SAN FERNANDO— Clutching a tissue and wiping away tears, Sandi Nieves strained to see her son David as he testified against her at North Valley Superior Court Wednesday.
Nieves, 36, is accused of setting a fire on July 1, 1998, which claimed the lives of her four daughters: Nikolet, 12, Rashel, 11, Kristl, 7, and Jaqlene, 5.
Nieves also faces charges of attempted murder of David, who was 14 at the time of the incident.
His face solemn and emotionless, David, who had not seen his mother since the day of the fire, recalled the events leading up to and following the fatal slumber party.
Under direct examination from Deputy District Attorney Beth Silverman, David testified that the slumber party, organized by his mother in the kitchen of their Saugus home, was out of the ordinary and made him feel uncomfortable.
“I didn’t want to sleep in the kitchen,” David said. “She told me that I had to.”
The evening of July 1, David recalled, began with him and his four younger sisters watching movies and eating popcorn on blankets in the kitchen area.
He said he noticed his mother placing wooden dowels in several window sills in the kitchen while the younger girls fell asleep during the movies.
“After I fell asleep, my mom shook me and woke me up,” David recounted. “I was coughing and I couldn’t breathe. There was smoke all around me and it was stinging my nose.”
David remembered asking his mother if they could leave the house and go outside.
“She told me no, because the smoke could be coming from outside,” David testified. “I believed her and I trusted her.”
David also said he found it strange that when his sister, Nikolet, asked Nieves if she could go to the bathroom and vomit, “Mom said no, just to puke next to her.”
David and his sisters then followed Nieves’ instructions to put their faces into the blankets and pillows.
“I thought it would prevent us from breathing in the smoke,” said David.
David testified that he eventually passed out. After regaining consciousness once, David said he noticed that “everything was still.”
On his way to the bathroom, David observed that the carpet, as well as a door and a wall of a bedroom, were burning.
Recalling that he felt dizzy and nauseated, David said he was not able to think clearly at that point.
“My mind was like blank and I didn’t know what to think,” he said.
Before passing out a second time, David saw his sisters’ bodies.
“They were laying still and there was foam coming out of their mouths,” David recalled, expressionless. “I thought they had just been drooling.”
Upon waking a third time, David saw that his sisters were still not moving and his mother was not in the kitchen.
After locating his mother, David said he asked her what had taken place. She did not respond.
Sometime later, the fire department arrived, David said, and informed him of the death of his four little sisters.
“I was shocked,” David recalled.
When asked about a gas can discovered in the converted garage that Nieves used as a bedroom, David testified that it had not been used since the family moved to Santa Clarita.
Under cross examination by defense attorney Howard Waco, David testified that his mother taught the children about honesty and respect, taking them to a local Mormon church on a regular basis and attending church activities.
David said that while living in Santa Clarita, he and his sisters were not allowed to play out front, only in the backyard, and that phone calls and visits to friends were rarely allowed.
David said that after the fire, he told both his father, Fernando Nieves, and police that he did not want to live with his mother.
“After what happened, I didn’t really want to be with her. I had a little clue as to what happened,” he said. “I started piecing things together and thinking things through.”
In the weeks leading up to the fire, David said he saw changes in his mother’s demeanor.
“She was not spending much time with us. She got a new tattoo and she allowed us to dye our hair,” he said.
David, now 15, is scheduled to give more testimony today.
