The Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors unanimously denied the proposed Transit Mixed Concrete mine Tuesday on the grounds that the company did not adequately address the project’s traffic impacts.
About 100 Santa Clarita Valley residents attended Tuesday’s meeting, many bedecked in red “ anti-TMC ” T-shirts .
“Today’s decision by the board is a testament as to how effective we were in creating a coalition of regional support to oppose this project,” Mayor Frank Ferry said.
Transit Mixed spokesman Brian Mastin said the company was “obviously” disappointed with the board’s decision.
“We felt the board had information (it requested) before to approve the project,” he said. “We felt the traffic analysis was adequate.”
In 1989, Transit Mixed received back-to-back 10-year permits from the Bureau of Land Management to mine 78 million tons of sand and gravel to yield 56.1 million tons of concrete aggregates in eastern Soledad Canyon. Even though the federal government granted Transit Mixed mining permits, the county had to issue environmental approval before mining could begin. Transit Mixed is owned by Mexico-based concrete giant Cemex Inc.
A traffic study released Thursday by the county Department of Public Works stated that the project’s impact on traffic along Soledad Canyon Road would be too great, and that it would not be possible to widen the road. The study reported that state Route 14, however, would not be affected by the addition of trucks to and from the mine daily.
The department recommended that the board deny the project unless Transit Mixed agreed to traffic and environmental mitigation measures, as directed by county staff.
The board agreed that Transit Mixed’s environmental impact report did not adequately address traffic issues, nor had the company cooperated in working with the county to resolve the concerns.
“(Transit Mixed), in recent months, has refused to cooperate with county staff in making revisions to the EIR regarding traffic impacts, which revisions are necessary to allow the board to identify and impose the reasonably necessary traffic mitigation measures for the project,” Fifth District Supervisor Michael D. Antonovich said in his motion for denial.
“The applicant has not only refused to provide the necessary documentation to allow the EIR to be made complete as requested by county staff, it has even filed a lawsuit to prevent the county from making the EIR revisions that it believes to be necessary,” Antonovich said.
Transit Mixed sued the county on Jan. 23 in an attempt to halt further delays in opening the mine.
Mastin said he hopes a court will allow the project to proceed.
“(The board’s decision) demonstrates why we had to file the suit,” he said.
Three Transit Mixed representatives testified at Tuesday’s meeting, each stating that the EIR’s traffic analysis was conducted properly and its findings were accurate.
“We believe (the county staff’s) recommendation is improper,” said Transit Mixed attorney Kerry Shapiro. “In spite of our disagreements, the county is trying to put us in (a) Catch 22. If it isn’t one thing, it will be another. Today it is traffic.”
Mining company officials showed a 30-minute videotape that had been filmed on Soledad Canyon Road between the mine site and SR 14 during peak morning traffic hours— from 6 a.m. to 8 a.m. on Feb. 6— ostensibly to demonstrate that few cars used the road during the hours county staff said would be the worst.
First District Supervisor Gloria Molina called the video “shocking,” and questioned whether the amount of traffic shown would actually be impacted by the new trucks.
“In my district, we have cement removed daily,” she said. “In my neighborhood, we have cement trucks riding right along next to our school buses.”
County planning staff members said Transit Mixed’s video did not reflect ideal traffic conditions on the road.
“The real question is whether you believe this video shows the amount of traffic you see, or if traffic is as unstable as your staff suggests,” said John Hecht, a Transit Mixed engineer.
Hecht said that during peak hours, one truck would pass through the area every 15 minutes, and that the addition would not impact traffic flow.
Third District Supervisor Zev Yaroslavsky told Shapiro he didn’t think it was fair for Transit Mixed to “stonewall,” not having made any concessions to the county.
“I am very skeptical of someone who stonewalls for months and then, on the day of the hearing, presents a videotape,” Yaroslavsky said.
“The thing that gets me,” Antonovich said, “is that (Transit Mixed is) attempting to bypass the board by threatening to go to court.
“The Santa Clarita Valley is concerned about environmental safeguards,” he said.
Santa Clarita Deputy City Manager Rick Putnam spoke on behalf of the 75 to 100 people who signed up to testify against the project.
“I don’t have a videotape,” Putnam quipped to the supervisors.
“What I’m detailing here is not an 11th-hour issue,” he said. “But even at the 11th hour, (the supervisors) have the right and the obligation to take this into consideration.
“TMC would have you believe that you have no authority to deny this project.... TMC would have you believe that your hands are tied because of a contract with the federal government,” Putnam said. “TMC must comply with the county of Los Angeles.”
