Transit Mixed Concrete Co. on Monday appealed the Los Angeles County Planning Commission’s denial of the massive mining proposal on Soledad Canyon in Canyon Country and a hearing has been scheduled for May 23.
In filing the appeal, TMCC, a division of Houston-based Southdown Corp., claimed the commission’s denial of the proposed mining was not based on submitted findings or evidence that were presented at the public hearings, “and thus was either made in error or was an abuse of discretion.”
The Planning Commission on Dec. 1, 1999, unanimously voted to deny the project, where 83 million tons of aggregate would be mined from a 460-acre site near Soledad Canyon and Agua Dulce Canyon roads, adjacent to State Route 14. The gravel would be used as a key ingredient in constructing highways and homes.
The project calls for blasting twice weekly during the operation’s first 10 years and four times per week during the second decade.
According to Julie Moore, county regional case planner, the commissioners voted 5-0 because they determined that public health and environmental concerns outweighed the need for concrete aggregate.
In addition, the commissioners said that other aggregate resources are available outside of Los Angeles County that could be considered, even if it means for there would be a higher transportation cost.
Brian Mastin, a spokesman for TMCC, said if the project does not come through with the appeal, there will be higher aggregate transportation costs, which would impede productive construction of schools and roads or other public works.
“If you are going to spend money on transporting rocks you will have less money to do schools,” Mastin said. “You are spending money on transporting materials rather than construction.”
Mastin said the basis for the appeal, which cost $3,458.80, was based on the fact that the findings were not supported by the evidence provided. Also, the project was not found to be consistent with the county’s General Plan, which Mastin disputed because the previous permit would not have been issued if it was not consistent.
Included as a reason for the appeal was that the commission found unacceptable environmental impacts, despite the environmental impact report stating that such impacts on water and air were not significant.
The city of Santa Clarita has committed $120,000, which came from the Council Contingency Fund, to fight the appeal, said Lisa Hardy, planner for the city’s planning and building services.
The City Council has been opposed to the mining project, and last spring the city began establishing an aggressive opposition strategy, which will look at hiring a lobbyist to work with the planning deputies, looking at the economics and how the project will impact the city and surrounding areas, as well as a photo of the mining site, Hardy said.
Alan Cameron, director of Safe Action for the Environment, said that if the truth gets told the board will deny the project. But Cameron is afraid the decision to deny the mining project will be swayed by political and monetary reasons.
“We are going to be telling the truth in an unimpeachable manner,” Cameron said. “When you take on a project like this you can’t (make) wild assumptions. You have to prove what is correct and we can do that. We have the opportunity to win, but it is not going to be easy.”
