ArchiveSCV
the-signal.com. The Santa Clarita Valley Signal. Back to the collection.

· the-signal.com, Wayback capture

Thrills and Bills

While parents may get nervous about letting their children ride parking lot ferris wheels, they should know the state of California looks closely over the carny's shoulder but does not regulate permanent establishments like Disneyland, Knott's Berry Farm and Six Flags Magic Mountain.

California law provides for inspections and requires reporting of any accident involving portable amusement rides, but excludes established parks from reporting any injury or death. Six of the 15 most attended amusement parks in North America are in California. But no federal law or national agency requires ride operators in every state to file accident reports. Similarly, no California law requires all ride operators — both permanent and mobile rides — to report all accidents to the state. Serious injuries or deaths usually receive media coverage, but other accidents often go unreported.

Equally important is the fact that more than 75 percent of all accidents and injuries are caused by riders' refusal to obey posted safety rules — something no amount of regulation could prevent.

A Christmas Eve accident at Disneyland, where a metal cleat broke loose from the Columbia tall ship ride and flew into a crowd, killing Luan Phi Dawson and severely injuring his wife and a park employee, has brought the issue of amusement park safety to the fore — again. In response, Assemblyman Tom Torlakson, D-Antioch, has introduced AB 850, an amendment to the state labor code, which would allow for inspection and change reporting practices of permanent amusement parks.

Andy Gallardo, spokesman for Six Flags California, was quick to point out that the park is inspected regularly by the Los Angeles County Building and Safety Department.

"We've been inspected by them for the last 28 years, roughly every 90 days," he said. "We have had no violations lately. But we would support any legislation that would make any theme park safe. We welcome any opportunity to help them draft any theme park legislation. Safety and security has always been our priority."

Gallardo's sentiments were echoed by Six Flags' corporate parent, Premier Parks.

"We support legislation that will make a verifiable theme park safer," said Brent Gooden, spokesman for Premier Parks, which owns the Six Flags national chain. "We welcome the opportunity to be involved. But it's very important to note that, from a national perspective, the theme park industry is exceptionally safe. We work in a number of different states where legislation in many respects is very different. Many times, states look to Six Flags for development of polices and procedures. The bottom line is safety, we always say. We would never operate an attraction if it was not safe. The caliber and reputation of the major parks in California would strongly agree with that."

Queried about the company's opinion of rider responsibility laws, such as those on the books in Ohio that enacted by the city of Concord after a water park accident that claimed one person's life and injured 22 others, Gooden said that visitors need to understand their part in a positive park experience.

"Ohio is the state that has the strongest rider responsibility law on the books," he said. "In various studies it's been determined that at least 75 percent of injuries and accidents that occur at amusement and theme parks occur because the rider or patron has not agreed to or followed the stated rules. All the extensive and multiple safety regulations could not have prevented them. Safety is indeed a partnership between the park and its patrons. The rules are there to ensure every guest and every employee has a wonderful time and a great experience."

In 1978, Magic Mountain had three serious incidents. In February of that year, a young man was killed and his wife of a few hours seriously injured when a sky ride gondola jumped its cable and fell 50 feet to the ground. State engineers (the state regulates gondola rides, ski lifts and bungee jump attractions) traced the accident to a loose clamp that held the gondola on its cable. In July, 10 persons were injured when a train of passenger cars suddenly hurtled them backwards on the Revolution roller coaster. Inspectors found that the braking system had malfunctioned. And in December, a 20-year-old woman was flung from the Colossus roller coaster and died. Inspectors failed to find any evidence of a malfunction of the train or the lap bar. Instead, they speculated that the woman's size — 4 feet, 5 inches tall and 253 pounds, with a 53-inch waist — may have made the lap bar ineffective in her case. According to county building officials, Colossus was redesigned to prevent that from happening again.

Dean Fryer, spokesperson for California Occupational Safety and Health Administration and the Department of Industrial Safety, said that records reflect Six Flags Magic Mountain as being in compliance with worker safety regulations; a file check going back to 1991 revealed only three incidents where employee safety was compromised. One incident, from 1996, involved the implementation of the injury and illness prevention program and the issue of guard rails on certain workstations. Resulting fines of $8,745 are currently being appealed. The second involved requiring employees to wear proper foot protection, for which the park was fined $150 and the third, from 1991, involved a carpenter who fell through a platform on Colossus and received bruises, contusions and abrasions. The park was warned to implement fall protection devices and conform to regulations that prevent falls more than two feet. No fines were levied in that case.

"We don't find anything suspect, or anything out of the ordinary," Fryer said.

As Gallardo mentioned, both local Six Flags parks, Magic Mountain and Hurricane Harbor, are inspected for safety by the county at least four times a year and, according to inspectors, has a good record.

"The inspections are both scheduled and unannounced," said Melinda Barrett, public information officer for the Los Angeles County Department of Building and Safety. "In the winter, the park is only open weekends, so we must prearrange inspections. During season, we come in unannounced. Each of the 39 rides at the park require a permit and it takes him almost three weeks to do all of them."

"We test brakes and brake locks, look at passenger loading and exiting procedures and setup to make sure it's safe and that the employees are following correct procedures," said Barrett. "The inspectors walk the perimeter of the ride both while it's operating and when it's not operating, checking the curves or anywhere it runs near water, checking for rust. They also test the computer systems, creating unsafe situations on purpose to see if the ride will allow them to do that, something like putting two trains on the track at the same time. On Riddler's Revenge, they tried all kinds of things, like building up unacceptable levels of centrifugal force or cause more than one train to be in one place. The computers would not allow it and shut the ride down."

Richard Bagby, who supervises the inspectors who cover the park, said that his workers are there at least 90 days every year, checking the rides and creating "what if" situations to see if the equipment will malfunction.

"To my knowledge, we haven't had any accidents with the vehicles on the ride for a long time," he said. "When that woman flew out of the car on Colossus, they redesigned the coaster. Any failure of the equipment must be reported; but we haven't seen any of it yet. If the ride doesn't function properly, then they would report it to us, whether or not an injury is involved."

"When they do these inspections, they make suggestions. If there is a real hazard, they have the authority to shut the ride down, but we have never had to do that," Barrett added. "We only get involved with the malfunction of a ride, even if people are injured; for example, if it were a malfuction of the ride, say the bar came down in the wrong position. It is not required by the building code to report injuries to us, but they would tell us because we're the ones who inspect it. They need our expertise. But these things don't seem to be happening at Magic Mountain."

Assemblyman Torlakson became involved with amusement park safety in 1997, when a collapsed slide at WaterWorld in Contra Costa County resulted in the death of one young woman and the injury of 22 other park guests.

"We got involved because we learned from the State Department of Industrial Relations that there is no oversight when it comes to water parks or amusement parks," said Gary Gartner, Torklakson's spokesperson. "The only involvement was Cal/OSHA and only if an employee is injured. If a regular citizen is injured, there is no jurisdiction."

Torlakson called for hearings in his district and solicited reports from across the country. He then introduced a bill to amend the Amusement Park Safety Act to include permanent parks, but the bill died in the Labor and Employment Committee, after other amusement parks and the attorney for Knott's Berry Farm expressed their opposition.

After the Christmas Eve accident at Disneyland, the hue and cry for safety regulation has begun anew. Despite prior objections, Disney and Knott's officials seem to have changed their tune.

"We will work with Tom Torlakson or any other legislator or any other members of the industry if that's the case to help craft appropriate legislation," said Ray Gomez, a Disneyland spokesman. "It's something that our guests and public at large are saying would make them more comfortable in coming to a theme park and, if that's the case, then we're willing to support it."

Also in support is Jack Falfas, general manager of Knott's Berry Farm. That park, which also opposed state oversight in the past, was purchased by Ohio-based amusement park company Cedar Fair in late 1997. Falfas helped construct legislation to oversee parks in Ohio while working for the company.

"We have no objections to anything that might enhance our operations and we are interested in the opportunity to review any proposed new programs or procedures," he said in a prepared statement.

While the theme parks say they support "workable" regulations, Torklakson's bill is expected to come up against opposition in the Assembly, especially from Orange County Assemblyman Dick Ackerman, R-Fullerton, who has gone on the record stating he doesn't see the need for great urgency to get involved in regulating amusement parks and objects to adding another layer of bureaucracy under the guise of safety.

Assemblyman George Runner, R-Lancaster, whose district covers the Santa Clarita Valley east of Interstate 5, said although Six Flags California is not in his district, he is wary of legislation that might target amusement parks.

"My first response is that this is sometimes a typical knee-jerk reaction to something that takes place," he said. "I don't know how big of a problem this is in the state of California. It's being talked about again because of the death at Disneyland. My view is to look at major theme parks, such as Six Flags, and see them as pretty safe places. The other issue is that there is a huge difference between traveling setups, such as carnivals, and well-established theme parks. I don't think we need to set up any additional bureaucratic red tape just because it seems to be a fad and it's addressing something that someone might perceive as a problem. I would rather see the facts and see if something like this is really needed."One option is rider responsibility legislation.

"After the waterpark accident, the city of Concord passed a rider responsibility ordinance, which sets guidelines and states that riders have certain responsibilities," said Gartner. "The state has looked at putting something like that into place, but the problem with rider responsibility is, no matter how it's written, consumer attorneys contend it takes all the liability issues away from the park and place them with the consumer."

Assemblyman Curt Pringle, R-Garden Grove, attempted twice to introduce rider responsibility legislation. In 1996, backed by Knott's Berry Farm, he proposed the California Rider Safety Act, which, among other things, would require riders to understand and obey the posted safety rules, behave safely, not be under the influence of drugs or alcohol and not go on any amusement ride unless the rider, or their parents, knows the range and limits of their ability and knows that the requirements of the amusement ride will not exceed their limits. Opposed by the Consumer Attorneys of California, the bill was amended, effectively stripping it of all provisions except allowing amusement parks to detain and eject persons suspected of violating lawful park rules. In that form, it was signed into law by then-Gov. Pete Wilson. In 1997, Pringle, again backed by Knott's Berry Farm, introduced AB1289, which proposed to enact all the rider safety notification provisions of the previous year's bill. The bill died in committee and has not been resubmitted.

"The accident at Disneyland has served as a catalyst for public attention to make some changes. Cal/OSHA's report on Disneyland should be finished, and it appears that employee training and supervision may have prevented the accident," Gartner said. "What we're trying to do is set up a system for safety in theme parks. Right now 35 million people go to theme parks in California every year. The California Research Bureau determined that there are 71 theme parks in California and the two new parks (Legoland in Carlsbad and the expansion of Disneyland) will add another 10 million people. With 14 deaths at amusement parks since 1983, we lead the nation in that area."

Gartner said that Torlakson has received many letters, calls and e-mails of citizen support, as well as backing from places like Pacific Park on the Santa Monica Boardwalk, where the assemblyman announced introduction of AB 850.

"We've heard from someone who had been injured at Knott's Berry Farm and others who had accidents at amusement parks who feel very strongly that reporting should be required," Gartner said. "A woman whose son had his foot crushed on Thunder Mountain at Disneyland contacted us. She said it took them 20 minutes to get him off the ride and an hour to get to the hospital, but she didn't want to sue Disney. She just wanted to make sure Disney changed the ride to make it safer. She realized that even though he wasn't killed, it was still a serious accident. But because they aren't required to report these accidents, Disneyland issued a statement saying they hadn't had a serious accident in four years. People have a right to know when accidents occur. If the ride has a continual problem, the media can report on that and people can be aware of problems, but there's no way of knowing now."

The bill targets four components: accident reporting, regular safety inspections, employee training standards and proof of insurance.

"We are in the process of crafting the specifics of bill language, asking consumer groups as well as safety experts. There are 10 people in California who are pre-eminent safety inspectors for the amusement park industry," Gartner said. "The most critical thing is putting permanent amusement parks into the Amusement Ride Safety Act. We had a choice of putting in some language, but we thought we would rather work with people, asking them their experiences and making it as strong as it can be."

The bill is scheduled to be heard in the Labor and Employment Committee in April.

"We're only one of 12 states in the country that doesn't have oversight," Gartner said. "We have been amazed to hear people tell us they appreciate what we're doing. People are surprised that there is no reporting or regulation. In general, people want less government, but there are times, like in this case, where people expect there would be some sort of state involvement."

← Back to 1999

About this record

How it was held, read and classified

Record details

Morris ID
Not a Morris ID. This record is keyed ts-df:/main/0299/022899a.html.
System
date-file pages (/desk/MMYY/MMDDYY.html)
Reading copy
the-signal.com
Chosen by: only copy held. On this copy: words 2,656 (e-mail addresses counted as one token); reader comments 0 (counted, not reproduced here); images 0.
Extracted by
datefile:SLUG_to_rule
signal-extract/0.15 (2026-11-16)

Other copies

Held
None. The holding has this article from one host only.

How it was classified

Label
clearly-local
Judgment
A machine’s (recorded as machine), kept as one so it can be revisited.
Classifier
signal-localclass/0.7 (2026-11-12)
Local signals
  • url:v2_datefile_main
  • text:valley_names [3 distinct/15 mentions: Santa Clarita, Magic Mountain, Six Flags]
  • byline:named_writer_no_wire_credit [By CAROL ROCK]
  • text:valley_elected_official “George Runner”
National signals
none fired
Scores
local 8, national 0