed into a computer.
“Keysor management then reviewed the original emission entries and altered excessive emissions readings to a random number within legal limits,” Giles states. “The altered results were printed in a summary report. The original computer file was overwritten, and all other papers containing the original emission data were destroyed.”
Then, the “falsified summary report was submitted to AQMD and US EPA,” she states.
Giles reports that Patricia Douglass, the company’s human resources manager and safety team member, ordered an evacuation of the plant after a reactor gasket ruptured in February 1998, releasing vinyl chloride into the air. “Douglass was severely reprimanded by Keysor president Howard Hill and his plant manager, Scott Speakman, who both viewed this action as unnecessary.”
Giles states that one of the confidential ex-employees was told to shred a report on the incident, rather than file it with the appropriate agencies.
According to Giles, the ex-employee also reported that the company falsified reactor reports intended to describe how much toxic vinyl chloride vapor is released into the air when a PVC reactor is opened, as well as reports measuring the amount of vinyl chloride that remained in the slurry after extraction from the reactor.
Giles states that employees were monitored for exposure to vinyl chloride by wearing a device during their shift. She states that she personally examined different data entries and determined they had been altered.
She states that two employees were examined during a Cal-OSHA inspection in December and both showed exposure above allowable limits, including one who was 15 times higher.
